K-Pop Rates | Page 8 | The Popjustice Forum

K-Pop Rates

Discussion in 'K-pop' started by Dangerous Maknae, Jan 20, 2017.


  1. Oh this is great, I updated the original posts + links to the threads. Thanks x
     
    Squashua, Slice of Life and Sanctuary like this.
  2. Okay but can y'all fix your spelling of @Squashua unnie's name? dddddddddddddddd
     
  3. Sorry, @Squasha can't come to the phone right now. Why? Oh...
    [​IMG]
     
  4. Dddddd that was an honest mistake.

    I don't know what that SNSD discography rate thread is. I just went through the subforum and noticed it. Did it evolve into the singles rate? I think I saw Shockbox saying they want to eventually do a rate of their Japanese albums.

    "Pending" just meant rates that seemed in limbo.
     
    Slice of Life likes this.

  5. It was a mega rate for SNSD's Korean discography + their Japanese Discography + TTS albums + the girls' solo album - the singles that we rated before which was +100 songs and who had the time for that? So it got cancelled.


    The solo albums, as you know, later became part of SM Girls Rate and as for their discography I have a plan to do a rate for them without forcing people to rate all of their songs. It will probably be their Japanese album tracks + some selected songs from their Korean discography (which will be selected by a small pre-rate). I wanted to do it this year for their 10th anniversary but I had the debut rate so i will hopefully do it next year.
     
  6. Unnies don't forget the Boy Group Debut Singles Rate.

    I'm planning on running it in a month or two when my life starts to chill down and when the current rates are a fair way into their results.
     
  7. Why even do it when we already know the winner?

     
    karmarisma and junglefish like this.
  8. I don't think so, sweatie. xoxo

     
    send photo and karmarisma like this.
  9. Um hello?
     
    send photo and karmarisma like this.
  10. As Mariah once said "Condragulations Raja", just replace Raja with Sunmi (Unless ReVeluv mafia comes through) but I'm very excited for this


    Against TWICE probably [​IMG]


    Omg this SNSD ignorance, Blackpink yeah with 1 song, same as Wonder Girls and 2NE1 DDD.

    Currently there's 34 songs and hopefully TWICE comes through with another mini and we get some christmas album or something
     
  11. What albums are you including? I think Big 3 releases of this year are really more than 34 songs.
     
  12. Okay you're right I forgot about S.E.S. being a 2017 release

    Remember = 9
    Holiday Night = 10
    Rookie + Red Summer + Would U + Rebirth = 13
    Signal + Knock Knock/Melting + Japanese Album = 8 + (? probably 2)
    Majimak Cheoreom + Draw Me + Goodbye = 3


    And I didn't know if people would be for adding boy groups cause there's A LOT of songs there.
     
    Dangerous Maknae likes this.
  13. Oh so it's only girl groups? I thought you mean all of big 3 releases of this year nn. It's okay then.
     
    Serg. likes this.
  14. Rate idea incoming: Perfect All-Kills since it first became a thing, which was 2010/2011 apparently. I copied this list from https://kpoppersguide.wordpress.com/2017/09/06/paks/

    70 songs have achieved this so far. A bit of variety, a lot of IU. I'm not saying I want to run it myself, just throwing the idea out there for anyone that wants it.

    2017
    • Yoon Jong Shin – Like It [18 Aug — 23:30]
    • Team Dynamic Duo (Nucksal, Hanhae, Rhyno, MyunDo, Jo Woochan) – 1/N (SMTM6) [7 Aug — 00:30]
    • Heize – You, Clouds, Rain (Feat. Shin Yong Jae) [4 Jul — 14:30]
    • G-DRAGON – Untitled, 2014 [12 Jun — 00:30]
    • IU – Palette (Feat. G-DRAGON) [24 Apr — 1:30]
    • IU – Can’t Love You Anymore (Feat. Oh Hyuk) [10 Apr — 00:30]
    • IU – Through the Night [27 Mar — 00:30]
    • TWICE – KNOCK KNOCK [21 Feb — 13:30]
    • Ailee – I’ll Go To You Like The First Snow (Goblin OST Part 9) [13 Jan — 14:30]
    • Kwanghee & Gaeko – Your Night (feat. OH HYUK) (Infinite Challenge) [2 Jan — 14:30]

    2016
    • BIGBANG – FXXK IT [14 Dec — 18:30]
    • Heize – Star [6 Dec — 14:30]
    • TWICE – TT [26 Oct — 12:30]
    • I.O.I – Very Very Very [19 Oct — 15:30]
    • Han Dong Geun – Making a new ending for this story [Sep 2016]
    • Lim Chang Jung – The Love That I Committed [10 Sep — 13:30]
    • BLACKPINK – WHISTLE [14 Aug — 13:30]
    • Wonder Girls – Why So Lonely [8 Jul — 22:30]
    • BewhY – Forever (SMTM5) [3 Jul — 00:30]
    • One – Comfortable (feat. Simon D, Gray) (SMTM5) [27 Jun — 00:30]
    • One, G2, BewhY, DayDay – I’m not what you knew (feat. Simon Dominic) (SMTM5) [20 Jun — 00:30]
    • Urban Zakapa – I Don’t Love You [29 May — 00:30]
    • 10cm – What The Spring?? [4 Apr — 00:30]
    • TWICE – CHEER UP [27 Apr — 18:30]
    • Davichi – This Love [3 Mar — 13:30]
    • MAMAMOO – You’re the Best [29 Feb — 3:30]
    • GFRIEND – Rough [7 Feb — 14:30]
    • Crush – Don’t Forget (Feat. Taeyeon) [25 Jan — 00:30]

    2015
    • Oh Hyuk – A Little Girl (Reply 1988 OST Part 3) [23 Nov — 00:30]
    • IU – Twenty-three [26 Oct — 00:30]
    • IU & Park Myungsoo – Leon (Infinite Challenge) [8 Aug — 23:30]
    • BIGBANG – LET’S NOT FALL IN LOVE [9 Aug — 14:30]
    • SISTAR – SHAKE IT [27 Jun — 14:30]
    • BIGBANG – LOSER [3 May — 00:30]
    • missA – Only You [31 Mar — 23:29]
    • Jung Seonghwan & Park Yoonha – I Have To forget My Love in Sorrow (K-Pop Star 4) [20 Jan — 23:30]

    2014
    • MC MONG – MISS ME OR DISS ME (Feat. Jinsil of MadSoul Child) [3 Nov — 08:30]
    • Kwak Jin Un & Kim Pil & Do Hyuk – Only You (Superstar K6) [22 Sep — 14:29]
    • Soyou, Kwon Soonil, & Park Youngin (Urban Zakapa) – The Space Between [29 Sep — 11:29]
    • IU – My old story [19 May — 00:31]
    • Idina Menzel – Let It Go (Frozen OST) [2 Feb — 15:30]

    2013
    • IU – Friday (ft. Jang Yijeong of HISTORY) [23 Dec — 00:30]
    • Park Myungsoo & Primary – I Got C (Feat. Gaeko of Dynamic Duo) (Infinite Challenge) [4 Nov — 14:30]
    • IU – The Red Shoes [10 Oct — 11:30]
    • Busker Busker – Love, At First [28 Sep — 3:30]
    • Yoon Mirae – Touch love (Master’s sun OST Part 4) [2 Sep — 1:30]
    • SISTAR – Give It To Me [13 Jun — 10:30]
    • HuhGak, Jong Eunji – Short Hair [3 Jun — 2:30]
    • Lee Hyori – Miss Korea [May 2013]
    • PSY – GENTLEMEN [15 Apr — 1:30]
    • SISTAR19 – GONE NOT AROUND ANY LONGER [10 Feb — 1:30]
    • Leessang – Tears (Feat. Eugene of THE SEEYA) [28 Jan — 00:30]

    2012
    • NAUL – Memory Of The Wind [2012]*
    • G-DRAGON – THAT XX [3 Sep — 04:30]
    • PSY – GANGNAM STYLE [19 Jul — 09:30]
    • Busker Busker – If You Really Love Me [Jun 2012]*
    • Busker Busker – Cherry Blossom Ending [Apr 2012]*
    • BIGBANG – BLUE [29 Feb — 12:30]

    2011
    • IU – YOU & I [1 Dec — 09:30]
    • Leessang – Turned off the TV (feat. Yoon MiRae (Tasha), Kwon Jungyeol OF 10CM) [20 Aug — 23:30]
    • missA – Good-bye Baby [19 Jul — 20:30]
    • GG (Park Myungsoo & G-DRAGON) – Having an Affair (feat. Park Bom) (Infinite Challenge) [4 Jul — 09:30]
    • 2NE1 – I AM THE BEST [27 Jun — 00:30]
    • Kim Yeonwoo – If You’re Like Me [28(?) May 2011]*
    • 2NE1 – LONELY [16 May — 00:30]
    • Park Bom – DON’T CRY [25 Apr — 3:05]
    • Kim Bumsoo – Jebal (Please) [2(?) April]*
    • IU – The Story Only I Didn’t Know [17 Feb]*

    2010
    Since Instiz iChart doesn’t list 2010 records these have been taken from LOEN.
    • IU — Good Day [9 Dec — 4:00]
    • IU — Nagging (Feat. Seulong) (We Got Married OST) [7 Jun]
     
    RUNAWAY, Serg., karmarisma and 2 others like this.
  15. Okay but this still needs to happen, @Sanctuary unnie and I would be devastated if this doesn't push through. I'm so excited for this already dddddddd.
     
  16. Alright unnies, I have started putting together a list of songs for the Boy Group Debut Singles Rate - but I'd like to hear some opinions.

    Q1
    A. Should I include some of our ancestral Kpop groups: H.O.T, Shinhwa, g.o.d, Sechs Kies, Turbo

    B. Should I remove those spots and replace them with groups from my limbo list:
    *
    A.C.E | Top Secret | B.I.G | Boyfriend | Myname | C-Clown | Halo | ToppDogg | Myteen | M.I.B | A-Jax | Romeo | VAV | Boys Republic | MADTOWN | The Legend | DGNA-The Boss | MASC | Black6ix | VRomance | ONF | Golden Child | IZ | TRAX | Highlight (are we going to continue the meme?)

    any other nugu groups/groups I haven't thought of

    C. Are there particular groups (out of the ancients and the list above) that this sub-forum is passionately interested in voting for that I should include?

    Q2
    Do you think I should count NCT-U, NCT-127 and NCT-Dream as separate groups?
     
    Last edited: Oct 14, 2017
    Slice of Life and Squashua like this.
  17. I'm probably not the best person to answer this but I'd say:

    Q1A - The girls debut rate didn't include the 90's roster so maybe we should forgo groups like H.O.T & Sechskies e.t.c?

    Q1B - think it's going to depend how many other groups are on the list. The Girls debut rate had 2017 debuts on there but mainly the more notorious ones (P101 alums for example). I personally like a lot of these groups (A.C.E / Top Secret / MASC / Black6ix to name a few) but I'm not sure many of them would be legitimate contenders? It's a judgement call Unnie.

    Q1C - you can guarantee people will comment on this once the full list is revealed so might be worth just going for it perhaps?

    Q2 - I included them as separate groups in the 2016 SOTY rate just because their concepts are so wildly different but, again, it's up to you.

    Hope that helps x
     
    Slice of Life likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.