The problem of Tina is that she tried so hard to break away from her S Club image that she tried different music genres, from hip-hop to pop, to funk-soul. I think she has even tried rock. She got confused and didn't find her own music identity. When it came to release independently her music, she chose to remix her songs, release some poor remixes, kill her own songs, and lose the little credibility she had. And now, the most ironic thing is that she is back with S Club 3 and she was one of the members who needed the reunion of 2015. With a better guidance, I am confident she could have delivered something better.