Beb, the whole Britney Jean was included in the rate despite it not featuring Britney herself fff.
BIG POP GIRLS 2024
- Thread starter aux
- Start date
Let's be serious please, saying this interlude is in any way, shape or form better than greedy or any of Taylor's songs is just crazy talk. It was lucky to last as long as it did.
dd I think I read somewhere that Britney provided bits and pieces of (mostly) backing vocals throughout the album except on that song so I didn't want to be too harsh.
He/Him
Oh I'M HIS, HE'S MINE got a 6.5 from me and is definitely the best Katy song in the rate (not saying much of course ddd). The production is fairly boppy, the pre-chorus is nice and my favorite vocal moment from her across the three songs, and I like the contrast between her and Doechii. No big loss though.
LIFETIMES was my least favorite song in the rate and got a 4 for me. I mostly just think it's very boring and tired, and feels like a million artists could have released it. Like it's probably fine in the grand scheme of things but it just doesn't have anything particularly interesting in the production, melodies or lyrics. The 4 is pretty much entirely for Katy's voice. Good riddance. I do find it hilarious that Katy was out completely before anything else and didn't make it to #143.
And I do think both Katy songs would have gotten at least a few more points from me if Luke wasn't attached to them.
Oh. I Love You, I'm Sorry got a 9 from me. I didn't expect it to last long but yikes. Yeah it's fairly basic and I do think Taylor could release a more interesting version of it, but I still like the melodies throughout, her voice is pleasant and the lyrics are nice enough. It's a solid package overall even if there's a hundred songs like it that are also better. I enjoyed the songs in Gracie's set on my date at The Eras Tour but I haven't listened to any of her music since then.
Oh Louisiana is my lowest score on COWBOY CARTER with a 6 and honestly I like the production a lot and I don't mind that it's short but the vocals are low-key extremely grating. It probably would have been an 8-9 if Bey actually sang it herself.
Overall a pretty good start for me. Woohoo!
LIFETIMES was my least favorite song in the rate and got a 4 for me. I mostly just think it's very boring and tired, and feels like a million artists could have released it. Like it's probably fine in the grand scheme of things but it just doesn't have anything particularly interesting in the production, melodies or lyrics. The 4 is pretty much entirely for Katy's voice. Good riddance. I do find it hilarious that Katy was out completely before anything else and didn't make it to #143.
And I do think both Katy songs would have gotten at least a few more points from me if Luke wasn't attached to them.
Oh. I Love You, I'm Sorry got a 9 from me. I didn't expect it to last long but yikes. Yeah it's fairly basic and I do think Taylor could release a more interesting version of it, but I still like the melodies throughout, her voice is pleasant and the lyrics are nice enough. It's a solid package overall even if there's a hundred songs like it that are also better. I enjoyed the songs in Gracie's set on my date at The Eras Tour but I haven't listened to any of her music since then.
Oh Louisiana is my lowest score on COWBOY CARTER with a 6 and honestly I like the production a lot and I don't mind that it's short but the vocals are low-key extremely grating. It probably would have been an 8-9 if Bey actually sang it herself.
Overall a pretty good start for me. Woohoo!
Any/All
It was lucky to outlast... Katy Perry and Gracie Adams?
The interlude is mid, but some of the tracks still in are outright bad.
He/Him
Realizing most of my sub-8 scores are gone so that just leaves
Club classics
I might say something stupid
Everything is romantic
Kaleidoscope
Wishful thinking that I'll see any of the Charli songs leave soon though.
Club classics
I might say something stupid
Everything is romantic
Kaleidoscope
Wishful thinking that I'll see any of the Charli songs leave soon though.
he/him
I don’t care that Oh Louisiana is out but wasting a beautiful 0 in it is so silly to me.
she/her
...........I actually scored it higher than Grammy-winning song II MOST WANTED. dddddd
I'm actually quite pleased I gave it my 0, since it got no others. Not a waste!
He/Him
This song is never going to be remembered (This sentence could accurately end here) @Alchemy Jones v2.0 this got me goooood
Wtf is Kaleidoscope
He/Him
