The Pokémon Generation 4 Rate: GEN 4 CHAMPION REVEALED! | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

The Pokémon Generation 4 Rate: GEN 4 CHAMPION REVEALED!

Discussion in 'Off Topic' started by RJF, Apr 2, 2017.

  1. RJF

    RJF

    [​IMG]
    Well then.

    After two successful runs with the first two generations, creator of time @send photo, and current Gen 3 Rate runner and creator of space @Daniel! watch over the Popjustice forum, and peace reigns. However.

    A creature is breaching from the void of Lists & Charts...

    Bending the fabric of reality...

    A beast of darkness and nothingnessnessnessnessnessnessNESSNEssne....!!!!


    [​IMG]

    Yes, it is I, RJF! King of the Destortion World, and as always, I'm here to fuck you hoes up. This time, with the Pokémon Generation 4 Rate.

    Y'all know the drill by now, but even if you don't, I'll be copying and pasting in the same rules we've stuck by for the last three rates (The Fakémon Rate? I don't know her.) for anyone who is unsure of what they're doing. This time around, we're focusing on the batch of Pokémon that were introduced to us in the wonderful world of Sinnoh. Gen 4 was arguably peak Pokémon, teebs. Platinum holds up remarkably well against the newer titles, and I'm pretty sure Heart Gold and Soul Silver are widely considered the most "complete" experiences in the entire franchise. It's also my personal favourite, so it is an honour to bring it to you.

    Now, those rules I mentioned.

    - You give every Pokémon on the below list a score between 0-10, with half marks allowed.
    - You may give one Pokémon - your favourite, the one you want to win - an 11
    - You may give one Pokémon - your most hated, the one you despise - a -1
    - You may also submit a guess for the winner. If you guess right, your prize will be...

    [​IMG]
    MagneLi, the female-identifying shiny Magneton from my iconic Pokémon Moon Femlocke. Obviously, since there is only one, the person who guesses the winner first will get MagneLi. Every one else who guesses correctly will get a Dream Ball, IV bred Pokémon of their choice courtesy of the wonderful @send photo.

    I think that's it. I'm going to leave voting open until the end of the Gen 3 Rate, so a concrete date will follow when that's a little closer to happening.

    Turtwig
    Grotle
    Torterra
    Chimchar
    Monferno
    Infernape
    Piplup
    Prinplup
    Empoleon
    Starly
    Staravia
    Staraptor
    Bidoof
    Bibarel
    Kricketot
    Kricketune
    Shinx
    Luxio
    Luxray
    Budew
    Roserade
    Cranidos
    Rampardos
    Shieldon
    Bastiodon
    Burmy
    Wormadam
    Mothim
    Combee
    Vespiquen
    Pachirisu
    Buizel
    Floatzel
    Cherubi
    Cherrim
    Shellos
    Gastrodon
    Ambipom
    Drifloon
    Drifblim
    Buneary
    Lopunny
    Mismagius
    Honchkrow
    Glameow
    Purugly
    Chingling
    Stunky
    Skuntank
    Bronzor
    Bronzong
    Bonsly
    Mime Jr.
    Happiny
    Chatot
    Spiritomb
    Gible
    Gabite
    Garchomp
    Munchlax
    Riolu
    Lucario
    Hippopotas
    Hippowdon
    Skorupi
    Drapion
    Croagunk
    Toxicroak
    Carnivine
    Finneon
    Lumineon
    Mantyke
    Snover
    Abomasnow
    Weavile
    Magnezone
    Lickilicky
    Rhyperior
    Tangrowth
    Electivire
    Magmortar
    Togekiss
    Yanmega
    Leafeon
    Glaceon
    Gliscor
    Mamoswine
    Porygon-Z
    Gallade
    Probopass
    Dusknoir
    Froslass
    Rotom
    Uxie
    Mesprit
    Azelf
    Dialga
    Palkia
    Heatran
    Regigigas
    Giratina
    Cresselia
    Phione
    Manaphy
    Darkrai
    Shaymin
    Arceus

    See y'all at the Spear Pillar for the results. Good luck, and don't fuck it up.

     
  2. RJF

    RJF

    [​IMG]


    1. Luxray - 8.713
    2. Empoleon - 8.298

    3. Vespiquen - 8.255
    4. Mismagius - 8.213
    5. Weavile - 7.979
    6. Honchkrow - 7.862
    7. Torterra - 7.851
    8. Roserade - 7.819
    9. Piplup - 7.734
    10. Froslass - 7.681
    11. Togekiss - 7.543
    11. Drifblim - 7.543
    13. Gliscor - 7.532
    14. Leafeon - 7.500
    15. Garchomp - 7.424
    16. Drifloon - 7.404
    17. Glaceon - 7.340
    18. Mamoswine - 7.330
    19. Staraptor - 7.287
    20. Turtwig - 7.277
    20. Gallade - 7.277
    22. Darkrai - 7.181
    23. Infernape - 7.170
    24. Lucario - 7.064
    24. Magnezone - 7.064
    24. Electivire - 7.064
    27. Lopunny - 7.053
    28. Luxio - 6.968
    29. Gastrodon - 6.926
    29. Dialga - 6.926
    31. Floatzel - 6.872
    31. Shaymin - 6.872
    33. Arceus - 6.862
    34. Shinx - 6.840
    34. Giratina - 6.840
    36. Yanmega - 6.766
    37. Cresselia - 6.745
    38. Buizel - 6.681
    39. Dusknoir - 6.521
    40. Porygon-Z - 6.456
    41. Abomasnow - 6.383
    42. Rotom - 6.351
    43. Hippowdon - 6.319
    44. Buneary - 6.309
    45. Glameow - 6.298
    46. Prinplup - 6.287
    47. Combee - 6.149
    48. Monferno - 6.128
    49. Riolu - 6.117
    50. Staravia - 6.085
    51. Magmortar - 6.074
    51. Toxicroak - 6.074
    53. Gabite - 6.064
    54. Chatot - 5.947
    55. Grotle - 5.936
    56. Shellos - 5.915
    57. Starly - 5.872
    57. Palkia - 5.872
    59. Chimchar - 5.809
    59. Azelf - 5.809
    61. Snover - 5.787
    62. Gible - 5.766
    63. Croagunk - 5.723
    64. Spiritomb - 5.702
    64. Munchlax - 5.702
    66. Manaphy - 5.660
    67. Lumineon - 5.553
    68. Cherrim - 5.543
    69. Carnivine - 5.511
    70. Bronzong - 5.479
    71. Shieldon - 5.415
    72. Drapion - 5.394
    73. Ambipom - 5.383
    74. Mothim - 5.372
    75. Skorupi - 5.340
    76. Cranidos - 5.330
    76. Purugly - 5.330
    76. Hippopotas - 5.330
    79. Uxie - 5.287
    80. Cherubi - 5.227
    81. Bastiodon - 5.234
    82. Mesprit - 5.223
    83. Skunktank - 5.149
    84. Pachirisu - 5.085
    85. Rampardos - 5.043
    86. Stunky - 5.000
    87. Mantyke - 4.979
    88. Heatran - 4.957
    89. Finneon - 4.851
    90. Tangrowth - 4.830
    91. Kricketune - 4.819
    92. Bidoof - 4.798
    93. Budew - 4.777
    94. Happiny - 4.734
    94. Phione - 4.734
    96. Chingling - 4.532
    97. Bronzor - 4.415
    98. Bibarel - 4.287
    98. Lickilicky - 4.287
    100. Mime Jr. - 4.255
    101. Kricketot. 4.138
    102. Bonsly - 3.872
    103. Wormadam - 3.862
    104. Burmy - 3.521
    105. Probopass - 3.489
    106. Regigigas - 3.117
    107. Rhyperior - 3.106
     
    Last edited: Jun 8, 2017
    Squashua, Kyle., Number and 11 others like this.
  3. RJF

    RJF

    And another for... reasons.
     
    Number, RUNAWAY, aaronhansome and 6 others like this.
  4. So much iconic pokémon. So much trash also. I feel like I will be handing out 10s and 0s left and right. But middle scores are rare.
     
    Oleander, send photo and RJF like this.
  5. Floatzel serving indecent proposition from Masc hottie in the gym locker room and I'm sort of digging it.

    [​IMG]
     
    beekeeper, RUNAWAY, Kuhleezi and 18 others like this.
  6. This is maybe my favorite gen. I'm ready.
     
    RJF likes this.
  7. I just beat Zelda so I'll get to finishing my Platinum play and bump up some scores.
     
    Chris_P and RJF like this.
  8. RJF

    RJF

    Also, I think we can all agree there's no point in rating the different forms of Shaymin/Giratina/Wormadam etc separately.
     
    aaronhansome and Oleander like this.
  9. Flying Shaymin is much better though.
     
    Presibrent likes this.
  10. Me congratulating the winner

    [​IMG]
     
  11. Sinnoh is my favorite region, although it's not my favorite batch of Pokémon. Excited for this!
     
    RJF likes this.
  12. Who knew you had such a flair for graphic design.

    (I've never played a single Gen 4 game, but I'm tempted to find an emulator / rate all of 'em on appearance alone kii.)
     
    Chris_P and Island like this.
  13. Wait at me forgetting Jellicent and Zoroark are next gen I don't have time for these shit
     
  14. RJF

    RJF

    Sis I made every single cover in the Big Pop Girls Rate.
    Just fucking do it.
     
  15. There's only five that I like. Manaphy should win.
     
  16. RJF

    RJF

    In fact never mind.
     
  17. As the other gen IV stan I am oh so here for this. My 11 is easy but I'll hand out plenty of 10s along the way.

    Also, if you're replaying the games please do yourself a favour, skip out on Diamond & Pearl and dive straight into Platinum, because they're possibly the most lacking main series games 'til Sun & Moon. They needed a lot of polish and, thankfully, received it with the single best instalment introduced.
     
  18. I missed the other ones but doing this one for sure. I already know who my -1 will be too.
     
    RJF likes this.
  19. Gen IV is my fav all around gen so I'm excited this is finally beginning. Don't shoot me but I wouldn't be mad if Manaphy won. Or Shaymin.

    Or Dark Lord Giratina.
     
  20. Yes what a great generation all around. A lot of fantastic designs and one of the best starters! (The Emperor haself)

    No kii. I want to rate them separately.
     
    Presibrent likes this.