A Kiwi Versus Rate: Kimbra | Ladyhawke | Broods | The Naked And Famous | Bic Runga [DONE]

New page for final reveal.




































































































I made a start with you, but it's not fair
Cause you're over the Atlantic baby




























































































































The bittersweet between my teeth
Trying to find the in-betweens















































































































































































































































































































Adnotacja.jpg

2. Young Blood 9.4583


11: @BubblegumBoy @Remorque
Highest: 10x6: @Crisp X @Epic Chocolat @Untouchable Ace @berserkboi @soratami @Music Is Death | 9x1: @DJHazey
Lowest: 6x1: @Cutlery | 8x1: moi


written by/Thom Powers, Alisa Xayalith and Aaron Short

produced by/Thom Powers and Aaron Short
available on/Passive Me, Aggressive You
charts/#1 NZ (Platinum) #26 AU (Platinum) #30 GER (Gold) #64 UK (Silver) #14 US Bubbling Under (Platinum)


Alisa said:

"I remember being up at two in the morning playing with a main key line, the next day I showed it to Thom and we made a demo. I spent the rest of the day watching Skins and I got inspired by that rebellious spirit. Everything is so romanticised and exaggerated on that show. It makes you wish you had a teenage life like that. So I wrote lyrics that inspired dreaming and youthful exuberance."

Released summer 2010 as the second single leading into TNAF's debut album, "Young Blood" is undoubtedly the hit of the rate. Soundtracked countless TV shows and commercials. APRA Silver Scroll 2010 for best-written song. Covered by everyone from Jessie J to Birdy. Frankly, I don't think I've heard the whole song until last year.

So after the Great Peach Controversy this was looking like a runaway winner and I was making a surprised pikachu face. I guess I was just blindsided by my shortsightedness of including such a behemoth and not expecting that its status would make it make sense as a likely rate winner. It was the eleventh hour ballot from @Cutlery that turned the tables and granted my 11 the path to victory, which was an amazing twist to witness. K, think I've said enough, better get running!

hazey-01.gif
9 - If you take out the whistling elements the opening reminds me of "Pumpin Blood" by Nonono for some reason. This is pretty much the same calibre of an indie anthem that was, though I'm not in love when the song slows down.

berserk-1.gif

10 - Their masterpiece as far as I am concerned!


cutlery-2.gif

6 - The riffs are so good, and the lyrics can be shouted along to, but the entire arena sound of pretty much everything else, is just really unappealing and cheapens the music for me.


bb.gif

I think I always knew this was going to be my 11. It’s a complete bop from beginning to end. I’ve loved the song for years and still get goose bumps when it comes on



A song we could have rated:




h.jpg

1. Magic 9.5833

11: ME-hehe @soratami
Highest: 10x6: @DJHazey @Epic Chocolat @Untouchable Ace @berserkboi @Music Is Death @Cutlery | 9x2: @klow @Remorque
Lowest: 7x1: @Crisp X | 8x1: @BubblegumBoy


written by/Pip Brown and Pascal Gabriel
produced by/Pascal Gabriel
available on/Ladyhawke
1/6
charts/
#31 NZ


Ladyhawke said:
"That track I wrote all about sort of being alone. I wrote it when I first moved to London and I didn’t really know anyone. It was like a fantasy, imagining that you actually had someone you could talk to, which I didn’t."

I can play and hide behind grand concepts but the rationale behind this rate was to give my 11 to "Magic", simple as that. And now it happens to be the winner of the whole rate, which I bet nobody, including me, saw coming. Can you say legenddddd?

The fact that Pip/her label waited til a whole year passed to release it as the last single from her debut (September 2008 to September 2009)..................................... would I have ever even discovered Ladyhawke, had it not been for this timing? Now, if you indulge my nostalgia for a second, going back to early 2010, the success of Florence and the emergence of the whole Quirky Pop Girl phenomena, I was determined to find some more of this indie-type music and get into it. "Magic" was one of the first songs I stumbled upon on youtube and holy shit! Just.HOLY.SHIT. I don't think I can describe in words the new worlds that opened up to me when I heard that instrumental for the first time. The very first CD I burnt had "Magic" on it. To verify this claim, I pulled out an old hardcover I used to document my playlists in, and damn, the tracklist is pretty killer - "You've Got The Love" and "Rabbit Heart", "Under The Sheets", "I Predict A Riot", "Foundations", "Once", "L.E.S Artistes", "Trouble Is A Friend" and "Incomplete Lullaby" by Lisa Mitchell. What? I said I'd be indulgent!

To close this out, "Magic" still sounds as fresh and electrifying as ever. It remains one of my absolute favourites from the 2000s and I'm delighted to have created an opportunity for it to become a rate winner. My mind!


hazey-01.gif
10 - Ever since the Quirky Pop rate I just can't stop listening to this. I always compare songs with the same title especially if the song I knew first has a special place in my heart (which creates a high bar for the new song to subconsciously match) and that is Sophie Ellis-Bector's "Magic" from my favorite album of hers Make a Scene. Not only does it compare well but even being more of an indie rock song it still manages to create the same vibe I get from the Sophie song and parent album. The "over the Atlantic" lines pops the fuck off as well with its catchiness.

berserk-1.gif

10 - Yet another perfect track from my Queen <3333


cutlery-2.gif

10 - It smashes! Let’s hear it clap with the sound of getting attached quick and easy.



A Song We Could Have Rated:




the rest of stats and some final words will follow this week
 
The perfect winner! And I wouldn't say it was unexpected either, I figured Ladyhawke had it in the bag from the get-go, and it was either Magic or My Delirium. Funnily enough, in the first Quirky Pop rate, My Delirium ended two spots ahead of Magic, and here it was the other way around. Thank you for hosting another great rate @Phonetics Girl, hopefully it won't actually be the last you do!
 
he/him
Your mind indeed @Phonetics Girl! I love the story behind how you came discover a whole new world of music as I've had a few similar stories in my life too. To me, I expected My Delirium to run away with it, so this is a nice surprise. Though both are indie rock anthems and either would've deserved the crown, though knowing it was your 11 and purpose-built for this rate makes all the more special. I'll never be able to thank you enough for all the discoveries I made in this rate.
 
he/him
Fair
Overrated
Underrated


Kimbra

Settle Down | 9.5 | #59
Cameo Lover | 9 | #14
Two Way Street | 7 | #54
Good Intent | 6 | #79
Come Into My Head | 8 | #39

Warrior | 6 | #13
90s Music | 7.5 | #55
Miracle | 11 | #7

Goldmine | 8.5 | #77
Love in High Places | 9.5 | #68

Nobody But You | 5 | #63
Everlovin' Ya | 8 | #73
Sweet Relief | 5.5 | #70
Everybody Knows | 7 | #49

Top of the World | 10 | #50
Human | 6.5 | #67
Like They Do On The TV | 10 | #21

Version of Me | 9 | #57
Lightyears | 9.5 | #5
Silent Treatment | 7 | #60


+6

Ladyhawke

Embrace | 9 | #6
My Delirium | 10 | #3
Magic | 10 | #1
Manipulating Woman | 8.5 | #34

Love Don't Live Here | 7.5 | #29
Crazy World | 9.5 | #37
Morning Dreams | 9 | #47

Black White & Blue | 10 | #9
Sunday Drive | 10 | #11
Vanity | 3 | #80
The Quick & The Dead | 5.5 | #74
Cellophane | 5.5 | #62

Gone Gone Gone | 9 | #66
A Love Song | 6.5 | #10
Sweet Fascination | 8 | #36
Dangerous | 9 | #25

Let It Roll | 10 | #35
The River | 6 | #38
Wild Things | 6.5 | #8

Guilty Love | 10 | #22


+2

Broods


Bridges | 5 | #42
Never Gonna Change | 6 | #58
Sleep Baby Sleep | 5.5 | #76
Coattails | 9 | #31

Mother & Father | 6 | #44
L.A.F. | 7.5 | #27

Four Walls | 9 | #61
Evergreen | 7 | #53
Free | 9 | #20
Heartlines | 9 | #16

Couldn't Believe | 7 | #17
Recovery | 9 | #4

We Had Everything | 9.5 | #32
Conscious | 10 | #26

Peach | 10 | #15
Everything Goes (Wow) | 8 | #46

Hospitalized | 6 | #24
Too Proud | 8 | #65
Sucker | 5.5 | #52
Dust | 8.5 | #23

+/- 0

The Naked and Famous

All Of This | 9 | #45
Young Blood | 9 | #2
Punching in a Dream | 8 | #33
Hearts Like Ours | 6.5 | #28
I Kill Giants | 5.5 | #43

Higher | 10 | #19
Laid Low | 7.5 | #56
Sunseeker | 7 | #69

Bury Us | 8 | #18
Come As You Are | 5 | #78

+/- 0

Bic Runga

Drive | 9 | #64
Sway | 10 | #30
Suddenly Strange | 9.5 | #48
Drive (with Strawpeople) | 10 | #72

Get Some Sleep | 10 | #12
Something Good | 8 | #51

Winning Arrow | 10 | #75
Hello Hello | 9 | #71
Close You Eyes | 10 | #40
Dream a Dream | 9.5 | #40


-6


Fairness Ranking

1. Kimbra
2. Ladyhawke
3. Broods/ The Naked and Famous
4. Bic Runga

I had issues with many Kimbra eliminations but as my average rank showed, she did have her ups and downs so we ended up having more fair eliminations for her than bad ones.
 
Last edited:
giphy.gif

av. 8.2892

1. (#2) Young Blood 9.4583
2. (#18) Bury Us 8.7333
3. (#19) Higher 8.7
4. (#28) Hearts Like Ours 8.5208
5. (#33) Punching In A Dream 8.4417
6. (#43) I Kill Giants 8.2333
7. (#45) All Of This 8.1917
8. (#56) Laid Low 7.9667
9. (#69) Sunseeker 7.525
10. (#78) Come As You Are 7.1208

Most 10s: Young Blood (6)
11: Young Blood (2)
Lowest score: Come As You Are (0)

Voter averages:
1. @Music Is Death 9.8
2. @BubblegumBoy = @Remorque 9.2
4. @berserkboi 8.95
5. @Untouchable Ace 8.76
6. @Epic Chocolat 8.56
---average---
7. @Phonetics Girl 8.2
8. @Crisp X 7.85
9. @klow 7.65
10. @soratami 7.6
11. @DJHazey 7.55
12. @Cutlery 6.15
 
giphy.gif

av. 8.3331

1. (#4) Recovery 9.2708
2. (#15) Peach 8.8083
3. (#16) Heartlines 8.7792
4. (#17) Couldn't Believe 8.7458
5. (#20) Free 8.675
6. (#23) Dust 8.6042
7. (#24) Hospitalized 8.5667
8. (#26) Conscious 8.55
9. (#27) L.A.F 8.5417
10. (#31) Coattails 8.5042
11. (#32) We Had Everything 8.475
12. (#42) Bridges 8.25
13. (#44) Mother & Father 8.2083
14. (#46) Everything Goes (Wow) 8.175
15. (#52) Sucker 8
16. (#53) Evergreen 7.9917
17. (#58) Never Gonna Change 7.8875
18. (#61) Four Walls 7.75
19. (#65) Too Proud 7.6583
20. (#76) Sleep Baby Sleep 7.2208

Most 10s: Peach (6)
11s: Recovery (1) L.A.F (1)
Lowest score: Peach (3)

Voter averages:
1. @Music Is Death 9.65
2. @Phonetics Girl 9
3. @Untouchable Ace 8.76
4. @Epic Chocolat 8.49
5. @BubblegumBoy 8.385
---average---
6. @berserkboi 8.25
7. @Cutlery 8.175
8. @Remorque 8.1125
9. @Crisp X = @soratami 7.9
11. @DJHazey 7.725
12. @klow 7.65
 
giphy.gif

av. 8.4660

1. (#1) Magic 9.5833
2. (#3) My Delirium 9.4167
3. (#6) Embrace 9.1875
4. (#8) Wild Things 9.0167
5. (#9) Black White & Blue 9
6. (#10) A Love Song 8.9667
7. (#11) Sunday Drive 8.9417
8. (#22) Guilty Love 8.6083
9. (#25) Dangerous 8.5583
10. (#30) Love Don't Live Here 8.5083
11. (#34) Manipulating Woman 8.4208
12. (#35) Let It Roll 8.4083
13. (#36) Sweet Fascination 8.4042
14. (#37) Crazy World 8.3167
15. (#38) The River 8.3
16. (#47) Morning Dreams 8.1583
17. (#62) Cellophane 7.7458
18. (#66) Gone Gone Gone 7.6333
19. (#74) The Quick & The Dead 7.3667
20. (#80) Vanity 6.7792

Most 10s: Magic & My Delirium (6)
11s: Magic (2) My Delirium (1) Embrace (1)
Lowest score: Vanity (3)

Voter averages:

1. @Music Is Death 9.9 the stannage!!!!
2. @Phonetics Girl 9.275
3. @berserkboi 9
4. @Untouchable Ace 8.815
5. @soratami 8.75
---average---
6. @Remorque 8.4625
7. @Cutlery 8.3
8. @BubblegumBoy 8.24
9. @DJHazey 8.125
10. @klow 7.875
11. @Epic Chocolat 7.7
12. @Crisp X 7.15
 
So that would be it. Thanks to everyone who participated or engaged with the rate in any way. You'll never know how much motivation to push through and keep the reveals on track I got from every single comment.
Just for kicks, I decided to look up the distribution of my 10s between the artists and look how it went:

Bic Runga: 2
Kimbra: 8
Ladyhawke: 10
Broods: 8
The Naked and Famous: 2

There's nothing premeditated about that, swear!

However tired of rates I'm feeling at the moment, I have a new project for 2022 that will involve much less writing and much more copy-pasting, which is perfect for me. Hope to see you all there soon! Hint: Magic will be eligible.
 

Top