BIG POP GIRLS 2022 - THE END

He/Him
CRASH getting the girls ruffled up is so entertaining to see

yasseduction-charli-xcx.gif
 

aux

he/him
62

NTktNTMwNC5qcGVn.jpeg


7.1134

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 9 (@Solenciennes, @CorgiCorgiCorgi, @Sanctuary, @Dangerous Maknae, @Phloo, @soratami, @Trinu 3.0, @lovechoerrymotion, @Heartthrob)
LOWEST SCORE: 0 x 1 (@rdp)
MY SCORE: 6.75



On paper, a collaboration between Charli XCX and Rina Sawayama should be, at the very least, great. Particularly for myself, I love both artists separately. Despite my adoration for Taylor Swift's folklore and evermore, I'd say my favourite pandemic album remains being how I'm feeling now. Rina Sawayama is a phenomenal popstar who is on the cusp of immense success with two phenomenal albums under her belt. It just feels weird that this song came out the way it did. To me, it's just so... mediocre.

Before I dig into the track, there's a couple of things worth raising. The first part is that, while it is their first released collaboration, there was another one in the past. During the Charli era, Rina Sawayama and Charli XCX worked on a collaboration that was meant to be on that album. It was ballad. They decided that they'd rather work together on something more upbeat and waited for the "right" moment. It was then when this song was sold to Charli and she decided it should be their collaboration.

The other bit is that the song samples September's iconic, single hit, "Cry For You". The song has gone viral many times, but it particularly peaked in popularity with a tweet referencing the an infamous disappearance of a child. "Cry For You" is actually a really solid pop song, particularly, the chorus. This is where my issue with "Beg For You" lies. The reason that "Cry For You" smacks is because of that chorus. And fair enough, I think it can be adapted to the lyrics in this song, but the issue is that they lead to this boring ass drop that is so limp, it ruins the whole song.

I really think something like "Afterlife" should've been the blueprint for this. That, to me, remains one of the best songs Rina has ever done. On top of that, it suits Charli's sound so well. That would've been the obvious answer had it not been for this album where Charli is allegedly selling out. I guess it makes sense for it to be a bit devoid of much if she's essentially making an Ava Max album, but I digress.

There's just so much more that could've been done. It's just a bit disappointing all around. I'm not surprised this is going out now and I agree with it. I still play the song a lot since I did enjoy most of CRASH and I'm the sort of person who listens to albums (as opposed to making playlists), but it feels like an outlier within CRASH as well. It's just really bizarre.



 

Solenciennes

Staff member
I found Beg For You whelming too, I have to admit, but it absolutely delivered the Sellout Big Pop Girl energy Charli promised and actually, that being the point, it's a fun, mindless bop that gave two underrated pop stars a bona fide hit and definitely contributed to CRASH getting to number 1 on the album charts. A 10 for what it represents in Charli's (and Rina's) career, if not for its musical merits nn.
 
I found Beg For You whelming too, I have to admit, but it absolutely delivered the Sellout Big Pop Girl energy Charli promised and actually, that being the point, it's a fun, mindless bop that gave two underrated pop stars a bona fide hit and definitely contributed to CRASH getting to number 1 on the album charts. A 10 for what it represents in Charli's (and Rina's) career, if not for its musical merits nn.
I actually enjoy the song well enough, but calling it a bona fide hit is a huge reach. It only charted in a handful of countries and has less than 100 million streams on Spotify.
 

Solenciennes

Staff member
I actually enjoy the song well enough, but calling it a bona fide hit is a huge reach. It only charted in a handful of countries and has less than 100 million streams on Spotify.

It was Charli's highest charting hit since 2018 and Rina's first ever chart hit, I'd actually hear it out in the wild in public too which is just anecdotal but to me felt like an actual release that reverberated beyond the internet.
 
He/Him
If we were rating the AG Cook remix I’d have considered giving this a 10 because it SLAPS (that outro does things to me) but in its original form it lives forever stuck in the shadow of it’s sample.
 
Top