Destiny's Child: The Discography Rate - Your Winner is Announced! | The Popjustice Forum

Destiny's Child: The Discography Rate - Your Winner is Announced!

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by EnsnareTheSenses, Jul 31, 2018.

  1. [​IMG]

    Can you pay your bills?
    Do you only ring his celly when you're feeling lonely?

    Do you waaAAannt a foot ruUub, waAAaant a mAAAaaaNnicure? Wait.


    *

    Welcome, Children of Destiny, to Destiny's Child: The Discography Rate!

    Yes, Popjustice. Let me Cater 2 U, 'cause if you've been waiting for the discography rate of one of history's biggest-selling, most iconic groups of all time, then this is your day (okay, I did not think I'd have made three references to that song by 50 words in).


    I was truly surprised that one of music's greatest trios (well, after a certain point, but more on that later) had yet to be gifted with a classic PJ discography rate amongst those of us with taste. Thus, it inspired me from the heart (I've committed to this), and I have to say, it is a true honour to be at the helm of the rate of one of the most influential and defining groups to have existed in my lifetime.

    But more on that later too - I've gotta get my slippers, my dinner, my dessert and so much more, and get this thing going!


    *

    Choosing the best selection of songs for this rate was quite tricky, in that whilst I obviously want it to be fairly comprehensive, I had to draw a line somewhere. So, I made a few calls:

    - Only tracks where DC are the main artist have been included.
    - Only tracks with the presence of more than one member have been included - Beyoncé solo tracks from these albums have not been included.
    - Prominent soundtrack songs, originals, singles, and extras have been included.

    Let me know, however, if there are songs that you would like to be added to/taken off the list – I’ll be more than happy to make amends!


    I'm setting the closing date for votes at
    Friday September 14th, 11:59pm BST. Then, I’ll probably take the weekend to get everything in order, ready to kick things off at the top of the following week.


    In case anyone isn’t aware, here are the fairly standard ground rules for rates:

    1. Rate all of these songs from 0 – 10. Naturally, when rating a discography this dense, decimals will be allowed to make fine distinctions - keep them sensible.
    2. As always, the trusted 11 will come in very handy here to push your absolute favourite track beyond to clinch the title. 11s can really have a huge impact, so use your singular 11 wisely!
    3. Not that I think this situation will arise, but troll ballots won’t be accepted, and will be discarded faster than Farrah Franklin was from the DC 2.0 line-up.
    4. Commentary is encouraged, particularly for the more… prominent songs. You know the ones. I’m planning on keeping at least the first 1/2 of this rate pretty lean, so if you don’t comment on outros, and buried album tracks from 1998, I’m really not going to be distraught in the slightest. There's a fair amount we can get through pretty quickly here.
    5. If you could please submit your scores in the order that’s listed, that would be absolutely ideal. It will save me a lot of hassle in the remaining hour of the voting period when I’ll inevitably receive 70% of all submissions coming into my inbox at once.


    *

    And that’s the main stuff covered! Heathy, thriving discussion is encouraged, and please, vote consistently in the way that makes sense to you – not just the way you see things may or may not be heading from comments littered throughout the thread.

    Take time with this! Destiny's Child has a rich catalogue. Listen once, listen twice, and above all, have fun!

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Sep 9, 2018
    soratami, phily693, Island and 18 others like this.
  2. [​IMG]

    PM List:

    Destiny's Child (1998)

    [​IMG]

    Second Nature
    No, No, No Part 2 (featuring Wyclef Jean)
    With Me Part I (featuring Jermaine Dupri)
    Tell Me
    Bridges
    No, No, No Part 1
    With Me Part II
    Show Me the Way
    Killing Time
    Illusion (featuring Pras)
    Birthday
    Sail On
    My Time Has Come (dedicated to Andretta Tillman)
    Know That
    You're the Only One

    The Writing's on the Wall (1999)

    [​IMG]

    Intro (The Writing's on the Wall)
    So Good
    Bills, Bills, Bills
    Confessions (featuring Missy Elliott)
    Bug a Boo
    Temptation
    Now That She's Gone
    Where'd You Go
    Hey Ladies
    If You Leave
    Jumpin', Jumpin'
    Say My Name
    She Can't Love You
    Stay
    Sweet Sixteen
    Outro (Amazing Grace…) (dedicated to Andretta Tillman)
    Get on the Bus (featuring Timbaland)
    Can't Help Myself

    Survivor (2001)

    [​IMG]

    Independent Women Part I
    Survivor
    Bootylicious
    Nasty Girl
    Fancy
    Apple Pie à la Mode
    Sexy Daddy
    Perfect Man
    Independent Women Part II
    Happy Face
    Dance With Me
    Emotion
    Dangerously in Love
    Brown Eyes
    The Story of Beauty
    Gospel Medley (dedicated to Andretta Tillman)
    Outro (DC-3) Thank You

    Destiny Fulfilled (2004)

    [​IMG]

    Lose My Breath
    Soldier (featuring T.I. & Lil Wayne)
    Cater 2 U
    T-Shirt
    Is She the Reason
    Girl
    Bad Habit
    If
    Free
    Through with Love
    Love
    Gots My Own
    Game Over
    Why You Actin'
    2 Step

    Misc.

    [​IMG]

    Once a Fool (featuring William Floyd)
    Stimulate Me (featuring Mocha)
    No More Rainy Days
    Dot
    My Song
    Bootylicious (Rockwilder Remix) (featuring Missy Elliott)
    8 Days of Christmas
    Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
    I Know
    Stand Up for Love
    Nuclear
    You Changed
    Say Yes
    Feel the Same Way I Do
    Winter Paradise
    A 'DC' Christmas Medley
    Spread a Little Love on Christmas Day
    Home for the Holidays
     
    Last edited: Sep 9, 2018
  3. [​IMG]

    83. Intro (The Writing's on the Wall) - 4.45
    82. Outro (DC-3) Thank You - 4.58

    81. Winter Paradise - 4.86
    80. Killing Time - 4.95
    79. Spread a Little Love on Christmas Day - 5.15

    78. Home for the Holidays - 5.19
    77. Gospel Medley (dedicated to Andretta Tillman) - 5.20
    76. Outro (Amazing Grace…) (dedicated to Andretta Tillman) - 5.31

    75. My Time Has Come (dedicated to Andretta Tillman) - 5.34
    74. Birthday - 5.38
    73. Stimulate Me - 5.39
    72. A 'DC' Christmas Medley - 5.43

    71. Love - 5.52
    70. Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer - 5.56
    69. My Song - 5.71

    68. Why You Actin' - 5.860
    67. Feel the Same Way I Do - 5.865
    66. If - 5.88

    65. Tell Me - 5.90
    64. Bridges - 5.91
    63. Once a Fool (featuring William Lloyd) - 5.92

    62. You're the Only One - 5.95
    61. With Me Part II - 5.96
    60. No More Rainy Days - 6.06

    59. Free - 6.08
    58. Game Over - 6.09
    57. Sexy Daddy - 6.13

    56. Cater 2 U - 6.16
    55. Sweet Sixteen - 6.17
    54. Can't Help Myself - 6.20
    53. Gots My Own - 6.36

    52. Sail On - 6.38
    51. 2 Step - 6.39

    50. I Know - 6.54
    49. Apple Pie à la Mode - 6.56

    48. Is She the Reason - 6.57
    47. T-Shirt - 6.59
    46. Stay - 6.63

    45. Stand Up for Love - 6.74
    44. Second Nature - 6.77

    43. Nasty Girl - 6.78
    42. Dance With Me - 6.80
    41. She Can't Love You - 6.83

    40. Show Me The Way - 6.87
    39. Bootylicious (Rockwilder Remix) - 6.88
    38. Know That - 6.90

    37. Bad Habit - 6.952
    36. Confessions (feat. Missy Elliott) - 6.954
    35. No, No, No Part 1 - 6.98
    34. Dot - 6.99

    33. Independent Women Part II - 7.04
    32. Now That She's Gone - 7.062
    31. You Changed - 7.064

    30. Perfect Man - 7.20
    29. Nuclear - 7.22
    28. 8 Days of Christmas - 7.23

    27. Brown Eyes -7.25
    26. The Story of Beauty - 7.29
    25. Fancy - 7.34

    24. If You Leave - 7.40
    23. With Me Part I (featuring Jermaine Dupri) - 7.52

    22. Happy Face - 7.61
    21. Girl - 7.65

    20. Where'd You Go - 7.71
    19. Temptation - 7.84

    18. Dangerously in Love - 7.97
    17. So Good - 8.09

    16. Hey Ladies - 8.21
    15. Illusion (featuring Pras) - 8.30

    14. Get on the Bus - 8.63
    13. Emotion - 8.73

    12. Soldier (featuring T.I. & Lil Wayne) - 8.83
    11. No, No, No Part 2 - 8.89
    10. Say Yes - 8.94
    9. Through with Love - 9.08
    8. Bootylicious - 9.10
    7. Survivor - 9.25
    6. Bug a Boo - 9.47
    5. Jumpin' Jumpin' - 9.52
    4. Bills, Bills, Bills - 9.70
    3. Independent Women Part 1 - 9.71
    2. Say My Name - 9.98
    1. Lose My Breath - 10.35
     
    Last edited: Mar 5, 2019
  4. [​IMG]

    Reserved. I'm just going to shut over my laptop lid, because I have to be up for work in like, 5 hours or something.​
     
    Last edited: Jul 31, 2018
  5. Guessing we can post now? Already iconic posts @EnsnareTheSenses !!!! I don't know their album tracks at all but with work slowing down hopefully in the next few weeks, I should be able to take part and rediscover why I loved these girls so much back in the day. May I ask - will you be doing a SPOTIFY list?
     
  6. Definitely doing this!

    I have their last two albums but I don't think I actually ever listened to the first two, so looking forward to discovering some gems among the album tracks.
     
  7. Where is "This is The Remix" ?

    OK probably we won't rate all those remixes, but you should include "Bootylicious (Rockwilder Remix feat. Missy Elliott)" that's a secure 8 to 11.
     
    TRAVVV and londonrain like this.
  8. Definitely here for this. The Writing's On The Wall to thrash all else.
     
  9. londonrain

    londonrain Staff Member

    Every single one of these albums has multiple 10s and some completely dispensable filler, but those 10s... whew.

    Definitely up for this!
     
    Island, TRAVVV, Remorque and 7 others like this.
  10. So excited to do this one!
     
    berserkboi and EnsnareTheSenses like this.
  11. 2014

    2014 Staff Member

    definitely here for this! especially if you keep digging gifs like these up x
     
    phily693, TRAVVV, londonrain and 5 others like this.
  12. Thank you so much! I was honestly delirious typing most of it, so I'm actually surprised in the light of day that it's fairly coherent. Ooh, I'll definitely look into doing that, yes - might need to be a little fragmented as there will definitely be some YouTube-only tracks here, but still.

    Good spot! I skimmed over it, completely forgetting that track had received special treatment, so to speak. I'll have another look-through things tonight, and will definitely pop that one on to the 'misc' list! I'll let you all know what's been added.

    yas welcome!

    I just realised I dropped this in the middle of the damn night for most of us, so I'm off to do a bit of promo x
     
  13. Not their collaborations? Say Yes and Whatever Kelly’s song was called?
     
    EnsnareTheSenses likes this.
  14. Poor the competition if Say YAS gets included.
     
    Island, Mushroom, londonrain and 4 others like this.
  15. Say Yes would get my 11.
     
    londonrain and berserkboi like this.
  16. Did they really record Amazing Grace twice?
     
    londonrain likes this.
  17. Saw this yesterday and I'm intrigued in doing this.

    The main reason is that I've listened to Beyonce's full discography a year ago and Destiny's Child would be a great addition.
    The only album that I've listened to in full is "Destiny Fulfilled" last year, and I've forgotten the most of it, so relistening to it a few times would be nice.

    I'm looking forward to discovering gems from their discography.
     
  18. So many excellent singles and some hidden gems on the albums of course! Through with Love better get the love it deserves. I should be able to do this if I manage to score all the tracks before my rate starts.
     
  19. londonrain

    londonrain Staff Member

    You Changed.

     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.