American Horror Story | Page 233 | The Popjustice Forum

American Horror Story

Discussion in 'TV + Film' started by Someboy, Oct 4, 2011.

  1. If Twisty wasn't killed so soon, Freakshow would've been iconic. But of course, Ryan wants to turn it into Glee.

    Also, I find it absolutely hilarious that if you just watched the first episode of Freakshow it would've been enough as a short film. A true testament to Mr Murphy's talent.
     
    maneater83 likes this.
  2. It would just become Scream Queens 2.
     
  3. Aliens next season, or I'm out.
     
    Meathook, kal and Shockbox like this.
  4. Sarah Paulson playing an alien from 50 different planets.
     
    popBrit, Mr. Humes, Lapras and 9 others like this.
  5. kal

    kal

    As much as I want this, Ryan would probably botch the execution, if he even goes for the idea, which seems like a reach.
     
    P'NutButter likes this.
  6. What song will she/they sing?

    And in which episode will we be shown the ACTUAL story/cast (yay plot twist!) in flashbacks, flashforwards and flash in between and etc.
     
    Shockbox likes this.
  7. I think they should revisit the concept they were working on before Gaga signed on and it became Hotel -- Civil War. We're overdue for a 'period piece' season and it lends itself to all kinds of deranged and fucked up characters, plus it could integrate the makeshift hospitals they set up for amputations and bullet extractions

    Basically, give me Gone With the Wind horror edition
     
  8. Tribal Spaceman

    Tribal Spaceman Staff Member

    And then shortly after we could have Slasher season 16: Uncivil Whores, which borrows heavily from it.
     
  9. I'm pretty sure Ryan would botch any concept at this point, they need to take some time, breath and welcome new writers, new ideas and even new actors, I wouldn't mind a season with a partly new cast and new talent, get rid of Evan Peters, whom I assume is bored as fuck of the series based on his last performance and keep Kathy Bates only if they are actually planning to give her something to work with and a genuine creepy character.

    The finale was... not the worst episode of the season, that's a lot considering. They tried to tie some loose points at the last minute, the young couple for example, and it fell flat on its face, I bet 80% of the viewers didn't even remember who they were. I agree with Ryan casting some crushes here and there and getting them naked sometimes, I can't blame him I would do the same on his position, but for the love of god, understand the difference of an eye-candy actor and a real one, next time restrict yourself and avoid giving them main roles.
     
    Rob and Dee91 like this.
  10. I liked this, I thought it was one of the least offensive seasons in terms of overall quality. It could have all been, like, 90 minutes long but the extra stuff was not as shit as the main chunk of most seasons, and it was short enough to tolerate all the way through unlike every single other season. I also think that Cordelia and Myrtle had more and better development than in Coven, I enjoyed them more.
     
    biffy77, Tribal Spaceman and rav4boy like this.
  11. Roanoke gets a bad rep from some people, for me it was one of the better seasons...:

    Ayslum
    Murder House / Coven
    Roanoke
    ...
    Apocalypse / Freak Show
    ...
    Hotel
    Cult
     
    Last edited: Nov 24, 2018
    Cosimo, Karvel and rav4boy like this.
  12. Not sure this is accurate for me since it's been a while since I last ranked them,
    but I am pretty confident about it.

    Pretty Great:
    Asylum
    Roanoke (first half)
    Freakshow

    Decent:
    Hotel
    Murder House
    Apocalypse

    Utter crap:
    Roanoke (second half)
    Cult
    Coven
     
  13. [​IMG]
     
  14. Asylum
    Apocalypse
    Roanoke
    Coven
    Murder House

    The rest.
     
  15. Murder House
    Coven
    Roanoke

    Apocalypse
    Asylum


    Freakshow


    Cult



    Hotel
     
    Holly Something likes this.
  16. [​IMG]
     
    Lapras, Meathook, Raw Sugar and 5 others like this.
  17. Roanoke (not sorry)
    Asylum
    Apocalypse
    Murder House
    Coven
    Hotel
    Cult

    Yet to see Freak Show.
     
    Mr. Humes likes this.
  18. YUP. I find Asylum too torture porn-y, which I don't like. Plus, throw in the aliens, the Nazis, and pretty much everything else and it ends up being too messy. Apocalypse is mostly just a mess as well but I was entertained. I love witches, what can I say.
     
  19. Murder House/Asylum
    Coven

    Roanoke
    Hotel/Apocalypse

    Freakshow
    Cult

    The bottom two I never finished as they just bored me.
     
  20. I think it’s more likely she’d play 50 different aliens from one planet.
     
    Meathook and Tribal Spaceman like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.