COMPLETE - The Indie/Alt Pop/Not-quite-'Mainstream'-but-still-accessible Girls 2017 Rate!!1

Jersey

Jersey

Petty Mayonnaise said:
The shortest way I can think to put it is it's like a little bit of Prince and Madonna were put through a 2017 alternative lens while still feeling very St. Vincent.
Click to expand...

It's settled.

tenor.gif


10's all around.
 
Number

Number

I can't get into St. Vincent at all and it bothers me. I've tried with each album since Strange Mercy and nothing sticks outside like, Digital Bopness nn. Gave Masseduction a spin yesterday and... shrug.
 
constantino

constantino

LEADERBOARD TEA - ROUND ONE (10 voters in)

I know it's still early days but I'm so excited to have a spreadsheet to analyse (that aren't the datasets I'm using for my stats assignments ddd), so here is your first helping of tea:

- As I said, talent is winning. The top 3 is excellent and my 11 is currently second without me even putting my scores in...so yay!
- In a shocking turn of events, 6/7 sections (including extras) are included in the top 10, with the highest rated song from the 7th album sitting literally just outside at #11.
- In fact, the sections are spread across the elimination order to the point where no single album is dominating.
- The Extras are fairing extremely well so far.
- A song with 2 of the 11s given so far is clinging onto the top 40...at #40...
- The song I thought was definitely gonna win is currently at #22.
- If this is any indication of what the actual order is gonna be...gag.

That's your lot...for now!

giphy.gif
 
Last edited:
Edu

Edu

Do you wanna be a hero?
Can I lay in your arms?
VHCkdPY.gif

Can you tell me it's alright
Even though I know it's not?
Woo oooh
VHCkdPY.gif

Can I lay back into the dark?
(In your arms, baby)
(In your arms, baby)​

Make sure you're giving this one the high score it deserves, sistren.
 
Trouble in Paradise

Trouble in Paradise

He/Him
constantino said:
LEADERBOARD TEA - ROUND ONE (10 voters in)

I know it's still early days but I'm so excited to have a spreadsheet to analyse (that aren't the datasets I'm using for my stats assignments ddd), so here is your first helping of tea:

- As I said, talent is winning. The top 3 is excellent and my 11 is currently second without me even putting my scores in...so yay!
- In a shocking turn of events, 6/7 sections (including extras) are included in the top 10, with the highest rated song from the 7th album sitting literally just outside at #11.
- In fact, the sections are spread across the elimination order to the point where no single album is dominating.
- The Extras are fairing extremely well so far.
- A song with 2 of the 11s given so far is clinging onto the top 40...at #40...
- The song I thought was definitely gonna win is currently at #22.
- If this is any indication of what the actual order is gonna be...gag.

That's your lot...for now!

giphy.gif
Click to expand...
Cue my anxiety about y'all not living for Masseduction and loving "Los Ageless" like me.

((also afraid to post my averages for how much I stanned St Vincent and how much I trashed Charli))
 
HeartSwells

HeartSwells

Number said:
I can't get into St. Vincent at all and it bothers me. I've tried with each album since Strange Mercy and nothing sticks outside like, Digital Bopness nn. Gave Masseduction a spin yesterday and... shrug.
Click to expand...

Teebs nothing she’s done has surpassed Actor for me, there’s this unsettling mix of gentle baroque with her signature guitar work, at a stretch it’s sort of Adz-esque in the way it melds them together. It’s way more interesting and bit more subtle than anything she put out after. I think it might be more your thing.

 
constantino

constantino

Reading this thread, your scores and your commentary is...interesting...some of y'all are in for a shock...

Also: THREE WEEKS LEFT!!!
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top