Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - The Results! | The Popjustice Forum

Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - The Results!

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by Music City Queen, Mar 16, 2014.

  1. A bit of fun, just to see where people would rank the singles from Atomic Kitten.

    Voting is via PM. Deadline is March 30th. Rate between 1 and 10, give a comment on the song if you like. I'm uncertain of when the original version of Cradle was released, so it's just Cradle 2005 that is in this list.

    Here's the singles in order of release:

    Right Now
    See Ya
    I Want Your Love
    Follow Me
    Whole Again
    Eternal Flame
    You Are

    It's Ok!
    The Tide Is High (Get The Feeling)
    The Last Goodbye
    Be With You
    Love Doesn't Have To Hurt

    If You Come To Me
    Ladies' Night
    Someone Like Me

    Right Now 2004

    Cradle 2005

    Anyone Who Had A Heart
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 9, 2014
  2. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate

    voting via pm or comment?
     
  3. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate

    What's the deadline?
     
  4. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate

    Don't forget Cradle!
     
  5. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate

    Vote via PM, deadline will be Sunday 30th March and Cradle has been added, thank you for reminding me!
     
  6. moorje

    moorje Guest

    Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    I'm so tempted to troll this poll and give everything a 0, apart from Be With You which I'll give a 10.
     
  7. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    Whole Again (Kerry Version) 10, the rest 0.
     
  8. SBK

    SBK

    Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    This. Deduct points for Jenny versions of Kerry originals.
     
  9. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    Don't mean to poop on the party but there is a waiting list for rates...

    Request your rate, here.
     
  10. SBK

    SBK

    Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    But who made you guys boss of the forum?
     
  11. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    I'm playing by the rules yo, don't shoot the messenger!
     
  12. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    Hmph. It's a good job you can't see how offended my face looks right now...

    (I keep telling people they can sack me and we can go back to a free-for-all, but it never seems to be a very popular suggestion).

    (Seriously, though, I'm clearly not the boss of anyone. The queues only work by mutual consensus, and if people decide they don't want to do things that way, there's nothing I can do about it, nor would I really want to).
     
  13. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    It's more out of respect but the lists thread hasn't been touched in a while (and we haven't had a regularly updated rate in a while), seeing as there is interest and it seems a fairly short list you should probably go ahead with it anyway, though if anyone in the queue at the moment wants to do theirs they shouldn't see this one as a reason not to put it out.
     
  14. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    I'm tempted to do this. Are we voting for the proper version of Whole Again or the crap Jenny one?
     
  15. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    Vote for the version you prefer. Same with any of the singles that Jenny re-recorded for the Right Now album re-issue.
     
  16. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    Jenny's version of Whole Again is so, so much better. I'll never understand people's preference for Kerry's voice.
     
  17. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    The video for "Cradle" has Kerry, so it had to have been some time before "Whole Again."

    This is the only acceptable version of "Whole Again."

    I didn't realise how good their discography really was until now. Lowest score was a 4, with four 9's and two 10's. Even given that there are four 5's, that's pretty impressive by my standards.
     
  18. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    'It's OK' is such a tune.
     
  19. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    I will be doing this before the deadline!
     
  20. Re: Atomic Kitten: The Singles Rate - Deadline: Sunday 30th March

    So glad I discovered this I luv me some Atomic Kitten.

    Especially If You Come to Me.
     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.