Big Pop Girls 2016 VS Rate - COMPLETE | Page 420 | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Big Pop Girls 2016 VS Rate - COMPLETE

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by RJF, Dec 5, 2016.

  1. [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]


    (Thanks so much @RJF, it was such a great ride. The effort, the commentaries, the dragging was all 100%)
     
  2. K94

    K94

    Quelle surprise.
     
  3. Yet you couldn't have given Formation more than a 6? @Slice of Life

    [​IMG]
     
  4. RJF

    RJF

    TOP 5 (POINTS)

    1. Into You - 1366.5
    2. Kiss It Better - 1344.5
    3. Formation - 1339.5
    4. All Night - 1287.5
    5. Sorry - 1284
     
  5. Solenciennes

    Solenciennes Moderator

    @RJF stub your cigarette out on me thank you for this rate
     
  6. RJF

    RJF

    Here is the spreadsheet too. You'll find how the leaderboard changed through the voting on the second page of it. The number of voters as at the bottom of each leaderboard.
     
  7. Thank you so much for this @RJF made a bleak January fly by xx
     
  8. RJF

    RJF

    LEADERBOARD

    1. Into You - 9.831
    2. Kiss It Better - 9.673
    3. Formation - 9.637
    4. All Night - 9.263
    5. Sorry - 9.237
    6. Touch It - 9.209
    7. Love On The Brain - 9.137
    8. Thinking Bout You - 8.824
    9. Needed Me - 8.809
    10. Slumber Party - 8.799
    11. Freedom - 8.759
    12. Same Ol' Mistakes - 8.699
    13. 6 Inch (Feat. The Weeknd) - 8.629
    14. Hold Up - 8.626
    15. Dancin' In Circles - 8.622
    16. Knew Better / Forever Boy - 8.619
    17. Side To Side (Feat. Nicki Minaj) - 8.615
    18. If I'm Dancing - 8.439
    19. Everyday (Feat. Future) - 8.435
    20. Diamond Heart - 8.421
    21. John Wayne - 8.417
    22. Make Me...(Feat. G-Eazy) - 8.403
    23. Pray You Catch Me - 8.385
    24. Don't Hurt Yourself - 8.378
    25. Consideration (Feat. SZA) - 8.356
    26. Work (Feat. Drake) - 8.353
    27. Daddy Lessons - 8.309
    28. Joanne - 8.284
    29. Perfect Illusion - 8.281
    30. A-YO - 8.255
    31. Greedy - 8.191
    32. Do You Wanna Come Over? - 8.187
    33. Bad Decisions - 8.162
    34. Man On The Moon - 8.097
    35. Desperado - 8.018
    36. Change Your Mind (No Seas Cortés) - 8.011
    37. Million Reasons - 8.004
    38. Dangerous Woman - 7.982
    39. Be Alright - 7.903
    40. Sometimes - 7.881
    41. Mood Ring - 7.853
    42. Moonlight - 7.802
    43. Angel Down - 7.766
    44. Love Drought - 7.759
    45. Close To You - 7.752
    46. Invitation - 7.723
    47. Just Luv Me - 7.662
    48. Grigio Girls - 7.568
    49. Never Ending - 7.547
    50. Let Me Love You (Feat. Lil Wayne) - 7.511
    51. Sinner's Prayer - 7.457
    52. Hey Girl (Feat. Florence Welch) - 7.453
    53. Liar - 7.421
    54. Love Me Down - 7.349
    55. Come To Mama - 7.248
    56. Yeah, I Said It - 7.241
    57. Better - 7.133
    58. Higher - 7.04
    59. Sandcastles - 6.946
    60. Coupure Électrique - 6.874
    61. Hard To Forget Ya - 6.849
    62. Just Like Me - 6.824
    63. Sex With Me - 6.784
    64. James Joint - 6.759
    65. Woo - 6.665
    66. Just Another Day - 6.209
    67. Leave Me Lonely (Feat. Macy Gray) - 6.004
    68. I Don't Care - 5.888
    69. Focus - 5.831
    70. Clumsy - 5.683
    71. What You Need - 5.46
    72. Forward (Feat. James Blake) - 5.45
    73. Step On Up - 5.284
    74. Private Show - 5.27
    75. Jason's Song (Gave It Away) - 5.216
    76. Pose - 5.064
    77. Rise - 3.928
    78. Goodnight Gotham - 3.817​
     
  9. 'Into You' is a truly brilliant song and deserves all the accolades and superlatives thrown at it and I suppose Ariana pulls it off amazingly as well.

    It's tiring just seeing all these results, so much hard work was put into this and we are all very grateful. Congrats on another stellar rate @RJF!
     
    RJF likes this.
  10. @RJF This was an amazing rate! Thank you so much for putting in all the work between your drinking breaks!
     
    johnny_tsunami and RJF like this.
  11. I mean, honestly, with a top 3 like that there really are no losers. I'd have been happy with whatever the outcome.

    Thanks @RJF for making this iconic as always, and letting the gherls make fools of themselves along the way.
     
  12. RJF

    RJF

    OH CHRIST 200 notifications nope I'm going for a bath.
     
    BML, DJHazey, Slice of Life and 17 others like this.
  13. @RJF in during said bath

    [​IMG]
     
    BML, Slice of Life, evilsin and 13 others like this.
  14. [​IMG]
     
    BEST FICTION likes this.
  15. I love that Touch It and Knew Better/Forever Boy were two of Ari’s highest tracks, I don’t count them as bonus tracks when we have Leave Me Lonely.
     
  16. “Into You” feels to me like the least among all the AAA Pop Behemoths of the last few years (I’m counting “Drunk In Love”, “Style” and “Run Away With Me”) and I personally connect a bit more with the stuporous longing in “Kiss It Better”, but they’re both absolutely fantastic songs and that’s a fine and worthy finish.

    Thanks again, @RJF, for running this towering, messy, apocalyptic beast. I’m still a little bit in shock at how rapidly things escalated as it raced towards the finish but you kept, abetted and cooled things so judiciously; the result being a rate that was truly iconic. You also highlighted in beautiful detail the new, interesting directions these ladies are headed in, which makes the future of mainstream pop seem really exciting indeed.
     
    K94, Mr Blonde, aaronhansome and 12 others like this.
  17. Solenciennes

    Solenciennes Moderator

    This seems like Ariana's promo strategy for Into You
     
    Last edited: Jan 24, 2017
  18. This rate was the definition of The Most in the best (and occasionally worst nn) way possible, and @RJF honestly, truly can't be thanked enough for the hours of dedication he's put into the most time-and-effort-consuming rate in PJ history, all for the amusement of this ramshackle group of messy queens, and throughout the dreariness of January too! So massive thanks, king.

    Also...
    [​IMG]
     
  19. As disastrous as many of the results were, the ending felt rather...inevitable. It was a perfect top 3 and by the time it gets to that point we're just celebrating greatness.

    Thanks for the immense time and effort you dedicated to this @RJF. It feels right to send off one of the best years in pop music since the turn of the century with this amount of fanfare and we wouldn't have been able to do so without you.
     
  20. RJF

    RJF

    There is a far more... more version of that "Kiss It Better" paragraph ddd.