It's Gonna Be a Hot Rate : Monrose Discography Rate (Winner revealed!)

Vixen

Vixen

She/her

318838monroserate.png
As some you might know Monrose was a German pop girlgroup, first established in November 2006 on the fifth season of the German adaption of ‘Popstars’, a bit similarly to Girls Aloud. The trio consisted of Mandy Capristo, Senna Guemmour, and Bahar Kızıl. They were signed to Starwatch Music and released their debut album 'Temptation' shortly after that in December, becoming one of the most successful acts launched on a similar platform, thus following the steps of the likes of ‘No Angels’. The girls found success mostly in Germany, as well as in Austria, Poland and Switzerland. They were never properly launched in the UK, let alone the US, but their music travelled through the world to entice a few of us here, ready to rate their discography. Which consisted, by the time they broke up in November 2010, of four albums, three of them being quite good and hiding some of the best girlgroup songs of the last decade, and most precisely the absolute bop that is "Hot Summer". This is the time for you guys to discover all those goodies!

As I'm well aware some people do not know exactly who they are, but could potentially be interested in discovering them, I decided to throw a little "playlist" of some of their songs (12, actually). Hopefully their sound will seduce some of you.


More to be found here
​




The Rules​

Let’s keep it simple : rate each song on a scale of 0 to 10, using half points too if you want, and send your completed list to me (Vixen) by PM, by using an appropriate title so your votes are easy to find amongst all the other messages if anything was to happen. You also have the opportunity to award that one extra special song an extra special score of 11, so don’t waste it! It could mean the difference between a song coming in at #1 or #3, and we know all too well how irritating that feels. Commentary is also welcome, and encouraged. In fact, as this rate is rather niche and will potentially only appeal to a certain number of people, you are all very much encouraged to provide commentary so the results do not look too empty.
Also, I’m not keen on faffing around with single mixes, radio edits and what have you, so if a track is concerned, just rate whichever version you prefer, and mention which it is as an aside in your comments if you truly must.

You have 30 days to vote, that’s Thursday the 23rd of June. Work it!
 
Last edited:
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
642050Temptationalbum.png

Temptation (2006)
1. Shame
2. Even Heaven Cries
3. Oh La La
4. No
5. I'm Gonna Freak Ya
6. Love Don't Come Easy
7. Of A Kind
8. Your Love Is Right Over Me
9. Work It
10. Do That Dance
11. Live Life Get By
12. Push Up On Me
13. Butt Butt




913728StrictlyPhysicalAlbum.png

Strictly Physical (2007)
1. Dangerous
2. Hot Summer
3. Strictly Physical
4. Rebound
5. What You Don't Know
6. Leading Me On
7. Golden
8. Sooner Or Later
9. Just Like That
10. Yesterday's Gone
11. Burning
12. Monrose Theme
13. Everybody Makes Mistakes
14. Say Yes



174789IAMalbum.png

I AM (2008)
1. Strike The Match
2. A Love Bizarre
3. Certified
4. Why Not Us
5. Going Out Tonight
6. You Can Look
7. Tip Toe
8. Teach Me How To Jump
9. Stolen
10. Electricity
11. Hit 'N' Run
12. No Never
13. Stained
14. What They Want
15. Don't Touch The Fader
16. Step Aside



440128Ladylikealbum.png

Ladylike (2010)
1. This Is Me
2. Superstar DJ
3. Like A Lady
4. Don't Take It Personal
5. Doing Fine
6. Definition Of A Woman
7. Love Must Carry On
8. Breathe You In
9. All Or Nothing
10. No No No
11. Catwalk V-O-G-U-E
12. Mono
13. I Surrender


The Extras
After Making Love
Diamonds and Pearl
Walking Away (Craig David’s single)
We Love
Scream​
 
Last edited:
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
The list of everyone who voted :

GhettoPrincess
Sweet Music
Txetxu
Sprockrooster
tylerc904
Macanudo
plasticFANTASTIC
DJHazey
TrainJumper
iheartpoptarts
Epic Chocolat
eyeline
SloMover
If You Go
Reboot
Utopia
Zdarlight
Totto
Rob
Remorque
Conan
Mr.Arroz
Vixen

Results will be found here.

61 Oh La La 4,761
60 Diamonds and Pearls 4,761
59 No 4,978
58 Live Life Get By 5,022
57 Walking Away (Craig David’s single) 5,065
56 Butt Butt 5,109
55 I'm Gonna Freak Ya 5,152
54 Your Love Is Right Over Me 5,174
53 Going Out Tonight 5,283
52 Love Don't Come Easy 5,457
51 Work It 5,478
50 All Or Nothing 5,500
49 Golden 5,565
48 A Love Bizarre 5,630
47 Definition Of A Woman 5,891
46 Sooner Or Later 5,978
45 What They Want 6,065
44 Everybody Makes Mistakes 6,152
43 Do That Dance 6,174
42 We Love 6,196
41 No No No 6,283
40 Teach Me How To Jump 6,304
39 Breathe You In 6,478
38 Love Must Carry On 6,565
37 I Surrender 6,783
36 After Making Love 6,826
35 Monrose Theme 6,891
34 Stained 6,957
33 Don't Take It Personal 6,978
32 Stolen 7,000
31 Doing Fine 7,043
30 Don't Touch the Fader 7,326
29 Scream 7,348
28 Even Heaven Cries 7,391
27 2 Of A Kind 7,435
26 You Can Look 7,457
25 Rebound 7,457
24 Strike The Match 7,543
23 Mono 7,587
22 Why Not Us 7,630
21 Superstar DJ 7,696
20 Yesterday's Gone 7,761
19 What You Don't Know 7,761
18 Push Up On Me 7,826
17 Burning 7,870
16 Electricity 7,957
15 No Never 8,087
14 Tip Toe 8,152
13 Leading Me On 8,174
12 Like a Lady 8,239
....
 
Last edited:
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
(Just in case, you never know!

That means, you can all post know and appreciate that shitty graphic I did.)

Right, also, since some of their material have been deleted from Youtube (seriously, which label still does that?), I've joined a different link for each album. You'd have to click on the year the album was released instead of the tracklist to get to that "second link".​
 
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
DJHazey said:
Yaaaas, let me read through this properly when I get home from work. I'm ready for these ladies to become a new fav!
Click to expand...
If I may recommend you (or anyone else, really) a listen order to their albums, it would be that one :

01. Strictly Physical
02. I AM
03. Ladylike
....... 04. Temptation (try getting through that cheese fest, there's still a few bops)​
 
DJHazey

DJHazey

he/him
Vixen said:
If I may recommend you (or anyone else, really) a listen order to their albums, it would be that one :

01. Strictly Physical
02. I AM
03. Ladylike
....... 04. Temptation (try getting through that cheese fest, there's still a few bops)​
Click to expand...

Actually getting the worst out of the way is always my policy and knowing it will get better will help. So that works out, by doing it in order.
 
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
DJHazey said:
Actually getting the worst out of the way is always my policy and knowing it will get better will help. So that works out, by doing it in order.
Click to expand...
Well, I meant that 'Temptation' was their worst album actually. So if you want to get the worst out of the way first, start with that. It's very "local Popstars released cheesy Pop RnB leftovers" whereas they were already far more electro and glossy one year later with 'Stricty Physical'.

EDIT: Nevermind, you actually understood, haha.
 
C

Conan

I am so ready. In fact, I lay awake last night reminiscing and thinking about what to put in my commentary.

For a start, I don't think "Temptation" is that bad, considering it's a Popstars debut album, hastily cobbled together and trying to fit any of the contestants. It definitely has it's moments, especially this one:
[media]
 
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
iheartpoptarts said:
As someone who gets my life to 'Hot Summer' every summer, I really should check out their albums! Here for this!
Click to expand...
It's an absolute bop. You should really give a try to 'Strictly Physical' (the album). That's the one 'Hot Summer' comes from.

Zdarlight said:
Here for this. I love Monrose, especially the I AM album.
Click to expand...
It's an amazing album. I can't wait for your scores!

Conan said:
I am so ready. In fact, I lay awake last night reminiscing and thinking about what to put in my commentary.

For a start, I don't think "Temptation" is that bad, considering it's a Popstars debut album, hastily cobbled together and trying to fit any of the contestants. It definitely has it's moments, especially this one:
[media]
Click to expand...

'Two of a Kind' is that bop. So is 'Push Up On Me'. But let's be honest, 'Temptation' pales a lot in comparison to their three other albums.

But yes, please, provide commentary! That woud be very much appreciated.
 
Vixen

Vixen

She/her
iheartpoptarts said:
As someone who gets my life to 'Hot Summer' every summer, I really should check out their albums! Here for this!
Click to expand...
'Hot Summer' is just perfect through and through. It's funny because despite Senna being an iffy vocalist, she's truly selling those verses like no one else. All these damn covers of 'Hot Summer' pale in comparison of Senna's cool and almost arrogant delivery of those lines.

@Mr.Arroz don't do me and our girls like this. Post immediately.
(xoxo)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top