I Think I'm Gonna Win This Time: The One Direction Discography Rate | Page 124 | The Popjustice Forum

I Think I'm Gonna Win This Time: The One Direction Discography Rate

Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by ohnostalgia, Apr 1, 2016.

  1. Because it's great!
     
    constantino and Lost In Japan. like this.
  2. eccentricsimply

    eccentricsimply Staff Member

    I thought it was a hallucination amongst the 1D fandom to think that song is good.

    I've been with this post open for the longest time but I just have no words for how Wrong (feat. Kehlani, buy it on itunes) you are.
     
    CorgiCorgiCorgi and ohnostalgia like this.
  3. I'm torn between devastation at I Would and being genuinely satisfied with most of the top 10.

    The ideal ranking:

    10. Stockholm Syndrome (why still here???????)
    9. Tell Me A Lie
    8. They Don't Know About Us
    7. What A Feeling
    6. What Makes You Beautiful
    5. Kiss You
    3. One Thing
    3. Best Song Ever
    2. No Control
    1. Fireproof, obvs
     
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  4. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    Yes, post your Top 10 lists. Also we're at the Top 10. No excuses for not submitting some commentary!!!
     
  5. Dream top 10 is:

    10. They Don't Know About Us
    09. One Thing
    08. Best Song Ever
    07. Tell Me A Lie
    06. What Makes You Beautiful
    05. What A Feeling
    04. Stockholm Syndrome
    03. No Control
    02. Fireproof
    01. Kiss You
     
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  6. 10. Kiss You
    9. Stockholm Syndrome
    8. They Don't Know About Us
    7. One Thing
    6. Tell Me A Lie
    5. No Control
    4. Best Song Ever
    3. What Makes You Beautiful
    2. What A Feeling
    1. Fireproof
     
  7. Scream at "Tell Me a Lie" making the top ten. Kelly's impact!
     
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  8. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    You're in danger.
     
    Sprockrooster likes this.
  9. 10. They Don't Know About Us
    9. What A Feeling
    8. Fireproof
    7. One Thing







    6. Kiss You
    5. Tell Me A Lie
    4. Stockholm Syndrome
    3. What Makes You Beautiful
    2. No Control
    1. Best Song Ever

    I cannot at my own #1, but that is the result of songs that should not have gone.
     
  10. Nooooooooo!

    Anyway:
    10. No Control
    9. Best Song Ever
    8. They Don't Know About Us
    7. Kiss You
    6. One Thing
    5. What Makes You Beautiful
    4. Tell Me A Lie
    3. Stockholm Syndrome
    2. What A Feeling
    1. Fireproof
     
  11. KAG

    KAG

    Dream results:

    10. 'What a Feeling' (I'm surprised at how far this has lasted. One of the 'better' tracks on MITAM but not a career highlight)
    9. 'Tell Me a Lie'
    8. 'No Control'
    7. 'One Thing'
    6. 'Stockholm Syndrome'
    5. 'Fireproof'
    4. 'They Don't Know About Us'
    3. 'What Makes You Beautiful'
    2. 'Kiss You'
    1. 'Best Song Ever'
     
  12. 10. Fireproof (sorry)
    9. One Thing
    8. Tell Me A Lie
    7. Stockholme Syndrome
    6. No Control
    5. What A Feeling
    4. What Makes You Beautiful
    3. They Don't Know About Us
    2. Best Song Ever
    1. Kiss You

    I have one 7, one 8, one 8.5, one 9 and six 10s left, so I guess overall this hasn't been as much of a disaster as it appeared to be for me! Yas.
     
  13. 10 Fireproof (i've been preparing for the dragging this is going to cause for weeks)
    9 They Don't Know About Us
    8 What a Feeling
    7 Tell Me A Lie
    6 One Thing
    5 Stockholm Syndome
    4 No Control
    3 Best Song Ever
    2 WHat Makes You Beautiful
    1 Kiss You


    A bit of a disaster - my 11 remains, and a ten and a nine, but after that its all sevens and eights that I like but not top ten stuff.
     
  14. I wish I had so many good scores left.
     

  15. Yeah but my greatest fear in this rate is becoming you
     
    ohnostalgia likes this.
  16. I still have one 10, two 9s (which have since become 10s in my eyes), two 8.5s, three 8s, one 6 and a 5 still left, so I'm doing a lot better than I thought I would at the start of this rate.
     
  17. My Top 6 consists of 11, 10, 9's and a couple of 8.5' so I feel ok.

    10. What Makes You Beautiful (Sorry guys the song is not that great)
    9. One Thing
    8. Best Song Ever
    7. No Control
    6. Kiss You
    5. What A Feeling
    4. Tell Me A Lie
    3. Stockholm Syndrome
    2. They Don't Know About Us
    1. Fireproof
     
  18. 10. Stockholm Syndrome
    9. One Thing
    8. What a Feeling
    7. They Don't Know About Us
    6. Tell Me a Lie
    5. What Makes You Beautiful
    4. Fireproof
    3. No Control
    2. Kiss You
    1. Best Song Ever
     
  19. ohnostalgia

    ohnostalgia Staff Member

    All these Fireproof haters.... tsk tsk. Good luck with that.
     
    wackseed likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.