.

F

Fertilizer



songs.png



tumblr_99d45d00b8317222c3ff8bdc0d243506_87fdcee3_500.gif



Several weeks ago, I selected male artists from a 2020 best-sellers list, and asked subforum regulars to vote for who they wanted to be be part of the rate, also accepting write-ins for artists that weren't on the list, and with enough votes they would also be included. After that, I asked you guys to vote for which songs by these artists should compete, with the most voted artists having more song slots, and this what y'all picked:


songs.png

BALLOT TEMPLATE SHEET

or

100 - SuperM:
1 Billion Views - EXO-SC:
10 Months - ENHYPEN:
100 Ways - Jackson Wang:
24h - SEVENTEEN:
90's Love - NCT U:
ALL IN - Stray Kids:
Amnesia - KAI:
Answer - ATEEZ:
B.L.T (BLING LIKE THIS) - TREASURE:
Back Door - Stray Kids:
Bad Guy - 1THE9:
Black Swan - BTS:
Blue Hour - TXT:
Break All the Rules - CRAVITY:
Breath - GOT7:
BUMP BUMP - WOODZ:
Can't You See Me? - TXT:
Candy - BAEKHYUN:
Criminal - TAEMIN:
Daisy - PENTAGON:
Déjà Vu - NCT DREAM:
Dr. BeBe - PENTAGON:
Drip - SuperM:
Easy - Stray Kids:
Fairy of Shampoo - TXT:
FANTASIA - MONSTA X:
Forbidden Island - HA SUNG WOON:
Gasoline - MONSTA X:
Ghosting - TXT:
Given-Taken - ENHYPEN:
Go High - SF9:
Goblin (Favorite Boys) - A.C.E
God's Menu - Stray Kids
Good Guy - SF9
GRAVITY - ONG SEONG WU
Heaven - TAEMIN
HOME;RUN - SEVENTEEN
Howling - VICTON
I'm In Trouble - NU'EST
IDEA:理想 - TAEMIN
INCEPTION - ATEEZ
Kick It - NCT 127
Knock - ASTRO
LAST PIECE - GOT7
Lay Back - VERIVERY
Left & Right - SEVENTEEN
Love Killa - MONSTA X
Love Me Harder - WOODZ
LOVE YOU BETTER - GOT7
Make a Wish (Birthday Song) - NCT U
Midnight - PARK JI HOON
My Time - BTS
Nectar - WayV
NOT BY THE MOON - GOT7
Nothing On Me - KAI
ONE (Lucid Dream) - Golden Child
One (Monster & Infinity) - SuperM
Open Mind - WONHO
Pandora's Box - NCT 127
Paradise - Eric Nam
People - Agust D
Pretty Please - Jackson Wang
Pump It Up - Golden Child
R U Ridin'? - BAEKHYUN
REVEAL - THE BOYZ
Revival - CIX
Ridin - NCT DREAM
Starry Night - SUHO
Sukhumvit Swimming - ONF:
Summer Breeze - SF9
THANXX - ATEEZ
The Stealer - THE BOYZ
Tiger Inside - SuperM
TO BE OR NOT TO BE - ONEUS
Turn Back Time - WayV
VIVID - AB6IX
W.ALL - GHOST9
Where The Sea Sleeps - DAY6 (Even of Day)
Whiplash - THE BOYZ
WITH YOU - WONHO
Zombie - DAY6






YOUTUBE

APPLE MUSIC

 
Last edited by a moderator:
F

Fertilizer



RESULTS.png



tumblr_2902c443008cfb8de484e889d6c7d103_549c07d7_500.gif




SONGS LEADERBOARD



82. Fantasia | MONSTA X (5,9)
81. People | Agust D (6,1) ★
80. Easy | Stray Kids (6,5)
79. Break All the Rules | CRAVITY (6,5) ★
78. Where the Sea Sleeps | DAY6 (Even of Day) (6,6)
77. Black Swan | BTS (6,6) ★
76. ALL IN | Stray Kids (6,7)
75. Starry Night | Suho (6,7)
74. Love Killa | MONSTA X (6,8)
73. W.ALL | GHOST9 (6,9)


72. Midnight | Park Jihoon (7,0)
71. My Time | BTS (7,0)
70. BUMP BUMP | WOODZ (7,0)
69. God's Menu | Stray Kids (7,1)
68. Pretty Please | Jackson Wang & Galantis (7,1)
67. Pump It Up | Golden Child (7,1)
66. THANXX | ATEEZ (7,1)
65. Ridin' | NCT Dream (7,1)
64. Gasoline | MONSTA X (7,2)
63. Drip | SuperM (7,3)


62. Pandora's Box
| NCT 127 (7,3)
61. Howling | VICTON (7,3)
60. Tiger Inside | SuperM (7,4)
59. Dr. BeBe | PENTAGON (7,4)
58. Kick It | NCT 127 (7,4) ★
57. Goblin (Favorite Boys) | A.C.E (7,5) ★★
56. Answer | ATEEZ (7,5) ★
55. B.L.T (BLING LIKE THIS) | TREASURE (7,5)
54. Left & Right | SEVENTEEN (7,5)
53. 24H | SEVENTEEN (7,6)
52. Knock | ASTRO (7,6)


51.
HOME;RUN | SEVENTEEN (7,6)
50. 100 | SuperM (7,6)
49. Déjà Vu | NCT Dream (7,6)
48. Revival | CIX (7,7)
47. WITH YOU | Wonho (7,7)
46. Bad Guy | 1THE9 (7,7) ★★★
45. 100 Ways | Jackson Wang (7,7)
44. TO BE OR NOT TO BE | ONEUS (7,7)
43. Heaven | Taemin (7,7) ★
42. Vivid | AB6IX (7,8)


40.
TIE: Breath | GOT7 & IDEA:理想 | Taemin (7,8)
39. 90's Love | NCT U (7,8) ★
38. Go High | SF9 (7,9)
37. R U Ridin'? | Baekhyun (7,9)
36. Daisy | PENTAGON (7,9)
35. Paradise | Eric Nam (7,9)
34. Make a Wish (Birthday Song) | NCT U (7,9) ★
33. I'm In Trouble | NU'EST (7,9) ★
32. Inception | ATEEZ (7,9)
31. Love Me Harder | WOODZ (8,0)


30.
1 Billion Views | EXO-SC (8,0)
29. Whiplash | THE BOYZ (8,0)
28. Open Mind | Wonho (8,0)
27. Turn Back Time | WayV (8,0)
26. Back Door | Stray Kids (8,1) ★
25. Nectar | WayV (8,1)
24. Reveal | THE BOYZ (8,2)
23. Lay Back | VERIVERY (8,2)
22. LOVE YOU BETTER | GOT7 (8,2) ★
21. Fairy of Shampoo | TXT (8,2)


20. Gravity | Ong Seong Wu (8,2)
19. Forbidden Island | Ha Sung Woon (8,2)
18. Candy | Baekhyun (8,2) ★
17. One (Monster & Infinity) | SuperM (8,3)
16. NOT BY THE MOON | GOT7 (8,3) ★
15. Given-Taken | ENHYPEN (8,3) ★
14. Zombie | DAY6 (8,4) ★
13. LAST PIECE | GOT7 (8,4)
12. Amnesia | Kai (8,4)
11. 10 Months | ENHYPEN (8,4) ★★


10. Can't You See Me?
| TXT (8,4)
9. Sukhumvit Swimming | ONF (8,5) ★★★
8. Summer Breeze | SF9 (8,5)
7. ONE (Lucid Dream) | Golden Child (8,5) ★★
6. Blue Hour | TXT (8,6) ★
5. Good Guy | SF9 (8,6) ★
4. Criminal | Taemin (8,7) ★★★★★
3. CLICK HERE (8,8) ★★★
2. CLICK HERE (9,1)
1. CLICK HERE (9,2) ★★




ARTIST AVERAGES LEADERBOARDS



25. MONSTA X (6,7)
24. BTS (6,8) ★
23. Stray Kids (7,1) ★
22. NCT 127 (7,4) ★
21. NCT Dream (7,4)


20.
Jackson Wang (7,4)
19. DAY6 + (Even of Day) (7,5) ★
18. WOODZ (7,5)
17. ATEEZ (7,5) ★
16. SEVENTEEN (7,6)
15. SuperM (7,6)
14. PENTAGON (7,6)
13. NCT (All Units) (7,7) ★★★
12. Golden Child (7,8) ★★
11. Wonho (7,8)


10. NCT U
(7,9) ★★
9. Baekhyun (8,0) ★
8. WayV (8,1)
7. Taemin (8,1) ★★★★★★
6. GOT7 (8,2) ★★
5. THE BOYZ (8,3) ★★★
4. SF9 (8,3) ★
3. ENHYPEN (8,4) ★★★
2. TXT (8,6) ★★★
1. Kai (8,7)

47. Agust D (6,1) ★
46. CRAVITY (6,5) ★
45. DAY6 (Even of Day) (6,6)
44. MONSTA X (6,7)
43. Suho (6,7)
42. BTS (6,8) ★
41. GHOST9 (6,9)


40. Park Ji Hoon
(7,0)
39. Stray Kids (7,1) ★
38. VICTON (7,3)
37. NCT 127 (7,4) ★
36. NCT Dream (7,4)
35. Jackson Wang (7,4)
34. DAY6 + (Even of Day) (7,5) ★
33. A.C.E (7,5) ★★
32. TREASURE (7,5)
31. WOODZ (7,5)


30. ATEEZ
(7,5) ★
29. SEVENTEEN (7,6)
28. ASTRO (7,6)
27. SuperM (7,6)
26. PENTAGON (7,6)
25. CIX (7,7)
24. 1THE9 (7,7) ★★★
23. NCT (All Units) (7,7) ★★★
22. ONEUS (7,7)
21. AB6IX (7,8)


20. Golden Child
(7,8) ★★
19. Wonho (7,8)
18. NCT U (7,9) ★★
17. Eric Nam (7.9)
16. NU'EST (7,9) ★
15. EXO-SC (8,0)
14. Baekhyun (8,0) ★
13. WayV (8,1)
12. Taemin (8,1) ★★★★★★
11. VERIVERY (8,2)


10. GOT7
(8,2) ★★
9. Ong Seong Wu (8,2)
8. Ha Sung Woon (8,2)
7. THE BOYZ (8,3) ★★★
6. DAY6 (8,4) ★
5. SF9 (8,3) ★
4. ENHYPEN (8,4) ★★★
3. ONF (8,5) ★★★
2. TXT (8,6) ★★★
1. Kai (8,7)


EXTRA DATA


 
Last edited by a moderator:
F

Fertilizer

...who's up for some bonus content?

I want to have a ranking of PJ's favorite male idols, individually, to post at the end of this rate.
It will be just a simple reveal, no write-ups or anything (maybe for the Top 3?).

It's completely optional, but I'd love if every voter participated! To participate, please send me a ballot, monthly-chart style, of your 10 to 15 favorite male idols, in order. You can use whatever criteria you want: looks, voice, personality, talent, a combination of it all, anything goes! You must send at least 10 idols, but you can keep going until you reach 1 point (15 idols maximum) if you want to. You must use this format:

25 points: IDOL (GROUP)
23 points:
21 points:
19 points:
17 points:
15 points:
14 points:
13 points:
12 points:
11 points:

9 points:
7 points:
5 points:
3 points:
1 point:


Bold = obligatory
Grey = optional


A few pointers:
- Use the idol's main stage name, not their birth name (example: V instead of TAEHYUNG)
- In the case of an artist that is in multiple groups, or has multiple names, use their main ones. Example: LUCAS (NCT) or SUGA (BTS) instead of LUCAS (SUPERM) or AGUST D.
- If it's a solo artist, include just the stage name, no parenthesis
- Any male K-Pop idol or singer is eligible, they don't need to have a song in this rate. Active or inactive, as long as they have at some point in time been part of K-Pop.

The deadline: you have until the #1 song is revealed~


 
Last edited by a moderator:
he/him
Well I already know what’s getting my 11... and anyone who knows me well enough can probably guess what it is.

But there’s a lot of great songs here so this will be an enjoyable rate. It’ll be nice for the boy groups to shine on their own without fear of them being tanked by girl group stans ddd
 
F

Fertilizer

Just realized VERIVERY are not represented meanwhile KPJ flops like Eric Nam and Kang Daniel are here omfg
tumblr_inline_o7c2h8bBFC1qd7qdc_500.gif


@OspreyQueen we/they failed our faves
Sorry unnie, you were the only one who voted for them fff

I did spare everyone some minutes by just having Zico and Kang Daniel share one song though, kii.
They were both tied with just like... 3 votes between them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
By the way @Glitterizer, I will probably be including commentary for all songs dddd which I understand is completely against
I don't want to outright forbid commentary for non-11 songs, but if you want to send them, please keep to a small amount. Let's save those thoughts for the thread to help it stay alive fff
but the commentary was more so for me to keep track of my (often evolving) thoughts as I have been scoring these songs since a bunch of them were new to me and I gave (and will keep giving) the playlist a bunch of listens to solidify these scores. Don't worry, I'll be sending you a pretty spreadsheet so you can easily hide the column and ignore them dddd, and I'll be sure to bold the important ones. Feel free to include all, any, few, or none of them! <3 (And you know my ass will be commenting through the whole reveal, we may stan a flop boy group but we don't let our PJ user kings flop!)

So excited for this rate!
 

Top