Ultimate K-PopJustice Albums [#1 Revealed & I'm Done] | The Popjustice Forum
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Ultimate K-PopJustice Albums [#1 Revealed & I'm Done]

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Alouder98, Sep 5, 2017.

  1. Hello

    [​IMG]


    So I'm back with another rate much sooner than I planned. I think I said before that I won't start a rate until probably next year but this rate gave me an idea that I think would be fun. That rate which is still on is about finding out which album is the ultimate favorite album of PJ community and when I saw a few K-Pop albums found their way into it, I thought ''why don't do a K-Pop edition of this?''. I (and probably every K-Pop fan) know that the overall quality of albums in K-Pop world is not really high but still there are some great albums in it and we're here to find which album is the best of them.


    But how are we going to do this? Just send me your top 10 favorite albums in order via PM and I will do the rest of works. Also along with each album please choose 1) Your favorite track on the album 2) The track you would recommend to a new listener 3) What you consider the most underrated track on the album. (you can choose a song twice).


    Some notes (rules?):

    - Mini albums/EPs are allowed. Complication and greatest hits albums are not, unless more than half of those album are new tracks. (For example Girls' Generation first Japanese album is accepted but their The Best album is not.)

    - Repackage albums and their standard edition both will be counted as one album. (For example T-ara's Absolute and Breaking Heart both will be counted as Absolute)

    - Like always, commentaries are optional but highly encouraged.


    The deadline is October 15. This rate won't be fun if the number of participants is small so please participate. Also if any parts is unclear for you, feel free to ask me xx



    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2017
    evilsin, Deja-Boo, Sanctuary and 4 others like this.
  2. Results

     
    Last edited: Nov 2, 2017
    evilsin, ajmkv, Deja-Boo and 3 others like this.
  3. Stats

    Girl Groups - 57
    Boy Groups - 23
    Solo Female - 22
    Solo Male - 10
    Sub-units - 5
    Co-ed Acts - 1
    SM - 34
    YG - 14
    JYP - 11
    Nega Network - 6
    Pledis - 6
    MBK - 5
    Cube - 4
    WM - 4
    DSP Media - 3
    Star Empire - 3
    Starship - 3
    Amoeba Culture - 2
    Big Hit - 2
    Banana Culture - 2
    JellyFish - 2
    Woolim - 2
    APOP - 1
    AVA - 1
    B2M - 1
    Block Berry Creative - 1
    Chrome - 1
    C-JeS - 1
    De Chocolate - 1
    Dream Tea - 1
    Happy Face - 1
    J.Tune - 1
    LOEN - 1
    Mystic - 1
    Pan - 1
    Park Jiyoon Creative - 1
    Shofar Music - 1
    Source Music - 1
    2016 - 20
    2015 - 18
    2017 - 15
    2012 - 13
    2014 - 13
    2011 - 10
    2009 - 8
    2010 - 8
    2013 - 8
    2008 - 3
    2002 - 1
    2004 - 1
    SNSD - 7
    EXO - 5
    2NE1 - 4
    Brown Eyed Girls - 4
    SHINee - 4
    T-ara - 4
    4Minute - 3
    After School - 3
    BoA - 3
    f(x) - 3
    Twice - 3
    B1A4 - 2
    BTS - 2
    EXID - 2
    Miss A - 2
    Monsta X - 2
    Nine Muses - 2
    Oh My Girl - 2
    Primary - 2
    Rainbow - 2
    Taeyeon - 2
    VIXX - 2
    Wonder Girls - 2
    15& - 1
    Akdong Musician - 1
    Apink - 1
    Balbbalgan4 - 1
    Big Bang - 1
    Crayon Pop - 1
    Day6 - 1
    DIA - 1
    Dreamcatcher - 1
    EXO-CBX - 1
    Gain - 1
    GFriend - 1
    Girl's Day - 1
    Got7 - 1
    Ha:tfelt - 1
    Infinite - 1
    IU - 1
    Ivy - 1
    Jewelry - 1
    Jonghyun - 1
    KARA - 1
    Lee Hi - 1
    Lee Hyori - 1
    Lee Jung-hyun - 1
    Lim Kim - 1
    Lovelyz - 1
    Luna - 1
    Miryo - 1
    Narsha - 1
    NCT 127 - 1
    Nell - 1
    NU'EST - 1
    Park Jiyoon - 1
    Odd Eye Circle - 1
    Orange Caramel - 1
    Rain - 1
    Red Velvet - 1
    Se7en - 1
    Seohyun - 1
    Seungri - 1
    Sistar - 1
    Son Dam Bi - 1
    Tablo - 1
    Taemin - 1
    Taeyang - 1
    Tiffany - 1
    TTS - 1
    Uhm Jung Hwa - 1
    XIA - 1
     
    Last edited: Nov 8, 2017
    evilsin, Deja-Boo, Sanctuary and 2 others like this.
  4. This rate is such a great idea, btw. I'm really interested to know just what kind of albums people enjoy listening to (and whether there's a consensus)

    Guess whose Top 10 is going to all SHINee and f(x) and Nu'est.
    Kings and Queens only
    [​IMG]
     
    Sanctuary, Ceir and Alouder98 like this.
  5. If y'all neglect Step 2/4....
     
    Alouder98 likes this.
  6. But f(x) don't have 10 albums so how do I complete this?
     
    evilsin, Aries, Alouder98 and 5 others like this.
  7. He

    He

    I'm down.
     
    Alouder98 likes this.
  8. MeU's don't forget the often overlooked masterpiece:
    [​IMG]

    And thanks @Alouder98! - I'm already going to put in for a deadline extension....
     
  9. Oh guys, I forgot to mention something. This rate is not going to work like K-PopJustice monthly charts. Every album will chart here even if just one person gave it one point. So I would suggest to go with your own favorite albums instead of choosing what you think will chart here or not.


    Also if you think your list would be messy or embarrassing, don't worry. I'm here and I promise you your list is not as embarrassing as mine. I'm not sure about you @ryan_riot92 though, you're hard to beat.
     
    Last edited: Sep 6, 2017
  10. Any and all recommendations would be delightful / greatly appreciated considering my ballot currently consists of about 4 releases. I only really started listening past the singles over the last couple of years so I'm very behind on classic releases.
     
    Alouder98 likes this.
  11. [​IMG]

    Hey now, "INNOCENT" is a masterpiece!! Anybody who thinks otherwise isn't worth my time!
     
  12. I rarely listen to albums outside of f(x) and GG so I'll likely be putting forward their less good ones too but may use this as an opportunity to enlighten myself.
     
    Alouder98 likes this.
  13. Hahaha I figure I may as well go all out with my recommends, but I'll share girl groups/solo albums first to cater to the general preference (I highlighted albums that I personally think are bombastic). [Disclaimer: This is just my opinion] Wow, I really went to town with this list.

    Girl Groups
    • After School: Dress To Kill / First Love
    • AOA: Good Luck
    • APRIL: Prelude
    • f(x): Electric Shock / Pink Tape / Red Light / 4 Walls
    • BEG: Black Box / Basic
    • Bbolbbagan4: Red Planet
    • CLC: First Love / Cry'style / Free'sm
    • T-ara: Absolute First Album / Funky Town / Day By Day
    • EXID: Ah Yeah / Street
    • Fiestar: Black Label
    • SNSD: Lion Heart / Holiday Night / 1st Japanese Album / 2nd Japanese Album
    • Ladies' Code: Myst3ry
    • Lovelyz: Lovelyz8 / R U Ready
    • Miss A: Colors
    • Oh My Girl: Closer / Pink Ocean
    • Rainbow: Rainbow Syndrome Pt. 1 and 2 / Innocent
    • Red Velvet: Ice Cream Cake / The Red / Russian Roulette / The Red Summer
    • Stellar: Into the Stellar World
    • Unicorn: The Brand New Label
    • WJSN: Happy Moment
    • Wonder Girls: Wonder World / Reboot / Why So Lonely
    • 2NE1: 2nd Mini Album / Crush
    • 4Minute: Name is 4Minute / Crazy / Act.7
    • 9Muses: Primadonna
    Solos
    • BoA: Kiss My Lips
    • IU: Modern Times / Chat-shire
    • Ha;tfelt: Me?
    • Yezi: Foresight Dream
    • Gain: Hawwah
    • Jimin Park: 19to20
    • J.Min: Ready For Your Love
    • Luna: Free Somebody
    • HyunA: A+ / A'wesome
    • Lim Kim: Simple Mind
     
    Last edited: Sep 6, 2017
  14. Perfectioooooon. I'll probably start with the ones that have my favourite title tracks & work from there. I'd be very much down for a boys list too (because I'm even worse with my background knowledge there).
     
    Slice of Life and Alouder98 like this.
  15. Hahaha I'll share a Boys list tomorrow when I procrastinate from my assignments again. I really hope you find something you like! Kpop has so many solid albums, I probably missed quite a few.
     
    Slice of Life and Alouder98 like this.

  16. AMAZING. Half of my current top 10 are in this list so I think I should listen to those that are new for me before I submit my own ballot. Thanks so much <3
     
    Salami and Slice of Life like this.
  17. Really, really good list, K. Thanks.
    Looks a lot like the MP3 library on my phone, even.
     
    karmarisma and Alouder98 like this.
  18. Aaaa, I'm going to do it. Drop me a tag on the 20th or something, please @Alouder98!!
     
    Alouder98 likes this.