Discussion in 'Comeback corner' started by marknyc, Nov 16, 2007.
Wasn't this on the radio at one stage? Or uploaded online and then replaced?
I’m not sure to be honest! I remember a story that she was cut from the final edit because of issues within the group but I’m not sure how true that is.
She sounds great on it though!
When they uploaded the lyric video they accidentally used the demo version, which they quickly replaced with the final version.
"That song 'Beautiful 'Cause You Love Me' - that, I don't like at all! I listened to it and I was like 'Hang on a minute, so I'm only beautiful because you tell me!?' I'm not on board with that. I'm beautiful anyway, not because you told me."
"We should all be like that. We don't need people to validate ourselves. So I just said, I'm not gonna sing on that song."
She was happy enough to sing on the demo though? She definitely has that opinion because of the fan reaction.
We know Nadine recorded most of the demos before the girls would lay down their vocals. So I always took it as more of a "You can delete me from that one."
This is only the case with Xenomania I believe, this probably worked differently.
I feel like we go over this every 6 months or so.
Hmm good point. I mean I can imagine they all probably laid down the vocals for it, but I still think if she didn't outright ask to be removed, she probably just didn't put up much of a fight for a solo line or two.
I’m so bored of it, especially because of the barrage of abuse that gets thrown my way. I don’t even bring it up!!!
So we don't need to go in circles about this again. People can state their feelings about the song without having to be met with a defense from either side that isn't necessary. Some people like it, some people don't. Stop taking it personally (to everyone involved) and making a personal crusade about a song that I'm sure none of these women wake up and think about eight years after the fact.
Hers. She said that she didn't want to be on the track and just did the "my baby" bits.
Still can't believe she did these.
I CANT TELL YOU HOW SAD I FEYUHL
I gave my custom TEN vinyl a spin today. "On The Metro" just SLAPS.
Never seen these! Thanks for posting!!
Confirms that Memory Of You should have been performed as a 5 at some point live! It sounds fab!
I wish they had kept it like this with Sarah having the full second verse just brushed it up with a second vocal take, she would've gotten it together live and Nadine and Nicola on the chrous.
Praying all albums get a pressing one day.
I'll hate myself for paying for the custom print/vinyl pressing when and if it ever does (please be a purple/black swirl queens i BEG), but it was a cool little project for myself!
Separate names with a comma.