Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Alouder98, Jan 20, 2017.
"4minute slut" is probably more iconic than all of our faves' careers combined so let's not!
I mean Volume Up already happened. What are y'all on about?
Not related to the current discussion at all but: I wish we could do discography rates for acts that are active, like we do in the main forum. For example Red Velvet have enough amount of songs and a discography worthy of having their own rate, I don't get why we should wait like 5 years for them to disband so we can run a rate for them.
Because in the span of the rate being created, votes being sent in, and the rate being completed the group could've announced a comeback, had it, and already gone back to solo promotions.
Kpop just moves too fast. And the discographies aren't as extensive as say..Koda Kumi, who needs multiple parts.
Also a Red Velvet rate would kill me. Choosing an 11 isn't possible.
Well then we can have a rate 3-4 years later too, like what people do in the main forum. It's better than not having a rate for them at all.
Didn't the SNSD Singles rate happen over a year before SNSD... ended up in possible limbo?
It was obviously only singles, but it was obviously done because they had a huge amount of singles.
I don't see why that same logic couldn't be applied to acts with large discographies, like say having over 50+ tracks released (see: EXO, Red Velvet), or who have been around for a substantial amount of time (SHINee, f(x)).
Red Velvet - 52+ Songs
SHINee - 158+ Songs (including Japan releases)
f(x) - 58+ Songs
EXO - 83+ Songs (including EXO-CBX)
Most of those are substantial enough songs to rate for each act.
Let me help you out.
We may as well just do f(x).
We still have so many girl groups that disbanded that don't have a rate KARA, Rainbow, Miss A, 4Minute, Spica, T-ara
Luckily we'll never have SNSD Discography rate because SM doesn't disband their groups but imagine having to rate their 200 songs
Oh also another random thought: I think it would be good if someone runs a rate for JYP solo girls after Yubin and Suzy release their albums. We will have enough songs by then:
Sunmi : Full Moon + non-album singles
Yenny : Me? + non-album singles
Suzy : Yes No Maybe? + new album
Fei : Fantasy
Yubin : upcoming album
Jia : the single she released last month.
Sis I've been saying for half an year that I want to run their discography rate this Summer. How did you miss my never-ending promos?
For real though, don't worry. It will be a selected discography rate and I'll make sure the list won't be longer than 50-60 songs.
Prepare for 'Why is _______ not here' comments ddd, i'll make sure to participate
This is the worst part of running rates nn. I'm thinking of including all of their Japanese songs (23 songs if I counted correctly) and then doing a pre-rate for their Korean songs.
Or maybe I include the albums that are popular among the fans (my own faves actually, hehe) like The Boys, Holiday Night and Lion Heart and then only pick well-known/popular songs from the other albums.
Just ditch the ballads.
You mean all of their pre-2011 albums?
Okay this is a good idea as well. I will consider it.
Actually yes do that as well but include Genie (Japanese obv) and Hoot.
I'm going through Won Prize threads and...wow, we made so many choices, fam.
Separate names with a comma.