This rate was a trainwreck, but you were flawless @Petty Mayonnaise
All Rates On Deck: R&B Queens, The Sequel (WINNER ANNOUNCED!)
- Thread starter Petty Mayonnaise
- Start date
2014
Staff member
Thanks @Petty Mayonnaise! Countdown is great so the winner could have been worse.
he/him
Countdown winning goes a long way to remedying the disservice that was done to Beyoncé (and the general messiness of the results) throughout this rate and when Love on Top left before the top 10 I REALLY didn't think she had a chance. But yes!!! I re-listened to Countdown yesterday after saying I preferred 2 On and I might have been wrong. It's so so manic and exciting and iconic.
Thank you for taking the reins of this rate and revealing the forum's questionable taste @Petty Mayonnaise!
Thank you for taking the reins of this rate and revealing the forum's questionable taste @Petty Mayonnaise!
ohnostalgia
Staff member
She/her
Exactly @Lost In Japan. I love that Bey prevailed even though a third of this rate was gunning for her. I also relistened to Countdown yesterday and I think it's slightly better than 2 On.
I'm still not over Feeling Myself being trashed and Janet failing to make the Top 10.
I'm still not over Feeling Myself being trashed and Janet failing to make the Top 10.
she/her
Wait, 'Overdose' didn't win?!
You can tell I don't belong here...
You can tell I don't belong here...
ohnostalgia
Staff member
She/her
It's an R&B rate not a pop songs rate!
she/her
Exactly.
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAS!
he/him
You've won this round, but the basic bop lovers will have their revenge.
Thank you @Petty Mayonnaise it was a lot of fun catching up with the rate and everything, I also discovered my general taste is somewhere halfway between @DJHazey and @A&E and this is giving me life.
God I haven't posted on PJ for months and apologies for letting this rate nearly go down the shitter! Thank god for @Petty Mayonnaise .
A little tea for y'all from my rate...
- Mariah won easily with You Don't Know What To Do and Overdose came second.
- Other notable top 10's - #Beautiful, No Sleeep.
- Tinashe had the highest album average. 2 On was her highest ranking track but only came in at #10.
- Nicki had the worst album average followed closely by Mariah, then Janet, Bey and Ciara after that.
- Countdown was in the Top 10, but Love On Top was Bey's highest ranking track.
The rest was pretty similar.
XX
A little tea for y'all from my rate...
- Mariah won easily with You Don't Know What To Do and Overdose came second.
- Other notable top 10's - #Beautiful, No Sleeep.
- Tinashe had the highest album average. 2 On was her highest ranking track but only came in at #10.
- Nicki had the worst album average followed closely by Mariah, then Janet, Bey and Ciara after that.
- Countdown was in the Top 10, but Love On Top was Bey's highest ranking track.
The rest was pretty similar.
XX
I cannot believe how much more satisfying that original list looked like. I blame ALL newcomers.
he/him
he/him
I love Mariah but thank god You Don't Know What to Do didn't win.
