Are you ready for this? The Red Velvet Discography Rate (Due April 19) | Page 3 | The Popjustice Forum

Are you ready for this? The Red Velvet Discography Rate (Due April 19)

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by eccentricsimply, Mar 21, 2020.

  1. I might take part in this just so I can be the rate villain. Red Velvet "lost" me in 2017 but this might be a fun excuse not do to any important "working from home" work.
    Serg., evilsin, PopZeitgeist and 3 others like this.
  2. ysev and Cotton Park like this.
  3. This high score better means you give your 11 to Body Talk xx

  4. aux


    Just how many pictures of these girls holding guns do y'all HAVE
  5. All of them need manicures.
    eccentricsimply, evilsin and ysev like this.
  6. Choose your fighter





    Vixen, Serg., nikkysan and 5 others like this.
  8. Listening to The Red now and I hope it doesn't get done dirty here. I mean Dumb Dumb? Campfire?
    Oh Boy? Lady's Room? Cool World? all classics!
  9. You know, it's a good thing I've sent my ballot this early. It gives me a few weeks to prepare myself for the forthcoming hot takes. I hope I won't make any enemies during the reveals. You better not slander any of my high scored songs.

    Or else

  10. If you’re going to purposely score low every song after 2017 I might tell you to rescore dddd
  11. I would never do that! I still love a lot of their album tracks after 2017. I mean, Sunny Side Up might even get my 11. Maybe. It's just the title songs/singles that I feel nothing for and that will be scored accordingly.
    ysev, nikkysan, PopZeitgeist and 2 others like this.
  12. Alright!!!

    This is more of an overall warning too. If anyone plans on purposely scoring low an entire concept for instance, then I’m going to ask to rescore.
    Kuhleezi, ysev and nikkysan like this.
  13. Submitted!

    ICC 7.5
    The Red 8.2
    The Velvet 7.8
    Russian Roulette 6.43
    Rookie 8.5
    The Red Summer 8.55
    Perfect Velvet 8.58
    The Perfect Red Velvet (just the three added songs) 9.67
    Summer Magic 7.58
    RBB 9.5
    RVF D1 8.96
    RVF D2 7.08
    RVF Finale 8.75
    #Cookie Jar 6.67
    Sappy 8.83
    Extras 6.94
    I am not surprised that RBB, (The) Perfect (Red) Velvet and Day 1 are my highest rated projects.
  14. I have five ballots counting mine so I'll post some tea #soon
    Ugly Beauty, Kuhleezi, Vixen and 5 others like this.
  15. I’ll post my averages too xx

    Ice Cream Cake - 8.1 (10 x 2, 6.5 x 1)
    The Red 8.75 - (10 x 4, 6 x 1)
    The Velvet - 6.9 (9 x 1, 5 x 1)
    Russian Roulette - 7.9 (9 x 3, 6.5 x 1)
    Rookie - 8.1 (10 x 1, 5 x 1)
    The Red Summer - 8.8 (10 x 1, 7 x 1)
    The Perfect Red Velvet - 8.5 (10 x 4, 6.5 x 1)
    Summer Magic - 8.75 (11 x 1, 10 x 2, 7 x 2)
    RBB - 9.2 (10 x 2, 8 x 1)
    The ReVe Festival Day 1 - 9.41 (10 x 4, 8 x 1)
    The ReVe Festival Day 2 - 7.3 (9 x 1, 6 x 1)
    The ReVe Festival Finale - 8.0 (10 x 1, 6 x 2)

    Japanese Songs - 6.9 (9.5 x 1, 4 x 1)

    Extras - 6.125 (6.5, 6 x 1)
  16. Day 1 the highest average and a likely 11 to Power "PAK" Up? We stan an intellectual!
    nikkysan and aux like this.
  17. I will get started on this today. I look forward to re-discovering their first full album the most as that was always my favourite.
  18. Update: I do not think this is the rate for me. My scores are ... not really worth sending in.

    Please know that I would have given Automatic my 11. Or Sunny Side Up. But other than that I can't really find that many gems like everyone else.
  19. I’ve been crazy busy and only just noticed this! So so excited.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.