K-Pop Rates | Page 21 | The Popjustice Forum

K-Pop Rates

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Dangerous Maknae, Jan 20, 2017.

  1. Don't even try it, binch. I will defend Replay till the end of time.
     
    eccentricsimply likes this.
  2. Wait, WHAT?!
     
  3. If anyone ever does that, please crowdsource your graphics so everyone can think of a different way to remove Hwayoung.
     
    RUNAWAY likes this.
  4. Okay so, checking my schedule, it's likely I'm gonna open the part 2 of the SHINee rate for votes around the last week of October-first of November. That way results will start once my classes are over and I can hopefully get everything done before the new year!
     
  5. Yes awesome. Will it have the Japanese stuff too?
     
    eccentricsimply likes this.
  6. Yes it will have (most) of their Japanese singles!!!


    That said I have gathered the songs to be rated and we have a few more for this half of the rate - 75 (62 Korean + 13 Japanese) - , which is why I'm gonna open the second part in a week or so because then the rating period can be a bit longer.
     
    Remorque and Reboot like this.
  7. So I guess I'm hosting the Song of the Year 2018 Rate???

    Yes, I'm hosting the Song of the Year 2018 Rate.
     
    Kuhleezi, codecat, He and 8 others like this.
  8. Okay more details...

    I don't wanna do the whole "nominate 20 songs" thing because I think it's a huge waste of time dddddd. But I wanna keep the SUPER TRASH portion where each voter will send one (and just one) song straight to the finale.

    So to replace the "nominate 20 songs" thing, I plan to use the top 5 songs of the K-Popjustice Charts. I also included songs that didn't hit top 5 but charted two months in a row because I think they deserve to be rated. Here's the song list as of September 2018:

    DECEMBER 2017
    Heart Attack - LOOΠΔ / Chuu


    JANUARY 2018
    Bboom Bboom - Momoland
    Heroine - Sunmi
    Bad Boy - Red Velvet
    Roller Coaster - Chungha
    Secret Garden - Oh My Girl


    FEBRUARY 2018
    One Shot, Two Shot - BoA
    Black Dress - CLC
    The Boots - gugudan
    Heroine - Sunmi
    Bboom Bboom - Momoland

    Everybody Knows - BoA
    Dreams Come True - WJSN


    MARCH 2018
    Egoist (feat. JinSoul) - LOOΠΔ / Olivia Hye
    Black Dress - CLC
    Jealousy - Monsta X
    Look - GOT7
    Rosy (feat. HeeJin) - LOOΠΔ / Olivia Hye x Go Won
    jenga - Heize


    APRIL 2018
    Lady - EXID
    Dally - Hyolyn
    What Is Love? - Twice
    Sober - Hyo
    Shine - Pentagon


    MAY 2018
    Good Evening - SHINee
    love4eva (feat. Grimes) - LOOΠΔ / yyxy
    LATATA - (G)I-DLE
    Get It - Pristin V
    You and I - Dreamcatcher


    JUNE 2018
    DDU-DU DDU-DU - BLACKPINK
    Something New - Taeyeon
    BAAM - Momoland
    Lady - Yubin
    Forever Young - BLACKPINK


    JULY 2018
    I'm So Sick - Apink
    See Sea - Hyolyn
    Blue Moon - Gyeong Ree / Kyungri
    Love U - Chungha
    Sunny Summer - GFriend


    AUGUST 2018
    Hi High - LOOΠΔ
    HANN (Alone) - (G)I-DLE
    favOriTe - LOOΠΔ
    Yeolgi - LOOΠΔ
    Power Up - Red Velvet


    SEPTEMBER 2018
    Siren - Sunmi
    Save Me, Save You - WJSN
    Memoria - GFriend
    Lil' Touch - Girls' Generation-Oh!GG
    Remember Me - Oh My Girl


    OCTOBER 2018
    TBA


    NOVEMBER 2018
    TBA


    DECEMBER 2018
    TBA


    SPECIAL SONGS
    (songs that didn't hit top 5 but charted two months in a row)
    Baby Don't Stop - NCT U
    Time for the Moon Night - GFriend
    Now or Never - SF9
    We Go Up - NCT Dream

    SUMMARY
    27 - Group - Female
    7 - Group - Male
    16 - Solo - Female
    0 - Solo - Male
    0 - Coed

    4 - Album Tracks
    46 - Singles

    50 - Total (as of September 2018)

    If we add the fifteen songs from October to December 2018, we will have a total of 65 songs. And if we include 30 super-trash songs (rough estimate), that's 95 songs in total.

    Again, your suggestions and recommendations will be appreciated.

    I plan to open the thread first week of December.
     
    Last edited: Oct 18, 2018
  9. Top 5 of each month + super trashes is a perfect idea.


    I can't believe Time for the Moon Night didn't chart in the top 5 though.
     
    eliminathan, He, vague and 2 others like this.
  10. If anyone desperately wants that format to return, I could run it, seeing as I did exactly that in my rate earlier this year. And then it would only be my time that would be wasted, and my time is worthless anyway.

    My worry is that 95 songs would be a lot.
     
    Slice of Life likes this.
  11. This isn’t technically a rate, but anyone interested in a November Madness bracket?

    We’d bet on sales, music show wins and bopitude.
     
    Slice of Life likes this.
  12. Can we find a new name for this though nn
     
    codecat and Slice of Life like this.
  13. We rated 100 songs last year. I think 95 or so will be okay?

    Ddddddd spoiler alert but I was gonna call it SUPERSARANG ksjfhsjdjdjdux
     
  14. Omg I was literally thinking about how this would be a good idea to implement for SOTY Rate.

    Been making a contest for my Supersarang since January nn but I have an obvious choice I'll submit.
    Y'all better vote for What so it charts in the second month and gains immediate access so I don't have to create a fake account to submit another song.
     
  15. I think 50 is fine. If we'd done that last year (or actually this year) we'd have finished on time. Whatever 'on time' means. It's so much work....
     
    Slice of Life and junglefish like this.
  16. How did Egotistic not go top 5.
     
    Slice of Life likes this.
  17. Taste prevailed kekeke.
     
  18. Okay so if people want, like, just 50 songs, how do we narrow down the songs? I really don't want a pre-rate to happen because it is exhausting dddddd.
     
    Cotton Park likes this.
  19. I really don't think 100 songs is a problem especially since 99% of us already heard 90% of the songs (Assuming y'all pick weird Supersarang songs) like it's not much work for us voters, it's just about the host.
     
  20. Yes. It's about the host. 100 is a huge undertaking.
     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.