The Born This Way | Teenage Dream | Warrior 2nd Eras Rate - WINNER REVEALED! | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

The Born This Way | Teenage Dream | Warrior 2nd Eras Rate - WINNER REVEALED!

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by ThisIsRogue, May 8, 2017.

  1. [​IMG]


    Gaga. Katy. Kesha. Rare creatures from a rare time in pop music that saw them burst into our lives with earth-shattering smash hits. Their debuts reflected each artists' points-of-view, delivered in their own unique styles. The Katy, Kesha, Gaga First Eras Rate that was hosted last year gave us the opportunity to assess their debut efforts. Gaga was the clear victor, occupying the top 3 spots. Kesha held her own with 5 songs in the top 10. Poor Katy, however only managed to scrape one song into the top 10.

    As we've seen time and time again in pop music, an artist's sophomore effort is almost as crucial as their debut if they want to achieve longevity. It's their opportunity to consolidate their position in the pop music landscape. The road to the pantheon of Big Pop Girls™ is paved with unfulfilled potential and one-hit wonders. Gaga and Kesha may have softened the impact of a sophomore slump with The Fame Monster and Cannibal, but those releases are still firmly tied to their successful parent albums. In pop music, there's always a risk of flopping, even when your material is good.

    So, what did these ladies deliver us with their sophomore efforts, was it as good as what they provided us with their debuts and was it good enough to cement their status in pop music? You be the judge.



    THE RULES
    • Rate each song on a scale of 0 - 10.
    • Part points are allowed, but only to 1 decimal place.
    • You may award one song the coveted 11/10. Your justification for awarding this is up to you. You can simply award it to your favourite song, or award it to another song that you love, but feel is under-rated.
    • These ladies can be quite polarising, as observed in the First Eras rate, so I'll be on the lookout for any ballots that are trolling. Please be reasonable with your votes.
    • Commentary to go with your scores is welcome, encouraged and will very much be appreciated, not only by myself but also by your fellow voters.


    THE SONGS

    We're looking at these artists' second album eras, so this includes songs on re-releases such as Teenage Dream: The Complete Confection.

    Also, to hopefully save any confusion, any songs where there's an alternate version due to the addition of a featured artist or an artist produced remix, have also been listed beside the album version. You do not need to submit separate scores for each version of the same song.



    Lady Gaga: Born This Way

    [​IMG]

    <Spotify | Youtube>

    1. Marry The Night
    2. Born This Way / Born This Way [The Country Road Version]
    3. Government Hooker
    4. Judas
    5. Americano
    6. Hair
    7. Scheiße
    8. Bloody Mary
    9. Black Jesus ✝ Amen Fashion
    10. Bad Kids
    11. Fashion of His Love
    12. Highway Unicorn (Road to Love)
    13. Heavy Metal Lover
    14. Electric Chapel
    15. The Queen
    16. You and I / You and I [Jazz Version]
    17. The Edge of Glory



    Katy Perry: Teenage Dream

    [​IMG]

    <Spotify | Youtube>

    1. Teenage Dream
    2. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) / Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) featuring Missy Elliott
    3. California Gurls featuring Snoop Dogg
    4. Firework
    5. Peacock
    6. Circle The Drain
    7. The One That Got Away / The One That Got Away [Acoustic Version]
    8. E.T. / E.T. featuring Kanye West
    9. Who Am I Living For?
    10. Pearl
    11. Hummingbird Heartbeat
    12. Not Like The Movies
    13. Part of Me
    14. Wide Awake
    15. Dressin' Up



    Kesha - Warrior

    [​IMG]

    <Spotify | Youtube>

    1. Warrior
    2. Die Young / Die Young [Deconstructed Remix]
    3. C'Mon
    4. Thinking of You
    5. Crazy Kids / Crazy Kids featuring Will.I.Am
    6. Wherever You Are
    7. Dirty Love featuring Iggy Pop
    8. Wonderland
    9. Only Wanna Dance With You
    10. Supernatural / Supernatural [Deconstructed Remix]
    11. All That Matters (The Beautiful Life)
    12. Love Into the Light
    13. Last Goodbye
    14. Gold Trans Am
    15. Out Alive
    16. Past Lives



    VOTING IS OPEN UNTIL MONDAY, JUNE 5TH FRIDAY, JUNE 9TH
    7am US EST / 12pm BST / 9pm AEST CLOSED
     
    Last edited: Jun 13, 2017
    soratami, Serg., mokitsu and 13 others like this.
  2. Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    1. Marry The Night
    2. Born This Way
    3. Government Hooker
    4. Judas
    5. Americano
    6. Hair
    7. Scheiße
    8. Bloody Mary
    9. Black Jesus ✝ Amen Fashion
    10. Bad Kids
    11. Fashion of His Love
    12. Highway Unicorn (Road to Love)
    13. Heavy Metal Lover
    14. Electric Chapel
    15. The Queen
    16. You and I
    17. The Edge of Glory

    Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    1. Teenage Dream
    2. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)
    3. California Gurls featuring Snoop Dogg
    4. Firework
    5. Peacock
    6. Circle The Drain
    7. The One That Got Away
    8. E.T.
    9. Who Am I Living For?
    10. Pearl
    11. Hummingbird Heartbeat
    12. Not Like The Movies
    13. Part of Me
    14. Wide Awake
    15. Dressin' Up

    Kesha: Warrior
    1. Warrior
    2. Die Young
    3. C'Mon
    4. Thinking of You
    5. Crazy Kids
    6. Wherever You Are
    7. Dirty Love featuring Iggy Pop
    8. Wonderland
    9. Only Wanna Dance With You
    10. Supernatural
    11. All That Matters (The Beautiful Life)
    12. Love Into the Light
    13. Last Goodbye
    14. Gold Trans Am
    15. Out Alive
    16. Past Lives

    1. munro
    2. Remorque
    3. Elysium
    4. Sanctuary
    5. theincredibleflipper
    6. KingBruno
    7. GhettoPrincess
    8. Terminus
    9. GimmeWork
    10. tylerc904
    11. DJHazey
    12. Sprockrooster
    13. Alouder98
    14. 2014
    15. theelusivechanteuse
    16. CorgiCorgiCorgi
    17. D.F.P.
    18. ThisIsRogue
    19. Posh Spears
    20. evilsin
    21. RMK
    22. Glitterizer
    23. ohdenny
    24. Aester
    25. Slice of Life
    26. ohnostalgia
    27. Mushroom
    28. DrinkMyTears
    29. Bangers&Bops
    30. Angeleyes
    31. Reboot
    32. Robsolete
    33. Andy French
    34. VitaminBee
    35. send photo
    36. constantino
    37. mokitsu
    38. unnameable
    39. First2Run
    40. Hurricane Drunk
    41. Animalia
    42. ufint
    43. ILLEFINT
    44. Tigerlily
    45. kalonite
    46. Petty Mayonnaise
    47. sexercise
    48. Weslicious
    49. Serg.
    50. WhenTheSunGoesDown
     
    Last edited: Jun 13, 2017
  3. Results

    00. Latest update: Top 5 summary (July 5, 2017)

    00. Controversy score explained

    48. Who Am I Living For? - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    47. Peacock - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    46. Dressin' Up - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    45. Pearl - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    44. Not Like The Movies - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    43. Circle The Drain - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    42. Firework - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    41. Wherever You Are - Kesha: Warrior
    40. Gold Trans Am - Kesha: Warrior
    39. The Queen - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    38. Dirty Love featuring Iggy Pop - Kesha: Warrior
    37. Wonderland - Kesha: Warrior
    36. Out Alive - Kesha: Warrior
    35. Bad Kids - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    34. Past Lives - Kesha: Warrior
    33. Americano - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    32. Love Into The Light - Kesha: Warrior
    31. Crazy Kids - Kesha: Warrior
    30. All That Matters (The Beautiful Life) - Kesha: Warrior
    29. Warrior - Kesha: Warrior
    28. Thinking of You - Kesha: Warrior
    27. Black Jesus ✝ Amen Fashion - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    26. Only Wanna Dance With You - Kesha: Warrior
    25. Highway Unicorn (Road to Love) - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    24. Hummingbird Heartbeat - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    23. Fashion of His Love - Lady Gaga - Born This Way
    22. Wide Awake - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    21. Part of Me - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    20. Supernatural - Kesha: Warrior
    19. You and I - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    18. Last Goodbye - Kesha: Warrior
    17. Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.) - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    16. California Gurls featuring Snoop Dogg - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    15. Electric Chapel - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    14. Born This Way - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    13. Hair - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    12. Bloody Mary - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    11. Government Hooker - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    10. C'Mon - Kesha: Warrior
    09. Die Young - Kesha: Warrior
    08. The One That Got Away - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    07. Judas - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    06. E.T. - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    05. Heavy Metal Lover - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    04. Scheiße - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    03. Teenage Dream - Katy Perry: Teenage Dream
    02. Marry The Night - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
    01. The Edge of Glory - Lady Gaga: Born This Way
     
    Last edited: Jul 10, 2017
  4. Last edited: Jul 10, 2017
    Posh Spears and Animalia like this.
  5. YES! Excited for this.

    Good thing my favorite song is terribly underrated.
     
    Posh Spears and ThisIsRogue like this.
  6. Kiii these Coverlandia covers

    [​IMG]
     
    constantino, evilsin, Serg. and 8 others like this.
  7. @ThisIsRogue please change Born This Way for the Special Edition cover, Teenage Dream for the textless cover and Warrior for the japanese edition cover, k, thnx.
     
    Sanctuary and ThisIsRogue like this.
  8. Haha I was actually going to use one of the alternate covers for Born This Way and Teenage Dream but figured I'd stay true to each artist's original vision. Born This Way has always been particularly terrible with that Word Art style title and terrible photoshopping. The standard Warrior album cover isn't that bad by comparison!

    I can of course update the album covers if enough people find them too much of an assault on their eyes and artistic sensibilities.
     
    Sprockrooster likes this.
  9. So here for this.

    And just to be a nitpicky there is also an official acoustic one for The One That Got Away. I imagine it is allowed to rate that version too if they prefer it?
     
    ThisIsRogue likes this.
  10. Yes, I did see the acoustic version on The Complete Confection. Must have forgotten to list it alongside the album version.
     
    Sprockrooster likes this.
  11. WAIT at Dressin' Up being way better than I remembered.
     
    Last edited: May 8, 2017
    ThisIsRogue and DJHazey like this.
  12. I'm here for Born This Way and ..... only Born This Way. I liked Teenage Dreams singles at the time but I think they aged not very well and Warrior wasn't a good album even in 2012.
     
    ThisIsRogue likes this.
  13. I feel like this has all been rated before?
     
  14. I can't wait for Heavy Metal Lovers win x
     
  15. Can't wait for Kesha to win this with a bonus track.
     
  16. I still can't get over the hideous blue Outer Glow on the Teenage Dream font.
     
    ThisIsRogue likes this.
  17. It is amazing that Gaga and Katy, two women who are known for their strong visuals, could be OK with such ugly design choices for their second eras.
     
    Sprockrooster likes this.
  18. I havenot. None of these and I have been her for 2 years now. So it definetely has been a while. Very glad it is happening!
     
    ThisIsRogue likes this.
  19. Submitted already, I could rate Born This Way and Warrior in my sleep so I took my time with Katy to really be fair with my scores. @Lost Boy would be proud.

    Born This Way - 8.58
    Teenage Dream - 7.36
    Warrior - 8.15
     
    constantino, evilsin, Serg. and 4 others like this.
  20. I cannot WAIT for Gaga to stomp all over this rate. Teenage Dream (the track obvi) can go T15 tho.
     
    RMK and ThisIsRogue like this.