It's Gonna Be a Hot Rate : Monrose Discography Rate (Winner revealed!)

he/him
My recap:

61. Oh La La - 2
60. Diamonds And Pearl - 2
59. No - 3
58. Live Life Get By - 4
57. Walking Away - 4

56. Butt Butt - 7
55. I'm Gonna Freak Ya - 10
54. Your Love Is Right Over Me - 6

Tragic that @eyeline didn't actually give I'm Gonna Freak Ya the 10 it deserved.
 
he/him
I'm happy with eliminations so far. Looking back, I should have rated Diamonds and Pearls lower than what I gave it...
 
This has gone so perfectly.

I'm preparing to be disappointed when Love Bizarre exits long before it should (I'd place it Top 20!), since I'm seeing people coming for it!
 
She/her
SO THERE YOU GO GUYS.























ANOTHER ELIMINATION.


















IT'S NOT FROM TEMPTATION...





































IT'S NOT FROM LADYLIKE AS WELL....




































IT'S NOT FROM STRICTLY PHYSICAL...



















YES, IT'S FROM "I AM"....



















You could say this song is very....bizarre.





It's...








53. Going Out Tonight

664051GoingOutTonight.png


Score: 5,283.

Highest Score: 9,5 x 1 ( @plasticFANTASTIC )
Lowest Score: 1 x 1 ( @TrainJumper )

The first song to leave from the girls' third album is 'Going Out Tonight', their first venture in the reggae realm, and their last one, thank God. Now, I do think the "worst I AM song" title goes to 'A Love Bizarre', but this one is a close second, so not a surprise for me. Let's see what you guys have to say.

TrainJumper starts things off by asking the only appropriate question when you're done listening to that poor excuse of a song : "What. Is. This?" It's a shitty song, Trainy, that's what it is. Is it alright if I call you Trainy? Imma call you Trainy anyway. Here's what eyeline, on the other hand, had to say "Monrose twerking circa 08, this is quite awful though." GhettoPrincess seems to agree, because she thought the song sounded "like a weird mixture of an urban pop group and a Disney group. It just doesn’t work well". tylerc904 also noticed the 'weird' aspect of the song by stating it was "bizarre, not in a good way. The delivery of the "Give the dog a bone" bit is cringeworthy EVERY time". As if that wasn't already harsh enough, Totto just pretty muchs laught it off and grant it a poor 3.

But don't worry, surprisingly, this track got quite a its fair share of positive comments as well. Sprockrooster stanned for Bahar and thought she "bringing it in this" and seemed to appreciate "that islandbeat" . Similarly, iheartpoptarts esteemed the song was "cute and breezy" and it was giving her " 'How I Roll’ feels with island influences here and there!"

DJHazey claimed it was definitely "not as bad as it's made out to be", although he does agree with tylerc904 "that the "give a dog a bone" stuff is crap, but only because it sound like they suddenly want to give us reggae vocals", he further pursues with "I mean this isn't mid-90s eurodance. Playful bits like "o-we-o-we-oh" normally work better for me than they are with this. I wouldn't scream for someone to turn this off, but I wouldn't tell them to turn it up either". Well, you better scream to turn it off if I ask you to!

Now, the highest scorer of the song, plasticFANTASTIC, wasn't exactly right when he thought he "might be the sole person liking this song in this rate", but he admitted he "can't help to love this bizarre electro-raggamuffin jam. it's just catchy as fuck and so fun to sing a long to and i love the synth flourishes on the backing track".


 
It always annoyed me that apparently they had something like 300 demos for I Am and yet Going Out Tonight and A Love Bizarre made the cut and we only had one b-side in the amazing After amazing Love.

It's that cringe inducing line with "give that dog a bone" that makes Going Out Tonight a total mess for me.
 
Top