Girl Band VS. Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) Winner and Runner-Up

The time has come to pit 4 of the most prolific, on this forum at least, UK Girl Groups of the last two decades. All of their singles will go head to head in the ultimate Battle Royale and compete for your votes.

Voting rules: 0-10 score system (half points are acceptable) PLEASE rate them in the order they appear below for my sake. 80 singles is hard enough to keep track of. Re-votes are not allowed as we have all had ample time (17 years for some singles) to process them. Realizing you had switched votes or pressed the wrong number and it needs correcting is allowed, but don't take me for a fool.

Feel Free to send your comments/criticisms etc in a separate PM and mark it as such.

The Nominees Are:
Spice Girls
Wannabe
Say You'll Be There
2 Become 1
Who Do You Think You Are
Mama
Spice Up Your Life
Too Much
Stop
Viva Forever
Goodbye
Holler
Let Love Lead The Way
Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)

Sugababes
Overload
New Year
Run For Cover
Soul Sound
Freak Like Me
Round Round
Stronger
Angels With Dirty Faces
Shape
Hole In The Head
Too Lost In You
In The Middle
Caught In The Moment
Push The Botton
Ugly
Red Dress
Follow Me Home
Easy
Walk This Way (vs. Girls Aloud)
About You Now
My Love Is Pink
Change
Denial
Girls
No Can Do
Get Sexy
About A Girl
Wear My Kiss

Girls Aloud
Sound Of The Underground
No Good Advice
Life Got Cold
Jump
The Show
Love Machine
I'll Stand By You
Wake Me Up
Long Hot Summer
Biology
See The Day
Whole Lotta History
Something Kinda Ooooh
I Think We're Alone Now
Sexy! No No No
Call The Shots
Can't Speak French
The Promise
The Loving Kind
Untouchable (Single Edit)
Something New
Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me

The Saturdays
If This Is Love
Up
Issues
Just Can't Get Enough
Work
Forever Is Over
Ego
Missing You
Higher (ft. Flo Rida)
Notorious
All Fired Up
My Heart Takes Over
30 Days
What About Us (ft. Sean Paul)
Gentleman
Disco Love
Not Giving Up

Don't Judge Lest Ye Be Judged.
 
Last edited:
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Results
#80: Beautiful Cause You Love Me
#79: I Think We're Alone Now
#78: Walk This Way

#77: Headlines (Friendship Never Ends
#76: Get Sexy

#75: Wear My Kiss
#74: See The Day
#73: I'll Stand By You
#71 (Tie): Girls
#71 (Tie): Let Love Lead The Way

#70: Just Can't Get Enough
#69: Gentleman
#68: Angels With Dirty Faces
#67: 30 Days

#66: Long Hot Summer
#65: Soul Sound
#64: My Love Is Pink
#62 (Tie): Missing You
#62 (Tie): Forever Is Over
#61: My Heart Takes Over


#60: Issues
#59: Follow Me Home
#58: Mama
#57: If This Is Love

#55 (Tie): Jump
#55: Easy

#54: About A Girl
#53: No Can Do
#52: Shape
#51: Change
#50: In The Middle
#49: New Year

#48: Life Got Cold
#47: Holler
#46: Caught In The Moment
#45: Whole Lotta History

#44: Ugly
#42 (Tie): Work
#42 (Tie): Wake Me Up
#41: Disco Love


#40: Red Dress
#39: Notorious
#38: Love Machine
#37: What About Us?

#36: Denial
#35: Can't Speak French
#34: Too Much

#33: Goodbye
#32: Not Giving Up
#31: The Loving Kind
#30: Untouchable

#28 (Tie): Ego
#28 (Tie): About You Know
#27: Higher

#26: No Good Advice
#25: Who Do You Think You Are
#24: Up
#23: Wannabe
#22: Overload


#20 (Tie): Too Lost In You
#20 (Tie): The Promise
#19: The Show

#18: 2 Become 1
#17: Round Round
#16: Stronger

#15: Run For Cover
#14: Push The Button
#13: Stop

#12: Something New
#11: Sound Of The Underground


#10: Hole In The Head
#9: Something Kinda Ooooh

#8: Say You'll Be There
#7: Spice Up Your Life

#6: Biology
#5: All Fired Up
#4: Sexy! No No No...
#3: Viva Forever
#2: Freak Like Me
#1: Call The Shots
 
Last edited:
He / Him / His
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Spice Girls - 4.77
Sugababes - 6.78
Girls Aloud - 7.47
The Saturdays - 6.91

----------------------------------------

Spice Girls: 10x1 / 0x0
Sugababes: 10x2 / 0x0
Girls Aloud: 10x4 / 0x1
Saturdays: 10x2 / 0x1
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

FUCK

Right I'm gonna mark these now...
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Oh my.

This is going to be intense.
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

I don't know if I should listen to these before marking but this is very exciting.
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

The darkest clouds of shade are looming...
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Unfortunately, at least for me, Theme To St. Trinian's is ineligible. While it did chart from digital downloads, the song was removed from a la carte buying to avoid confusion with their real single at the time Call The Shots.

It will appear in the GA B-Sides and rarities rate.
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Coming for my rate crown, are you?
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Really looking forward to this. What happened to 'Freedom' though? Is it excluded because it was a freebie?
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

This will be amazing. More than anything, I'm excited to see Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me leave in last place. Anything more than a 0 average will be too much.
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

This rate is incredible. Sugababes have to win. That list of singles is just...flawfree? There's about 2 duds. Amazing.

Such a fucking shame Girls Aloud had to ruin their discography with so many shitey covers, they coulda had this.
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Also, can I please give 'Overload' 50/10?
 
Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Coming for my rate crown, are you?
My production values will sadly fall short.

Really looking forward to this. What happened to 'Freedom' though? Is it excluded because it was a freebie?
It's considered a promo single, so I didn't think it qualified.

Also, can I please give 'Overload' 50/10?
While I considered giving a certain single an 11, anything greater than a 10 will be rounded down.
 
D

Deleted member 11652

Re: Girl Band Versus Rate (Spice vs. Suga vs. Aloud vs. Sats) VOTING ENDS APRIL 7-8th: BST 5AM/EST

Uh oh.
 

Top