BIG POP GIRLS 2024

[constantino]

Can you all fight until Monday evening? Let’s see.

This rate having office hours is sending me.

 

[Stradiwhovius]

What fucking song are you even talking about

I am... guessing Bittersuite and I am on record as giving that a 10.

 

[Dijah]

The Diner…?

 

[Gabeee9292]

The Diner…?

Yes nn

 

[boom bazooka joe]

Need greedy and French Exit to get the fuck out.

 

[Serg.]

I mean I'll take 'The Diner' being called, as it is the worst song on the album with a theme she's previously written about but its not her time yet.
I mean I love Ariana but Intro is still here... nn

 

[Subwaykid]

Let’s say bye to bye on Monday

 

[cosmicfox]

bye to bye

to bye
to bye
to bye

I don't wanna say goodbye to her

 

[Euphoria]

Y'all are fucking crazy. Guilty Pleasure and The Diner? Both 10s.

End of the World, Bye, Blackbird, Amen, 3/4 of that Dua album, I Think About It All The Time, Mean Girls, Texas Hold Em, Flamenco, HISS, Greedy, Yes And?, Florida!!!, Clara Bow, After Midnight, Bittersuite, and The Black Dog can all exit before those. Thank yew.

 

[Inland Empire]

Guilty Pleasure is top 3 on that album and The Diner is the best thing on HMHAS and shouldn’t be leaving at least until Femininomenon is out

Eternal Sunshine is mid and is around about due a culling

Nothing from Radical Optimism is even close to kicking out territory yet

Discipline is a misunderstood piece of avant-garde futurepop and is a top 3 Janet album if not her absolute best

 

[Mushroom]

Eternal Sunshine is mid

Nothing from Radical Optimism is even close to kicking out territory yet

 

[Adam]

I would rather see SKINNY go before THE DINER, even though I only scored them 0.25 apart. Maybe I'm a proud big gal!

I'd also love to see these go before we get into the top 100;

intro (end of the world)
Spring breakers
I think about it all the time
I Hate It Here
California
ordinary things (feat. Nonna)
Everything is romantic

 

[dirtypony]

For me, Hit Me Hard and Soft and Eternal Sunshine are the best albums here - neither of them deserve to lose anything yet.
We could lose a couple of extras before we get to Dua’s.

 

[soratami]

I'm sorry but if there's anything that needs culling it's Cowboy Carter. That album still has so many songs left and could definitely lose at least like half a dozen now, and nothing of great value would be lost.

 

[Consideration]

Let's cull more Taylor tibbs

 

[estfer]

The calls for I think about it all the time. Get fucking taste.

 

[Maki]

I'm sorry but if there's anything that needs culling it's Cowboy Carter. That album still has so many songs left and could definitely lose at least like half a dozen now, and nothing of great value would be lost.

I agree but clearly this is not a safe space to call for any Beyoncé song. Like, some were even defending "OH LOUISIANA" ff

 

[Stradiwhovius]

APT. is an absolute racket and should have been one of the first tracks out.

 

[Subwaykid]

APT. is an absolute racket and should have been one of the first tracks out.

Most of the extras have overstayed their welcome with the exception of Ms. Nasty and Roan if we're having that conversation

 

[Sam de Jour]

Angel of My Dreams and APT. for top 2 x