I Think I'm Gonna Win This Time: The One Direction Discography Rate

iheartpoptarts · Jun 16, 2016

I just wanted to say that I've always loved One Direction for bringing the boyband back and giving me countless perfect pop songs, but I feel like I know sooooooo much more about them now than I did back when we started. Like, infinitely more.

So, thanks again @ohnostalgia - I couldn't have asked for a better 1D education!

ohnostalgia said:

P.S. Yay for Niall and his lack of hilarious tattoos. I knew I liked him!

wackseed · Jun 16, 2016

Okay I'm finally back online after quite a week but OH WHAT A RATE! The drags! The memes! The battles! The graphics! The rage! THE DRAKE!!

Truly the best rate I've ever participated in and, even though the godtier song was runner-up, still very satisfying that so many others loved it the way it deserves. Good job y'all and amazing job @ohnostalgia

ohnostalgia · Jun 16, 2016

I swear I didn't pay her to say that.

First2Run · Jun 17, 2016

Ahh I'm so behind!!! But amazing work, and a deserving winner! It is pretty upsetting the winner is the only one above a 5 though.

Excellent hosting @ohnostalgia

A$AP Robbie · Jun 19, 2016

Just popped in to say, what a rate and easily the right winner (what. a. song). Great stuff @ohnostalgia

Furball · Jun 20, 2016

Great rate @ohnostalgia. Every song got a worthy send-off, and it was a pleasure to disagree, and occasionally (maybe) agree.

ohnostalgia · Mar 26, 2018

I'm updating the image links so I can finally delete my ancient tumblr and wow, re-reading this is a trip. I can't tell if I've become more or less extra since my debut.

boom bazooka joe · Feb 15, 2021

I’m sad that I missed this on the first go round.

Mvnl · Feb 15, 2021

Over Again was done dirty as one of the 2nd album hightlights

boom bazooka joe · Feb 15, 2021

Do we have a re-up in honor of 10 years since Up All Night has been released?

ohnostalgia · Feb 28, 2021

boombazookajoe said:
Do we have a re-up in honor of 10 years since Up All Night has been released?

I’d say only if there’s enough new voters interested. Essentially this was a rate for a dead group, so we wouldn’t usually re-rate them unless people really wanted it.