I Came, I Saw, I Conquered: The Madonna Discography Rate, Part III - The 21st Century

53_She_s_Not_Me.jpg


Direct Link




HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 7 (@Voodoo @LOTF @vikeyeol @Jonathan27 @Andy French @Future Lover @Mister_G)
LOWEST SCORE: 2 x 2 (@Anastasia Beaverhaus @Mikey1701)​
 
Last edited:
I really like She's Not Me but it was probably time for it to go. The S+S performance kind makes it great.

Body Shop is a ridiculous elimination. I think as has been evidenced already by Pop Gaz, some people were put off on first listen and so never "got it". Bye I guess.
 
I listened to "Body Shop" many times, mostly because it got such positive reaction here, and it just never goes anywhere. It's elevator muzak. It's not offensively bad, it's not amazing, it's just sitting there for some reason. Filler.
 
There's still wayyyy too much Rebel Heart in. I'd lose everything bar Living For Love, Devil Pray and Ghosttown (though Bitch, Hold Tight and Addicted can last a little longer too). Still, the EIGHT other tracks can fuck off now.
 

Top