All Saints

Mvnl

Mvnl

Staff member
Not saying that going 'Where are the Appleton's, have you fallen out again?" is a reasonable response (or even any of your business) based on a post of 2 members having fun together, but Shaznay replying 'why have you asked me this question?' isn't extremely reaffirming either.
 
D

Deleted member 29593

It may sound a bit disrespectful, but he's just a concerned fan. I did not expect her to answer...

1686041068855.png
 
Mvnl

Mvnl

Staff member
Oh yeah I get that. But still, what's going on between them privately is not information they owe any of us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kal
kermit_the_frog

kermit_the_frog

Mvnl said:
Not saying that going 'Where are the Appleton's, have you fallen out again?" is a reasonable response (or even any of your business) based on a post of 2 members having fun together, but Shaznay replying 'why have you asked me this question?' isn't extremely reaffirming either.
Click to expand...

I think she’s saying “why are you asking me to answer on behalf of someone else when you could just ask them directly? Is it because you want to cause trouble?”

By this point every one of them will be fed up with provocative questions from “fans”…
 
Mvnl

Mvnl

Staff member
kermit_the_frog said:
I think she’s saying “why are you asking me to answer on behalf of someone else when you could just ask them directly? Is it because you want to cause trouble?”

By this point every one of them will be fed up with provocative questions from “fans”…
Click to expand...

Yeah guess it makes sense if the emphasis is on 'me'!
 
Simone

Simone

Love that answer from Shaznay.
I know that we all would love to have another new album soon but a break is not a bad thing after 2 new albums and many years touring. I'm sure they will be back when they will feel ready to

I just wish they would release the first 3 albums on vinyl in the meanwhile :)
 
Saintsfan

Saintsfan

Simone said:
Love that answer from Shaznay.
I know that we all would love to have another new album soon but a break is not a bad thing after 2 new albums and many years touring. I'm sure they will be back when they will feel ready to

I just wish they would release the first 3 albums on vinyl in the meanwhile :)
Click to expand...
Wow. What a reply by Shaz..all is OK then but just shows we can't use insta posts to judge a situation.

As someone said on here, we have no right to know about personal friendship but we can ask about the band as professionals.
 
kal

kal

I'm gonna be a bit blunt here. It's incredibly creepy when people go to such lengths to take note whether celebrities like each others' posts on instagram, in an attempt to out "drama" or bad blood between them.

A real fan won't be going on such fishing expeditions. Literally nobody (besides tabloids?) benefits from that.

Kudos to Shaz for the graceful response. She didn't have to dignify it at all.
 
Obscenely Delicious

Obscenely Delicious

A good answer from Shaz, for whatever reason that clearly hit a nerve, but a lot of this could have been avoided if they'd acknowledged the gig cancellations directly at the time instead of hearing the reason of "unforeseen circumstances" second-hand from promoters which ultimately could mean anything.

Regardless of the real reason, a simple "we've had a brilliant few years but we've decided to take a break to focus on our own lives and careers for a while, hope to see you all in the future" post to at least give the official line would have done the job. It's all felt quite cloak and dagger.
 
Saintsfan

Saintsfan

Obscenely Delicious said:
A good answer from Shaz, for whatever reason that clearly hit a nerve, but a lot of this could have been avoided if they'd acknowledged the gig cancellations directly at the time instead of hearing the reason of "unforeseen circumstances" second-hand from promoters which ultimately could mean anything.

Regardless of the real reason, a simple "we've had a brilliant few years but we've decided to take a break to focus on our own lives and careers for a while, hope to see you all in the future" post to at least give the official line would have done the job. It's all felt quite cloak and dagger.
Click to expand...

Yean agreed. I think that's for the management to do I'd say.

They're definitely on a break and I think that's what just needed to be said at the time so there wouldn't be these kinds of questions and comments.

When it's left wide open we start trying to fill in the gaps and clearly get it wrong!
 
bonnieetclyde

bonnieetclyde

Have those comments since been deleted? I can't see them?

Anyway, with Shaznay saying she definitely hasn't fallen out with Appleton and it being mentioned in that recent Appleton interview that All Saints were ''on a break'' I guess we just have to assume they all need a time out from the band.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member 29593

bonnieetclyde said:
Have those comments since been deleted? I can't see them?

Anyway, with Shaznay saying she definitely hasn't fallen out with Appleton and it being mentioned in that recent Appleton into that All Saints were ''on a break'' I guess we just have to assume they all need a time out from the band.
Click to expand...


The comments were there very early this morning. I saw that person had responded again and Shaz may have deleted it all for that reason.
 
jamesyboy

jamesyboy

Could be wrong but the person asking the question doesn’t seem like English is their first language so Shaz probably took it the wrong way. I don’t think there was any bad intentions with asking them the question, maybe they could’ve just asked when All Saints are back.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top