GFRIEND - the discography rate ☾ #14

[junglefish]

Lea-leaderboard tea? In my GFRIEND rate? Never thought I'd see the day!

Yes buddies, we have finally hit 5 voters nn, so here goes:

• Out of 5 voters, only one has given their 11 to a title track
• A title track is winning
• Only one song has an average below 5
• One album has taken quite a beating
• We got way too many ties so hurry and help us break them!

I'd also like to announce our new deadline:

Voting closes Thursday, March 31, 11:59 pm

This is the FINAL FINAL deadline. There won't be any more extension, so please send us your ballots before then.
I'll ask the lovely @Slice of Life to tag you all in a couple days, just in case.

 

[eatyourself]

• Out of 5 voters, only one has given their 11 to a title track

One two three four five six seven... you make me regret my 11.

• A title track is winning

On second thought... Stop the count!

• One album has taken quite a beating

Poor Labyrinth!

 

[savilizabeths]

I really love the 11 picks so far. I know the titles will wind up getting 11s in the end but I appeciate the b-side picks so far!

 

[boom bazooka joe]

Scores submitted.

Season of Glass 6.83
Flower Bud 7.5
Snowflake 7.6
LOL 6.15
The Awakening 8.08
Parallel 7.58
Rainbow 8
Time For The Moon Night 8.33
Sunny Summer 7.5
Time For Us 8.18
Fever Season 8.5
Fallin' Light 8.06
Labyrinth 8.5
Song Of The Sirens 7.75
Walpurgis Night 9.57 (ffff)
Extras 6

I only shelled out 9 10s, since so much of this music was new to me and it I usually need to sit with a song for a while before it screams 10 to me, but I also didn't give out more than 4 scores below a 6, so the consistency in quality is definitely there! I definitely discovered a number of gems on this list, and I'm very curious how my scores do or don't align with the general consensus.

 

[soratami]

LOL 6.15

I see you haven't learned anything since the debuts rate.

 

[boom bazooka joe]

I see you haven't learned anything since the debuts rate.

Some of my scores got better!

Spoiler

And some of them got even worse!

 

[Cotton Park]

I'd also like to announce our new deadline:

Thank you for the extension. My life has been crazed lately, but I am committed to this!

 

[junglefish]

Thank you for the extension. My life has been crazed lately, but I am committed to this!

You’re welcome! I’m happy you’ll be joining us!

So far, the scores are pretty surprising! Not what I expected but it’s a good thing… I think!

 

[Monado]

About halfway done, will try to submit by the weekend!

 

[RUNAWAY]

@junglefish and @savilizabeths just wanted to let you know that the song One-Half from the 5th mini is titled One Hall in the PM list. My scores will be coming soon, nearly done!

 

[savilizabeths]

@junglefish and @savilizabeths just wanted to let you know that the song One-Half from the 5th mini is titled One Hall in the PM list. My scores will be coming soon, nearly done!

Fixed! Thank you so much, I genuinely can't believe I never noticed that.

 

[RUNAWAY]

FINALLY done with my scores! I wouldn't be surprised if I have one of the highest overall averages. Their discography is just without fault aside from a couple early songs. Rooting for my non-single 11 to do well, and I can't wait for this to start!!!

Edit: AVERAGES

Season of Glass: 9.583333333
Flower Bud: 8.75
SNOWFLAKE: 8.95
LOL: 8.225
The Awakening: 9.166666667
RAINBOW: 9.28125
Time for the Moon Night: 9.5
Sunny Summer: 9.4
Time for Us: 8.772727273
FEVER SEASON: 10.00
Fallin' Light: 9.25
回:LABYRINTH: 9.875
回:Song of the Sirens: 9.583333333
回:Walpurgis Night: 10.125
Extras: 8.1875

Ffffff I.....regret NOTHING. Girls would KILL for the quality of those last 3 releases.

 

[savilizabeths]

You lot and your non-single 11s. Buddies are really superior, I swear!

 

[boom bazooka joe]

回:Walpurgis Night: 10.125

And I thought my 9.57 was extra as hell.

 

[soratami]

Just noticed this dd

 

[Slice of Life]

Just got to Here We Are…….

Pleek Buddies, let’s not do this little masterpiece wrong!!!!! I am begging!!!!!!! That chorus just sends me to another dimension!!! And I promise you will also be sent to another dimension (aka the Banned Members list) if you decide to tank it!!!!

 

[Slice of Life]

​

WHERE ARE YOUR VOTES?!
​

☾​

@askew
@aux
@berserkboi
@BEST FICTION
@Capitan
@Charles Vingt-†rois
@chrisjche
@clowezra
@Conan
@Cotton Park
@Crisp X
@eccentricsimply
@eliminathan
@enjoy
@evilsin
@GeiPanda
@Glitterizer
@He
@HippoSteaks
@Hurricane Drunk
@Inland Empire
@Island
@Joli Chat
@KimLippington
@Kuhleezi
@leedlelee...
@Love Deluxe
@lovechoerrymotion
@Monkey0
@Music Is Death
@nikkysan
@Pretty Places
@Rainbow Trousers
@Rem
@Remorque
@SalineDijon
@Serg.
@SloMover
@soratami
@ThighHighs
@thommyh
@ultraviolet
@vague
@Vixen
@Wills

☾

You have until MARCH 31 to send us your ballots.
Don't disappoint us.​

 

[soratami]

I've rated about a third of the songs so far, should be finished by the weekend.

 

[Monado]

About halfway done, will try to submit by the weekend!

Suffice to say I failed this deadline ddd but it's coming, I promise.

 

[ysev]

Such a beautiful Spring song! Makes me wanna wear a school uniform and dance in front of a school yard embellished with cherry blossom trees! The beauty of youth…


Please please don’t tank it!!!