BIG POP GIRLS 2024

[BTG]

Love the songs from Wicked, love the girls’ vocals, but the execution on the soundtrack meant I had to dock some points.

This I will reluctantly accept, and yet…

 

[Secret]

I love Peter from the (devastating) bridge onwards but

Oh, hm, yes I underscored this in retrospect I guess but the melody on “said you were gonna grow up THEN you were gonna come find me” is a bitsy grating, sorry!

basically! It's why I don't revisit it particularly often and scored it a 6.

I'll be getting my insufferable Tortured Poets stanning on later in the rate though. You guys didn't avoid me going full psychotic about this album just because I was on my forum break.

 

[Sam de Jour]

11 x 1
@Lila

 

[CIOB]

Anything For Love is still not out.

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

OH also Peter pairs really well with Wendy by Maisie Peters.

 

[boom bazooka joe]

Love the songs from Wicked, love the girls’ vocals, but the execution on the soundtrack meant I had to dock some points.

This is acceptable for Popular (girl what was that autotuned vocal mess on that one part) but WHAT IS THIS FEELING DID NOTHING WRONG.

 

[RJF]

Groundbreaking

GOOD FUCKING NIGHT.

 

[Music Is Life & Death]

Anything For Love is still not out.
View attachment 62968

Yeah I would like to see it (and Club classics) leave soon.

 

[LTG]

This is acceptable for Popular (girl what was that autotuned vocal mess on that one part) but WHAT IS THIS FEELING DID NOTHING WRONG.

It starts out with the sound of a pen scratching out a letter. It’s horrible. Leave that to the film, not the album.

 

[Lila]

Me whispering what I’d love to say but can’t because I’m still a moderator

 

[Mirwais Ahmadzaï]

Someone please tell me what's so appealing about Club classics?

i wanna dance to
me
me
me
me
me

 

[klow]

Someone please tell me what's so appealing about Club classics?

The appeal to me is chiefly the part of the song between 0:45 to 0:58, which I would say are the most exhilarating 13 seconds of music in this entire rate

 

[soratami]

Yeah @Music Is Life & Death you're going to be waiting a while for that one. I too have a couple of fan faves from two of these albums I can't stand, but it'd be pointless to call for them this early, so I'm keeping my mouth shut... for now

 

[Verandi]

In defense of baby @aux, I've met her twice in London and both times she was wearing Eras Tour merch, so despite 2 poor scores she's still insane braver than the US Marines.

 

[Lila]

Me pivoting to my second 11 choice which was Girl so confusing

Me and @Sam de Jour settling our differences in Dalston's own The K Hole if he lets me do the Lorde part

 

[Stradiwhovius]

On Peter I could... on paper love it, but I just really can't connect with the idea of a megastar who found fame at a young age relating more to Wendy than Peter.

 

[Joe.]

@RJF having the highest host scores for all these Taylor porkchops?

 

[SMG]

‘Peter’ is top 5 on Tortured Poets.

 

[happiestgirl]

I need all those unlistenable Chappell Roan ballads out now. Besides California, that can go top 10.

 

[Sam de Jour]

Me and @Sam de Jour settling our differences in Dalston's own The K Hole if he lets me do the Lorde part

You: "YOU WALK LIKE A BITCH" when I was 30 @Sam de Jour said that sorry if you're not 30 yet I can't remember how old you are x

But also as IF I'd let you do that part