BIG POP GIRLS 2022 - THE END

I think the definition of Big Pop Girl has changed dramatically since 2016's blockbuster year for much of the old guard of BPG status and including different artists in these rates is a good democratic way to find out who's in and who's out. Certainly she's not on a commercial even footing with Taylor and Beyoncé, very few artists are, but we've given so many other relative newcomers their chance in these rates, it's fun!
Agree that it’s fun and happy @aux included it, but given how the other three albums crossed over in the US at least, I don’t think of something like Used to Know Me/ New Shapes having a “single effect” like Despecha or Anti Hero so it’s bizarre they’re still in but I’m also sort of shrug about it (my feelings will switch once beyonce loses a song before one of those leave)
 

aux

he/him
38

ODYtNDcxMi5qcGVn.jpeg


7.9012

11 x 1

@rdp

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 10 (@Joe., @Andy French, @Purple, @Maria, @Robert, @Remorque, @Stradiwhovius, @thommyh, @lovechoerrymotion, @heavymetalgaga)
LOWEST SCORE: 2 x 1 (@Trouble in Paradise)
MY SCORE: 8.5



"LA FAMA (feat. The Weeknd)" was the lead single from MOTOMAMI. It's a bachata song, but it does not have the iconic acoustic guitar of that genre. Instead, it opts for a vocal sample which replaces the guitar. It's kind of iconic if you ask me. It follows through with a lot of what Rosalia's career has been about - exploring these classic genres through her lens, modernising them and showing them to a new audience or an established audience who does enjoy that genre. It's part of the fun of her career. I know the optics of it are a mess sometimes and I won't get into it, but it's really what's made Rosalia be Rosalia.

This song was a perfect lead single for MOTOMAMI. It signals a clear shift from EL MAL QUERER, which we knew was coming already judging from the droplets, but still. However, despite being such a clear shift, it still has a through-line with EL MAL QUERER's ethos: updating a genre. The song continues Rosalia's shift into a global superstar, the feature is an obvious attempt to step into the English-speaking market. It didn't work in the US, at least, with the song peaking at #94. The more I think of it, I can't think of any other song to work on the standard album as a crossover hit, so I guess they tried!

This song was written in 2018. It was written as a solo song, but when Rosalia had the chance to collaborate with The Weeknd on a remix, they made a deal to collaborate for each others' albums. This is the second collaboration between the pair and I hope it's their last. This is not an Ariana Grande and The Weeknd collaboration where they tend to work fairly well. Rosalia, for whatever reason, hopped on a remix of "Blinding Lights" which is as awful as it sounds. This was their first collaboration. The Weeknd hops on this track returning the favour of bringing a completely useless feature. He does nothing. The solo version Rosalia performs on tour is miles above this.

 

rdp

he/him
Forgot to send commentary but basically I love the mix of the sensual, hazy rhythms of the melody with the soap opera dramatics of the lyrics. Stuff like "If you want to, sleep with her, but never marry her" reminds of me other spanish/portuguese songs I love with similar expressions that are kinda corny but in a good way - sometimes being corny is just the best way to express a feeling etc etc. Plus the live performances really make the song shine as said above

 
38

ODYtNDcxMi5qcGVn.jpeg


7.9012


LOWEST SCORE:
2 x 1 (@Trouble in Paradise)
MY SCORE: 8.5



It follows through with a lot of what Rosalia's career has been about - exploring these classic genres through her lens, modernising them and showing them to a new audience or an established audience who does enjoy that genre. It's part of the fun of her career. I know the optics of it are a mess sometimes and I won't get into it, but it's really what's made Rosalia be Rosalia.​

And this is what makes the song a 2 for me. From The Weeknd feature to the overblown wow! She is a bachata pioneer for this limp noodle.
 
39

AJEc9qq.jpg


7.8983

HIGHEST SCORE:
10 x 17 (@Sanctuary, @AllGagaLike, @Dangerous Maknae, @Jersey, @RetroPhysical, @Mr Blonde, @Blond, @Ashling92, @soratami, @unnameable, @DinahLee, @reputation., @Dreampopboy, @Laurence, @Music Is Life & Death, @papatrick, @Petty Mayonnaise)
LOWEST SCORE: 4 x 2 (@Monkey Meat, @Trouble in Paradise)
MY SCORE: 8



And with this elimination, four songs from Midnights remain.

"Maroon" sonically, feels like the spiritual sequel to "Dress". It has that same sultriness that song has. It's a bit shoegazey, but not as much as previous Taylor songs have. The song feels really intimate too. I know we were dragging her for the "concept" of this album, if any, but I feel like this song does suit some of the core concept of the album. A lot of Midnights feels confessional, the type of conversations you'd have in the middle of the night, and "Maroon" sounds as such through its production.

One thing that has rung true for most of this album is that, at least for me, it's 1989 via folklore and evermore. Essentially, some of the songs on the album feel like grown up, mature versions of what 1989 would look like if it were made today. "Maroon" is one of these songs. Lyrically, the album is effectively a folklore song.

The song also connects to "Red", for obvious reasons. All the colours mentioned in the song are shades of red, one way or another. In "Red", Taylor says that love is "burning red". She's mentioned in the past that red, for her, is the colour of a certain type of intense love that burns bright and fast. In a lot of ways, that's what the album Red is. In "Daylight", a later song from Lover, she revises this and says it's "golden". This clearly refers to her love in her current relationship, considering how introspective that song is.

It's interesting that she returns to shades of red for this song, showing that the love depicted in this relationship is the type that was described in "Red", but somehow, more mature. This is what I mean when I say that this album is 1989 via her last two albums. It's a newfound sense of maturity and growth that just wasn't there before in her pop albums. It elevates the record significantly.

I'm glad to see this make top five of Midnights, since it's a bit of an underrated one I find. It's not one of my favourites, but it's really solid and suits the album pretty well. In fact, I think it's up there as one of the songs that fixes a lot of the issues people tend to have with Taylor, but I digress.

The song has yet to be performed at The Eras Tour, so here's "Dress".


Um. This left way too early. Wtf.
 

aux

he/him
37

NTktNTMwNC5qcGVn.jpeg


7.9128

11 x 1
@Mushroom

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 11 (@Dijah., @fatyoshi, @Mr Blonde, @Andy French, @Sprockrooster, @FINISH LINE, @Music Is Life & Death, @Petty Mayonnaise, @lovechoerrymotion, @Trouble in Paradise, @heavymetalgaga)
LOWEST SCORE: 3 x 1 (@daninternational)
MY SCORE: 8



A discussion I had today was about the feeling of anger. It's interesting because it's an emotion that has plenty of negative connotations. It's not seen as a positive thing, to be angry. While we spoke about this in relation to films that deliberate anger viewers, a lot of the discussion was based on psychology and philosophy being applied to that. At the core, some academics argue that anger is actually a positive thing because it reaffirms your self-worth and self-respect. Essentially, being angry over something that was undeservedly done to you, makes you are of the respect you deserve.

"Plan B" is a song about this. It's about seeing your self-worth after being mistreated and not feeling you deserved better. "Plan B" served as the second single from her second studio album, Traumazine. The song was debuted at Coachella, but before that, she teased the song saying that it got the girls riled up. She knew the song was valuable and needed to be debuted live before it came out. As always with a Meg song, she oozes charisma and sells the shit out of the song. The song is so classic hip-hop, it samples a remix of "Freek'n You" with Jodeci and Wu-Tang Clan.

While Megan denies it, and says the song is about all of her exes and not someone in particular, it could easily be seen as a song written about Tory Lanez. In December of last year, he was convicted of assault and a couple other charges in relation to this. He's sentenced to 22 years in prison for shooting Meg. We had to celebrate! As an aside, it's so incredible to see her get justice and I will always ride for her because of how much flack she got over this. It's insane that there was ever any doubt on the events when there was so much evidence. We saw it all happen in real time.

The song is a banger, props to Meg for constantly uplifting everyone through her music.

 
Top