2KPOP16: SOTY Rate (THE FINAL: ~*WINNER*~) | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

2KPOP16: SOTY Rate (THE FINAL: ~*WINNER*~)

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Squashua, Dec 4, 2016.



  1. [​IMG]


    [​IMG]


    It's been a tough ol' slog this year right? As the rest of the world has been making typically moronic governmental decisions, the usual stable & glossy foundations of K-Pop have also hit a crisis point.

    Twice have been number one for 78 weeks, ShamanUnnie has created an army of devout cult members to run YG towers and impregnate Crayon Pope members and we bid jagbyeol to some of the most influential bands of the "golden age". We shoulda see the writing on the wall considering they've been caught in half-hearted limbos for near-on two years.

    On the flipside, nugus arrived in droves, fresh comebacks from your faves dominated the airwaves and a thousand Produce101 offspring groups were born and laid waste to the idea that K-Pop was over.

    IT AIN'T. FAR FROM IT CYSTREN.

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]


    The standard is sky-high

    The beats are louder.

    The choreo goes harder.

    The EXO-stans are perched
    to throw BTS under the bus kii.


    FORGET THE MAMAS AND THE MELONS,

    PJ HAS THE FINAL SAY


    [​IMG]


    ~~~ HOW IT ALL WORKS ~~~

    Like an idol caught in a ahjumma shaking scandal, I have been learning from my mistakes and will do better for the nation's producers.
    All the songs & groups chosen will be DOWN TO YOU.

    [​IMG]


    THE LONGLIST DRAFT

    Please choose a ballot of 13 SONGS that defined 2016 for you
    + 3 bonus slots for album tracks you love
    That's 13 for this year's bad luck, 16 to celebrate kii.

    There are however conditions:

    Only ONE SONG PER ARTIST (to make it fairer)
    Album tracks can be from any release this year
    OSTs and Japanese releases are allowed
    95% of sub-units will not be considered as separate artists
    (e.g. EXO-CBX is still under EXO, I.O.I with less members is still I.O.I
    NCT is one of the exceptions to this rule)


    If a song gets THREE VOTES = Auto-qualifier for the Final
    All other songs = through to the semis


    THE SEMIS

    The semis will feature all songs that received 1 or 2 votes in the Prelim ballots.
    The voting will be EUROVISION STYLE to make it speedy.
    i.e. you give one song a 12, one song gets 10, then scores of 8-1 from best to worst.


    THE FINAL

    All songs that successfully qualify will compete in a standard out-of-10 rate for the crown of the best song of 2016.
    Simples.

    ******

    Need some help/divine inspiration in deciding?

    [​IMG] [​IMG]

    Here's a text list of all the releases this year
    Here's 100 of Korea's faves in audio/visual form:


    Please use @Slice of Life 's 2016 discussion thread safezone to mull over your potential options and choices with your fellow sassy gurrls.

    I will be awaiting which combatants you choose as tribute, PJ sub-unit.

    Yours truly,

    SQUASH x

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Mar 17, 2017

  2. [​IMG]


    THE SEMIS

    [​IMG]


    Below we have four groups randomly selected to face one another. Your task is to deem which songs deserve a shot at the big time by scoring them in a Eurovision-esque style.

    In our edition scoring goes as follows:

    1 song will get your 10 points
    1 song will get your 8 points
    Then six more songs get the points 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 & 1.


    That's 8 songs of your choice
    meaning only 8 songs with the most points per Heats 1 - 3 will go through.

    Heat 4 will only have 6 songs go through
    meaning the scores follow a six to one format (6 points-5-4-3-2-1)


    SEMI-FINAL 1
    Playlist


    Qualifiers
    KARD - Oh NaNa (88)
    Berry Good - Don't Believe (64)
    Ladies' Code - Galaxy (61)
    Produce 101 - In the Same Place (54)
    Sistar x Moroder - One More Day (53)
    Jun Hyo Seong - Find Me (50)
    Snuper - Platonic Love (50)
    Taemin - Press Your Number (39)


    *****************************
    9th ~ Fiestar - Mirror (31)
    10th ~ Produce 101 - Fingertips (30)
    11th ~ Red Velvet - One of These Nights (30)
    12th ~ EXO - Lucky One (24)
    13th ~ Jessica - Wonderland (24)
    14th ~ A.DE - Good Time (21)
    15th ~ UP10TION - Attention (19)
    16th ~ Hoody - Like You (17)
    17th ~ AOA Cream - I'm Jelly Baby (14)
    18th ~ BTS - Forever Young (13)
    19th ~ Lee Hi - Breathe (12)
    20th ~ MIXX - Oh Ma Mind (11)
    21st ~ Monsta X - All In (11)
    22nd ~ INFINITE - The Eye (8)
    23rd ~ KNK - U (8)
    24th ~ FT Island - Take Me Now (6)
    25th ~ Hobby & Gain - Dollar (3)





    SEMI-FINAL 2
    Playlist


    Qualifiers
    Blackpink - Boombayah (89)
    Dal*Shabet - FRI.SAT.SUN (78)
    Fei - Fantasy (61)
    4MINUTE - Canvas (59)
    AOA - Good Luck (49)
    CocoSori - Exquisite! (36)
    SeoYuri - Secret (34)
    Matilda - You Bad! Don't Make Me Cry (32)


    *****************************
    9th ~ I.O.I - Whatta Man (31)
    10th ~ Dorothy - Purple Lips (28)
    11th ~ LiVii/Alice Vicious - Luna (28)
    12th ~ Gain - Carnival (27)
    13th ~ Gu9udan - Wonderland (25)
    14th ~ Taemin - Sayonara Hitori (23)
    15th ~ HyunA - How's This? (22)
    16th ~ NCT Dream - Chewing Gum (19)
    17th ~ Lee Hi - Hold My Hand (18)
    18th ~ Cosmic Girls - MoMoMo (16)
    19th ~ Nu'est - Overcome (13)
    20th ~ Momoland - Jjan! Koon! Kwang! (12)
    21st ~ D.O - Tell Me [What Is Love] (10)
    22nd ~ B.A.P - Skydive (8)
    23rd ~ Heize - Star (8)
    24th ~ WINNER - Baby Baby (6)
    25th ~ 100% - Better Day (5)
    26th ~ Boyfriend - Jackpot (4)


    SEMI-FINAL 3
    Playlist


    Qualifiers
    SHINee - 1 of 1 (78)
    EXID - L.I.E (65)
    Stellar - Crying (59)
    I.O.I - Crush (52)
    Blackpink - Stay (45)
    Rainbow - Whoo (40)
    EXO - Monster (40)
    B.A.P - Feels So Good (36)


    *****************************
    9th ~ f(x) - All Mine (35)
    10th ~ Taemin - Drip Drop (34)
    11th ~ Berry Good - Angel (32)
    12th ~ Hyomin - Gold (28)
    13th ~ Fiestar - Apple Pie (27)
    14th ~ VIXX - Dynamite (27)
    15th ~ BTS - Save Me (22)
    16th ~ C.I.V.A - Why Do You Call (20)
    17th ~ Akdong Musician - How People Move (17)
    18th ~ JYPark - Fire (16)
    19th ~ Kim Sejeong - Flower Road (15)
    20th ~ NCT U - The 7th Sense (14)
    21st ~ Hyoyeon- Mystery (12)
    22nd ~ B14A - A Lie (10)
    23rd ~ Meng Jia - Drip (8)
    24th ~ Hyolyn - Paradise (7)
    25th ~ MASC - Strange (4)
    26th ~ SF9 - Fanfare (3)


    SEMI-FINAL 4: Album Tracks
    Playlist


    Qualifiers
    EXID - Cream (34)
    Oh My Girl - 1 Step 2 Steps (29)
    Wonder Girls - To The Beautiful You (28)
    SHINee - Prism (19)
    GFriend - Gone With The Wind (17)
    Gu9udan - Diary (17)


    *****************************
    7th ~ EXO - Artificial Love (16)
    8th ~ Luna - Keep On Doin' (15)
    9th ~ Stellar - Insomnia (15)
    10th ~ Brave Girls - Help Me (14)
    11th ~ Brave Girls - Whatever (14)
    12th ~ Gain - Secret (14)
    13th ~ Oh My Girl - Knock Knock (14)
    14th ~ Jonghyun - Moon (13)
    15th ~ TWICE - Countdown (13)
    16th ~ 4MINUTE - No Love (11)
    17th ~ MAMAMOO - Words Don't Come Easy (11)
    18th ~ Taemin - Soldier (10)
    19th ~ IBI - IBI (9)
    20th ~ GFriend - Distance (7)
    21st ~ Taeyeon - Good Thing (7)
    22nd ~ Lovelyz - 1cm (6)
    23rd ~ BTS - Awake (5)
    24th ~ B14A - Nightmare (2)
    25th ~ Yezi & Co - Se Se Se (2)
    26th ~ INFINITE - Air (0)



    [​IMG]


     
    Last edited: Mar 24, 2017
  3. [​IMG]


    60 MEGA-HITS
    ONE MONSTER RATE





    THE FULL COMPLETE PLAYLIST



    ..::RESULTS::..





    GOLD
    Dal*Shabet - Someone Like U (9.65)
    [​IMG]


    SILVER
    Wonder Girls - Why So Lonely (9.60)
    [​IMG]


    BRONZE
    Luna - Free Somebody (9.03)
    [​IMG]

    4
    Stellar

    Sting (8.93)

    5
    GFriend

    Rough (8.90)

    6

    Red Velvet
    Russian Roulette (8.83)


    7

    TWICE
    TT (8.73)


    8
    Cosmic Girls
    Secret (8.50)

    9
    Oh My Girl
    Windy Day (8.38)

    10
    Ladies' Code
    Galaxy (8.33)



    11. Ladies' Code - The Rain (8.30)
    12. Sistar - I Like That (8.28)
    13. Sunny Girls - Taxi (8.25)
    14. Wonder Girls - To The Beautiful You (8.25, less 10s)
    15. GFriend - Navillera (8.18)

    [​IMG]

    16. Blackpink - Playing With Fire (8.15)
    17. MAMAMOO - Decalcomanie (8.15, no 11)
    18. KARD - Oh NaNa (8.03)
    19. Crayon Pop - Doo Doom Chit (8.00)
    20. Fei - Fantasy (7.98)

    21. Brave Girls - High Heels (7.95)
    22. Dal*Shabet - FRI.SAT.SUN (7.90)
    23. Brave Girls - Deepened (7.85)
    24. Tiffany - I Just Wanna Dance (7.80)
    25. Stellar - Crying (7.78)
    26. Oh My Girl - Liar Liar (7.75)
    27. Berry Good - Don't Believe (7.73)
    28. EXID - Cream (7.63)
    29. SeoYuri - Secret (7.60)
    30. Produce 101 - In the Same Place (7.58, more 10s)

    [​IMG]

    31. Snuper - Platonic Love (7.58)
    32. SHINee - 1 of 1 (7.55)
    33. TWICE - Cheer Up (7.53)
    34. AOA - 10 Seconds (7.50)
    35. Luna - Galaxy (7.48)
    36. Taemin - Press Your Number (7.43)
    37. Sistar x Moroder - One More Day (7.30)
    38. Blackpink - Boombayah (7.28)
    39. SEVENTEEN - Very Nice (7.25)
    40. Jun Hyo Seong - Find Me (7.20, has an 11)

    41. Taeyeon - Why (7.20, more tens)
    42. Tiffany - Heartbreak Hotel (7.20, less 10s)
    43. Rainbow - Whoo (7.18)
    44. SHINee - Prism (7.10)
    45. EXID - L.I.E (7.05)
    46. BTS - Blood, Sweat & Tears (7.03)
    47. Tiffany - Talk (6.93)
    48. 4Minute - Hate (6.88)
    49. 4Minute - Canvas (6.85)
    50. EXO - Monster (6.73)

    51. I.O.I - Crush (6.70)
    52. Oh My Girl - 1 Step, 2 Steps (6.58)
    53. B.A.P - Feel So Good (6.55)
    54. Lovelyz - Destiny (6.43)
    55. Matilda - You Bad! Don't Make Me Cry (6.38)
    56. AOA - Good Luck (6.28)
    57. GFriend - Gone With The Wind (6.18)
    58. Gu9udan - Diary (5.35)
    59. CocoSori - Exquisite! (5.10, has an 11)
    60. Blackpink - Stay (5.10)



     
    Last edited: Mar 30, 2017
  4. [​IMG]

    SHAMAN UNNIE SHOULD BE THE CENTER!!1!!1

    Kii. Anyway, I AM BEYOND PERCHED. Let me be very strategic with my song choices. Bring. It. On.
     
  5. Congratulations in advance to Gfriend's Rough, which wins Best Song of 2016 regardless of what anyone on forum.popjustice.com tells you.

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
     
    McQueer, Slice of Life and Squashua like this.
  6. This will go as smoothly as Syria's peace talks and I can't wait.
     
  7.  
  8. IOI ruined it.
     
  9. [​IMG]
     
    D is for Danger! likes this.
  10. Question, cyst @Squashua. What if I don't love enough album tracks? Can all my 16 songs be just singles instead? Also with the one-artist rule, this applies to both singles and album tracks, right? Like, I can't vote for both I.O.I's Very Very Very and Hold Up, for example?

    Anyway, I'm now listening to my 5-hour 2016 K-pop singles playlist and deciding which 16 songs to choose is messing me up. HELP.
     
    send photo likes this.
  11. Definitely taking part in this even though I probably wouldn't be able to name 13 songs on the spot. This rate should be a nice place to discover songs I haven't heard yet, I think.
     
  12. It's 13 singles max with an optional bonus 14th/15th/16th for album cuts. I'd keep some reserves on the singles front though because there's every chance they will be summoned anyway.

    Album tracks can be from any artist even if you picked them in your singles. So Veryx3 and Hold On would both be allowed on the same ballot.
     
    Slice of Life likes this.
  13. I've been way too absent from K-pop in 2016 but maybe this can bring me back into the fold. I'll probably jump in when the semis start to see what others have selected, as I haven't paid close enough attention this year to help with the draft.
     
    Slice of Life and Squashua like this.
  14. YATH! Better prepare for another Oh My Girl stanning from me, cyst. Kii.
     
  15. Can I send you my other favorite songs that will not make my Top 16 though and then have you enter them as your ballot? Kii. I'm kidding, cyst @Squashua. Don't kill me.

    I'm only half-kidding though.
     
    send photo likes this.
  16. By all means shoot those reserves over too, they may well get their moment in the spotlight... *giggles*

    [​IMG]
     
    send photo and Slice of Life like this.
  17. PERCHEDt!

    **Edited to ask: So how are we doing this Produce 101 thing? Do we count Crush as a PD101 single or I.O.I. album cut? Could we include "In The Same Place" and "24 Hours" since they are different groups? What are we to do?
     
    Last edited: Dec 5, 2016
  18. A toughie but I think we go with anything from the show (basically the 35 girls 5 concepts songs that were released) as one artist and anything that has appeared on an I.O.I album/EP as I.O.I. Hopefully that makes sense?

    [​IMG]

    Also I never set a date!

    How does December 14th/15th sound for the ballots with the Semis vote open over Christmas?
     
    send photo, Ceir and Slice of Life like this.
  19. So if it's 1 per artist and Produce 101 is one artist, we couldn't have In The Same Place and Pick Me?
     
  20. From what I understand, the team that sang In The Same Place is one group. So I think you can vote for both songs?
     
    send photo likes this.