I Came, I Saw, I Conquered: The Madonna Discography Rate, Part III - The 21st Century

Square · Oct 28, 2015

AM I FINALLY GOING TO SNATCH THAT #1?!?!?!

Deborux · Oct 28, 2015

I really, really want Nothing Fails to take it all the way now. Second isn't good enough. I wish I'd given it my 11.

Island · Oct 28, 2015

SERIOUSLY!?!?!?

Ugh. 'Hung Up' should win, I guess.

that boy is a monster · Oct 28, 2015

I actually thought Get Together would win. Huh. Lovely write up, @RJF.

Syzygyz · Oct 28, 2015

DISASTER.

Nothing Fails it is then.

Babylon · Oct 28, 2015

Devastating.

RJF · Oct 28, 2015

Tomorrow...

It ends.

Deborux · Oct 28, 2015

RJF said:
Tomorrow...

It ends.

I love that the two songs in the finale couldn't be more different. She's just the best.

Ray · Oct 28, 2015

"Hung Up" shouldn't win, but it will.

I'm down to two songs I don't care about. Goodbye "Get Together", you almost got my 11. It wouldn't change anything anyway. But I love you and we'll be having a moment later in the dark away from tasteless gays who think "time goes by so slowly" represents poetic lyricism.

RUNAWAY · Oct 28, 2015

Don't Tell Me should've won.

Syzygyz · Oct 28, 2015

Since Get Together didn't win, I probably should've given my 11 to Love Spent.

Deborux · Oct 28, 2015

Hung Up's middle eight is one of the best things in her entire career.

Babylon · Oct 28, 2015

Syzygyz said:
Since Get Together didn't win, I probably should've given my 11 to Love Spent.

Let's not say things like this in the heat of the moment please.

VivaForever · Oct 28, 2015

YESSSSS. YES YES YES.

Even if Nothing Fails falls at the last hurdle, top two is so much further than I would have expected it to go. I do wish we'd had Hung Up out here so it would be between Nothing Fails and Get Together, because I could stomach a Get Together win more easily than a Hung Up win.

sexercise · Oct 28, 2015

This is the first rate where I've been 100% confident (available on iTunes) in my 11. Easily one of the greatest pop songs of all time and I'm lowkey adding anyone who says it deserves below the top 2 onto my ignore list.

Babylon · Oct 28, 2015

I'm definitely backing Nothing Fails.

strangekin · Oct 28, 2015

At least Get Together has a fucking amazing write up

Deborux · Oct 28, 2015

Although I'm rooting for Nothing Fails, I'm currently getting my life to Hung Up

I can't keep on waiting forever
I know that you're still hesitating
Don't cry for me, 'cause I'll find my way
You'll wake up one day and it'll be too late

Glorious.

that boy is a monster · Oct 28, 2015

Hung Up was the last time Madonna ruled the world. It'd be a more than worthy winner. Also, it's a fucking brilliant song.

Sprockrooster · Oct 28, 2015

AAAAH! FOR THE LIFE OF ME! Nothing fails is in no universe better than get together. Hung up better wins this now