Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by Ironheade, Mar 3, 2018.
... Haven't we been losing more R&B than anything else though (other than Rap/Hip Hop)?
I would say we've been losing more pop-rock than anything because PJ is allergic to guitars.
I hope it's another peppy rock song tbh.
Take A Bow is the only song I strongly dislike that's left, but also am I right in thinking Tubthumping is still in? How the hell did that happen?
Not just me!
Are Diddy-Diddys still in? Please remove xx
Let's just kick out boring songs. I don't care what genre they are!
I'm sorry but Tubthumping deserves Top 10 in this rate, unfortunately you heathens will kick out pretty soon won't you?
When the list first went up for the rate, Tubthumping immediately struck me as likely the most divisive song on there. It's done well to get this far, but I suspect that the people who hate it really hate it and that will be its downfall.
There are some female vocals in it.
Dddd, okay then don't get upset when it's Low Scorer: @DJHazey for a lot of the R&B yet to be eliminated.
I thought you said you gave them all 7s? You won't be!
Haha, no I gave a couple 7s but yeah not even close to all of them.
Where do you stand on 'Bills, Bills, Bills'? Definitely one of the lesser Destiny's Child singles but I feel like it'll go a bit far just because it's them.
Dddd, that's one of the 7s.
Semi Charmed Life and Sunny Came Home were lowkey some of the best songs in this rate.
Big songs I could see going at this stage, whether I'd like it or not:
Take a Bow
Kiss From a Rose
Un-Break My Heart
I'll Be Missing You
Mo Money Mo Problems
Truly Madly Deeply
My Heart Will Go On
Going bold here: I don't think there's any chance Un-Break My Heart goes this early, in fact I think it's probably in a race with Don't Speak for the last ballad standing.
You're probably not far off with the rest, although there's plenty on the list I'd be happy not to lose.
Tubthumping just seems really "laddy" to me, and I don't know how many people on this forum have ever been accused of being a "lad".
Separate names with a comma.