Girl Groups Debut Singles Rate (#25) | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Girl Groups Debut Singles Rate (#25)

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Alouder98, May 4, 2017.

  1. Hana, du, se, annyeong haseyo, naneun Aloudereu da.


    [​IMG]



    In the last 10 years more than 100 girl groups have debuted (we're not rating all of them, though) and they have all made the crazy world of K-Pop. We know most these groups have changed their concepts or their line-ups during the years (except the never change cystren of K-Pop '' A Pink'' and a few others who have never got the chance to live more than two comebacks'', some of them improved and gave us great discographies , some of them went on a downhill and never came back and some of them disbanded because of their shitty agencies and many other dramas in this iconic side of the world. But it's not the time to discuss those things, we are here to decide which group started better. Who came with a banger and who came with a cheap shitty single and deserves the dragging of this forum?



    What songs are we going to rate?


    The Legends (2000s)

    [​IMG]




    Renaissance Of K-Pop (2010-2013)

    [​IMG]

    Miss A - Good Girl, Bad Girl
    Sistar - Push Push
    Nine Muses - No Playboy
    Girl's Day - Tilt My Head
    Dalshabet - Supa Dupa Diva
    Apink - I Don't Know
    Rania - Dr Feel Good
    Brave Girls - Do You Know
    Stellar - Rocket Girl
    EXID - Who's That Girl
    Crayon Pope - Bing Bing
    AOA - Elvis
    Spica - Russian Roulette
    Tahiti - Tonight
    Hello Venus - Venus
    Fiestar - Vista
    Ladies Code - Bad Girl
    Wassup - Wassup
    GI - Beatles
    BESTie - Pitapat



    Newbies (2014 - 2017)

    [​IMG]


    MAMAMOO - Mr. Ambiguous

    Sonamoo - Deja Vu
    Berry Good - Love Letter
    Purfles - 1 2 3
    Red Velvet - Happiness
    Lovelyz - Candy Jelly Love
    Laboum - Pit-A-Pat
    GFriend - Glass Bead
    Twice - Like Ooh Aah
    Oh My Girl - Cupid
    CLC - Pepe
    April - Dream Candy
    DIA - Somehow
    Blackpink - Whistle
    Cosmic Girls - Mo Mo Mo
    Momoland - "JJan! Koong! Kwang
    Gugudan - Wonderland
    Dream Catcher - Chase Me
    PRISTIN - Wee Woo




    Rules


    - Rate all the songs with a score between 0 - 10
    - Only one song may receive your 11 as your favorite song
    - Decimals are allowed
    - Commentary is encouraged and appreciated!
    - Please use the pm-able list in the next post


    Deadline is June 25, seven weeks from now.


    My mid-term exams will start next week and I have my final exams next month until deadline, so forgive me if I'm keeping it short and simple. And please vote.

    [​IMG]

     
    Last edited: Jul 7, 2017
  2. What's left?



    The Legends


    Brown Eyed Girls - Come Closer
    KARA - Break It
    Wonder Girls - Irony
    SNSD - Into The New World
    T-ara - Lie
    After School - AH!

    Secret - I Want You Back
    Rainbow - Gossip Girl

    2NE1 - Fire
    4Minute - Hot Issue

    F(x) - La Cha Ta



    Renaissance


    Miss A - Good Girl, Bad Girl
    Sistar - Push Push
    Nine Muses - No Playboy

    Girl's Day - Tilt My Head
    Dalshabet - Supa Dupa Diva
    Apink - I Don't Know
    Rania - Dr Feel Good
    Brave Girls - Do You Know
    Stellar - Rocket Girl
    EXID - Who's That Girl

    Crayon Pope - Bing Bing
    AOA - Elvis
    Spica - Russian Roulette

    Tahiti - Tonight
    Hello Venus - Venus
    Fiestar - Vista
    Ladies Code - Bad Girl

    Wassup - Wassup
    GI - Beatles
    BESTie - Pitapat




    Newbies



    MAMAMOO - Mr. Ambiguous
    Sonamoo - Deja Vu
    Berry Good - Love Letter

    Red Velvet - Happiness
    Lovelyz - Candy Jelly Love
    Purfles - 1 2 3
    Laboum - Pit-A-Pat
    GFriend - Glass Bead
    Twice - Like Ooh Aah
    Oh My Girl - Cupid

    CLC - Pepe
    April - Dream Candy
    DIA - Somehow

    Blackpink - Whistle
    Cosmic Girls - Mo Mo Mo
    Momoland - "JJan! Koong! Kwang
    Gugudan - Wonderland

    Dream Catcher - Chase Me
    PRISTIN - Wee Woo




     
    Last edited: Jul 25, 2017 at 5:24 PM
    Rainbow Trousers and send photo like this.
  3. Please add Wassup and their debut single, the cleverly titled, Wassup to the 2010-2013 list. They're still active, so they deserve to be there.
     
    Alouder98 likes this.
  4. Would it be possible to include both of Blackpink's debut songs? I'd give Boombayah a higher score.
     
    Alouder98 and junglefish like this.
  5. I can't believe the contenders for my 11 are Twice, Dreamcatcher and Blackpink.
     
  6. I'm ready to hate you all and your flop decisions.
     
  7. Honestly, I could list so many groups, but I don't think we'd ever finish. We should disqualify groups that only released one song or not active in the last year or so. We left out Pocket Girls and i-Ren. The others don't really stand a chance if we'd include them.
     
  8. I was ready to come in and stan for the classics but their debuts are, for the most part... not their best. It'll be an interesting rate to say the least.
     
    Mikl C, Alouder98 and Slice of Life like this.
  9. Wonder Girls and f(x) have some of my favorite albums ever but then you listen... to... their... debut... songs....
     
  10. Debut songs in general are... a choice.

    There's a handful here I already know & have a lot of time for but I'm more than apprensive to actually put myself through many of the ones I had tried to avoid until now.
     
    Alouder98 and Ceir like this.
  11. Into The New World should win... but it won't.
     
    Alouder98 and LOOΠΔ like this.
  12. Glass Bead could win and it would still be the same thing.
     
  13. IRONY or bust.

    This is gonna get bloody.
     
    McQueer and Alouder98 like this.
  14. As always, please harass me before the deadline @Alouder98 boo. I'm always so busy right now so I can't participate in rates as much as I used to but this is too good a rate to be missed.

    I'm ready to kill.
     
  15. Recycled jokes already and it's only the first page.
     
  16. I'm gonna rate Bing Bing pretty high anyway but I wish we were rating Saturday Night for the Pope instead... an easy 11.
     
    Slice of Life and Alouder98 like this.
  17. Don't be shady about my non-ironic 10 for No Playboy, hens.