Katy Perry - Smile | Page 550 | The Popjustice Forum

Katy Perry - Smile

Discussion in 'Pop & Justice' started by jamesmax, Sep 8, 2018.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Is Small Talk on any of the vinyls or is the only vinyl bonus the Target track?
  2. RJF


    All these reviews about the album being ill-timed for the current climate are... weird. Like everyone was enjoying the escapism the likes of Gaga's album of Joe Biden pop and Dua's album were providing, but the moment Katy Perry does it... it's suddenly a bit crass to be releasing pop music six months into this pandemic? What should she be doing then?

    The album even manages to mostly dodge and duck most of her worst tendencies; there's not a single borderline-meme song to be found for a change, her sense of humour has been thankfully eradicated from most of the music, and what you're left with is a remarkably solid pop album. Like I kept waiting for the trap door to open underneath my feet and find myself in one of her usual clown songs but it never happened. It's maybe lacking in big headliner moments outside of "Never Really Over", but the rest is so robust and well made that it's hard to have a problem with it.
  3. You congratulating Katy in favor of Gaga... 2020 is the year that the world ends.
  4. Honestly, what the fuck.
  5. I mean the Germans literally have the trashest musical taste of any country in Europe and their Spotify is rich with embarrassment, so...

    They also don't like smiling.
  6. I listened to the album once and it's a Katy Perry album? Nothing groundbreaking, few greatly produced and delivered bops,few duds and few tracks that I don't really care about. I'll probably spin this one couple more times but I don't see myself coming to it frequently in the future.

    Witness was much better.
    lushLuck and mattieh like this.
  7. RJF


    I cannot tell you how little affection I have for Lady Gaga in August 2020.
    myblood, Mushroom, lushLuck and 20 others like this.
  8. Guess what Mary
    myblood, Sam, 4Roses and 17 others like this.
  9. This is a cute, competent and consistent little pop record. And, let me be clear, we need these albums - little nuggets of timeless, hook-laden, crisply produced pop songs to dip into. It may not be as ambitious as her previous efforts but it’s still nowhere near as faceless as “Spotify playlist pop”.

    It’s all falling into good-but-not-great territory for me, aside from Never Really Over and Harley’s... Nothing is really tugging at my wig. But I’ll take “good not great” over “shit”.
    myblood, Maki, 4Roses and 13 others like this.
  10. The album is fine I guess. Sadly there's nothing as amazing as Never Really Over on there. Don't get why she didn't do more songs with Zedd and Dreamlab?
    Daszek likes this.
  11. I honestly didn't really have high hopes after Smile and What Makes A Woman, but the album turned out way better than I was expecting, I'm enjoying it a lot. I regret not going for one of those different covers now, does anyone know if they'll be made available again? (Sorry if this has been asked recently but I didn't read the whole thread).
    Maki likes this.
  12. I dont think they will!
    soratami likes this.
  13. Only Love seems like the closest thing to a hit here. In a perfect world, Champagne Problems would be #1 on all streaming platforms by now, though. Those harmonies are pop heaven.
  14. I figured as much, oh well. I do like the regular cover too, but I wish I'd bought the canon one.
  15. I really like this, because it’s probably her most straight-up, earnest, ironically no clownery album yet. It’s just a great set of Katy Perry pop songs, and I’ll be glad to have it on repeat this weekend.
    Ashling92, Sean_ius and lutz like this.
  16. It's funny to see the same people who called Chromatica generic/uninspired pretending this isn't straight up bad.
  17. If the age of poptimism doesn't make Katy a critical darling, nothing will. Just enjoy the album girls.

    This will end well.
  18. You really chose this as your first post huh.
  19. I'm never going to be a fan, but I listen to her stuff with an open mind and this is a marked improvement on the slog-tastic Witness.
  20. This album was always gonna be hard for Katy Perry. I see it as a bridging album from "Witness gate" to a new era. I wouldn't say this is a "new era" for her as such if that makes sense. Career wise I just see this as her putting a plaster on the wound, publicly recognising what happened with her last album and getting over it and hoping we do too...and I think we should because she's a fantastic pop star!
    melodrama likes this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.