I Think I'm Gonna Win This Time: The One Direction Discography Rate

iheartpoptarts

iheartpoptarts

she/her
ohnostalgia said:
So I've finalized my scores. I'm not saying these are the correct opinions (I'm a Tryant not a Tyrant), but. Go ahead and judge me- just remember who's in charge of the write-ups here.

UP ALL NIGHT
What Makes You Beautiful- 9
Gotta Be You- 7
One Thing- 10
More Than This- 2
Up All Night- 10
I Wish- 7
Tell Me A Lie- 7
Taken- 6
I Want- 8
Everything About You- 7
Same Mistakes- 6
Save You Tonight- 5
Stole My Heart- 10
Stand Up- 5
Moments- 2
Another World- 3
Na Na Na- 6
I Should Have Kissed You- 5

TAKE ME HOME
Live While We're Young - 10
Kiss You - 10
Little Things - 0
C'mon, C'mon - 7
Last First Kiss -5
Heart Attack - 10
Rock Me - 10
Change My Mind - 6
I Would - 10
Over Again - 4
Back For You - 7
They Don't Know About Us - 10
Summer Love - 7
She's Not Afraid - 10
Loved You First - 6
Nobody Compares - 8
Still The One - 8
Truly Madly Deeply -6
Magic -6
Irresistible -6

MIDNIGHT MEMORIES
Best Song Ever- 10
Story Of My Life- 8
Diana- 6
Midnight Memories- 0
You & I - 7
Don't Forget Where You Belong- 8
Strong- 6.5
Happily- 10
Right Now- 7
Little Black Dress- 1
Through The Dark- 7
Something Great- 5
Little White Lies- 8
Better Than Words- 9
Why Don't We Go There?- 6
Does He Know?- 2
Alive- 1
Half A Heart- 5
One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)- 10

FOUR
Steal My Girl - 8
Ready to Run- 8
Where Do Broken Hearts Go- 7
18- 4
Girl Almighty- 10
Fool's Gold- 8.5
Night Changes- 8
No Control- 7
Fireproof- 11
Spaces- 9
Stockholm Syndrome- 10
Clouds- 10
Change Your Ticket- 10
Illusion- 6
Once in a Lifetime- 3
Act My Age- 8

MADE IN THE A.M.
Hey Angel- 7
Drag Me Down- 10
Perfect- 9
Infinity- 1
End of the Day- 5
If I Could Fly- 1
Long Way Down- 5
Never Enough- 10
Olivia - 8
What A Feeling - 10
Love You Goodbye - 3
I Want To Write You A Song - 0
History - 6
Temporary Fix - 5
Walking In The Wind -7
Wolves - 8
A.M. - 6.5
Home - 6
Click to expand...

I agree with a lot of your faves on the first few albums, and then things start to differ a bit!
 
SophiaSophia

SophiaSophia

I joined tumblr once I hated every moment of it I deleted my blog after a few months I only followed two people one who was a tumblr SJW and the other just posted cat gifs and memes it was pointless I prefer Facebook anyway.

I shall get back onto this in the morning I had a break whilst I was out due to me getting distracted by Zayn's album which I bought.
 
eccentricsimply

eccentricsimply

Staff member
they/them
ohnostalgia said:
So I've finalized my scores. I'm not saying these are the correct opinions (I'm a Tryant not a Tyrant), but. Go ahead and judge me- just remember who's in charge of the write-ups here.

UP ALL NIGHT
What Makes You Beautiful- 9
Gotta Be You- 7
One Thing- 10
More Than This- 2
Up All Night- 10
I Wish- 7
Tell Me A Lie- 7
Taken- 6
I Want- 8
Everything About You- 7
Same Mistakes- 6
Save You Tonight- 5
Stole My Heart- 10
Stand Up- 5
Moments- 2
Another World- 3
Na Na Na- 6
I Should Have Kissed You- 5

TAKE ME HOME
Live While We're Young - 10
Kiss You - 10
Little Things - 0
C'mon, C'mon - 7
Last First Kiss -5
Heart Attack - 10
Rock Me - 10
Change My Mind - 6
I Would - 10
Over Again - 4
Back For You - 7
They Don't Know About Us - 10
Summer Love - 7
She's Not Afraid - 10
Loved You First - 6
Nobody Compares - 8
Still The One - 8
Truly Madly Deeply -6
Magic -6
Irresistible -6

MIDNIGHT MEMORIES
Best Song Ever- 10
Story Of My Life- 8
Diana- 6
Midnight Memories- 0
You & I - 7
Don't Forget Where You Belong- 8
Strong- 6.5
Happily- 10
Right Now- 7
Little Black Dress- 1
Through The Dark- 7
Something Great- 5
Little White Lies- 8
Better Than Words- 9
Why Don't We Go There?- 6
Does He Know?- 2
Alive- 1
Half A Heart- 5
One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)- 10

FOUR
Steal My Girl - 8
Ready to Run- 8
Where Do Broken Hearts Go- 7
18- 4
Girl Almighty- 10
Fool's Gold- 8.5
Night Changes- 8
No Control- 7
Fireproof- 11
Spaces- 9
Stockholm Syndrome- 10
Clouds- 10
Change Your Ticket- 10
Illusion- 6
Once in a Lifetime- 3
Act My Age- 8

MADE IN THE A.M.
Hey Angel- 7
Drag Me Down- 10
Perfect- 9
Infinity- 1
End of the Day- 5
If I Could Fly- 1
Long Way Down- 5
Never Enough- 10
Olivia - 8
What A Feeling - 10
Love You Goodbye - 3
I Want To Write You A Song - 0
History - 6
Temporary Fix - 5
Walking In The Wind -7
Wolves - 8
A.M. - 6.5
Home - 6
Click to expand...
We have 9 matches. Thank you for the She's Not Afraid love. Such a bop.
 
sexercise

sexercise

he/him
Made in the A.M. has a couple of dudes but I generally like it. What a Feeling is a discography highlight. Four is technically their best album & has my highest average but I'll always reserve a special place for Take Me Home. Truly their peak.

Midnight Memories is probably one of my most hated albums ever. I never felt more irritated than I was after I listened to it. That was also around the time they started looking like they were barely functioning anymore so it's just in general not a great time in 1D history.
 
Sprockrooster

Sprockrooster

ohnostalgia said:
This is all a secret ploy to shame you for your Louis love. Or to hunt out who else needs saving on this forum.
Click to expand...
Shame me? It is not like I put my love out of plain sight.

I will make it even better. I will have a Louis avatar the day the One Direction will start. I am on my phone now, but I will send you some Louis pics I love for you to pick from. You will be in charge for my avatar. How about that?
 
ohnostalgia

ohnostalgia

Staff member
She/her
Sprockrooster said:
Shame me? It is not like I put my love out of plain sight.

I will make it even better. I will have a Louis avatar the day the One Direction will start. I am on my phone now, but I will send you some Louis pics I love for you to pick from. You will be in charge for my avatar. How about that?
Click to expand...

If I'm going to have to deal with a Louis avatar you bet I need to pick the least hideous one. Can I make spiteful edits to it?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top