#KS✿TY2024: The K-Pop Song of the Year 2024 Rate | #15: "Idk how viable her solo career is but I'm rooting for ha"

Slice of Life

Staff member
hmm

smg4-koopa-troopa.gif

Thank you for always commenting, my sister.


















































And I'm sorry that we're gonna eliminate another one of your 10s....

sad-stan-twitter-guy.gif















































87.png


87-run-away.png


7.20918

HIGH:
(10) @Ana Raquel, @eliminathan, @GeiPanda, @love choerry motion, @Macsun, @soratami, @tj-x (9.75) @TéléDex (9.5) @Conan (9) @BEST FICTION, @Oleander
LOW: (1) @mika (3) @chrisjche, @eccentricsimply
MY SCORE: 8.5

LEADERBOARD JOURNEY:
10 voters: 88
20 voters: 80
30 voters: 85
40 voters: 91
49 voters: 87
Damn, these back-to-back-to-back JYP eliminations? I'm gagged! After ITZY and NMIXX, it's time for a Twice-related song to go. The victim? It's Tzuyu's Run Away.

Run Away is the lead single of Tzuyu's debut solo mini album, abouTZU. It was composed by Andrea Rosario, Elsa Curran, Davin Kingston and Johnny Simpson with lyrics by J.Y. Park "The Asiansoul" (his words, not mine). Run Away sadly didn't appear on the main Circle Digital Chart but it did peak at number 22 on the component Download Chart. It did a lot better in her native Taiwan, reaching number 1 on the Billboard Taiwan Songs Chart.

Let's be honest. I don't think anyone of us anticipated Tzuyu to be the third Twice member to debut solo. Certainly not before the likes of Mina, Chaeyoung and even Jeongyeon, even though reports say she doesn't want to go solo. Personally speaking, even as a casual Tzuyu fan, I didn't really have high expectations for her debut FFFFFFF! Yeah, that sounds mean but she just... doesn't scream ☆SOLO STAR☆ to me. So I was very pleasantly surprised when I found myself really liking her debut solo song, Run Away. I mean, what kind of second gen bop, right?

I know a lot of you will (negatively) comment on Tzuyu's vocals and yes, I agree. She is not a strong vocalist and I'd argue her vocals are actually what's stopping the song from going from good to great. I feel like in the hands of a more capable vocalist, the song will really soar... especially that chorus. That chorus just screams ♛DIVA VOCALS♛ and sadly, Tzuyu did not provide that. Despite her vocal shortcomings, I still think the song works. The bones of the song are just too good, I fear.

Anyway, lemme take this opportunity to promo Losing Sleep, THEE actual best song on Tzuyu's debut mini album. Now that's a 10 9.5!

THE JURY'S THOUGHTS:
@mika (1): "Again, modern disco isn't cute"

@chrisjche (3): "Bland as hell - nothing memorable about this song and her vocal execution is so boring."

@eccentricsimply (3): "You know that sentiment of 'who's gonna sing?' that's been around since a few questionable solo debuts? That was my reaction to the announcement of her solo. And I'm sorry, I'm still wondering who's going to sing. She really has no range whatsoever and I don't think the song helps her much. I do like being proved right when I say that not everybody should be a solo artist, so there ya go. At least for that the song worked." [Slicey: This is sooooooo...... well, I don't disagree but still......]

@KimLippington (5): "A lovely 9th place finisher at Eurovision." [Slicey: Now why is Eurovision always used as an insult HASHFJGSJHF!! I can't!!]

@Salami (5): "Well she's not a singer is she. It's not bad but what's the selling point here? It's KPop on autopilot."

@savilizabeths (5): "The only song I took from this album was Lazy Baby."

@clowezra (6): "Bless her." [Slicey: Shady!]

@boom bazooka joe (7): "I'm still learning all the TWICE girlies by name, so I didn't realize at first listening to this that this was a TWICE member. I'm glad I looked her up though, because I realized that she was who made the biggest impact on me in the Strategy MV. My Taiwanese Queen! I don't actually love her voice in this though ddd, but the song is alright!"

@Joli Chat (7): "she would’ve done much better with an edm anthem instead of this, but she’s cute!" [Slicey: Give Losing Sleep a stream, bestie!! #promo #ad]

@aux (7.5): "This is one of those songs that I don't mind, but I don't really see myself going back to despite being a ONCE." [Slicey: Damn... this one gotta hurt!]

@Serg. (8): "She brought opera back in a way that we haven't seen in a while. Maria Callas was shaking and rolling at the range."

@Vixen (8): "It's cute. Her little 2nd Gen serve."

@Ana Raquel (10): "I know some people were reminded of the 2nd gen listening to this but the chorus is VERY eurodance/1st gen with a more mellow melody"

@eliminathan (10): "I don't think anybody could have anticipated Tzuyu to have the best TWICE solo. MISAMO will pay for turning Mina into a subunit act and not a soloist!!" [Slicey: Now why are you attacking the non-Mina MISAMO members, heaux! Attack JYP's ugly face instead!]

@love choerry motion (10): "My favorite Twice solo I fear..."

@soratami (10): "I know the girls are all doing all sorts of retro songs, but I love how this still doesn’t sound like what anything else is doing right now. An iconic debut single."



 
The thing with tzuyu is... I love her but she doesn't have the voice to carry a slow song or a ballad, but also does not have the energy to pull off something more high bpm nn I still think the song is not bad but something more autotune/pitch-corrected friendly would've been so much better for her, and us too!
unqualified-shoes.gif
 

Slice of Life

Staff member
The next 6 eliminations will strictly involve Superbloom Songs only.

Here are the remaining Superbloom Songs:

Balloon in Love - Sunmi
Blush - WOOAH
BT14U - Bébe Yana & Closet Yi
Bubble Gum - NewJeans
Butterfly Effect - ARTMS
Cherry - Gyeongree
Classified - Oh My Girl
Flower Rhythm - ARTMS
Full Moon (feat. SPACECOWBOY) - Kim Areum
Gone - SOLE
Heartstorm - Sorn
Heaven - Taeyeon
If U.. - JUE
Igloo - Kiss of Life
Inner Dance - tripleS Glow
IYKYK - XG
Last Drop - Red Velvet
Last Festival - TWS
Like It Like It - Twice
NA - Hwasa
NEMONEMO - Yena
NPC - The Deep
Official - ICHILLIN'
Pinball - RESCENE
Run For Roses - NMIXX
Sabotage - Kwon Eunbi
Smart - LE SSERAFIM
Sparkle - ARTMS
Strawberry Rush - Chuu
Supernova Love - IVE & David Guetta
Sweat - ZEROBASEONE
Unstoppable - Sooyoung

Why, Why, Why - Sumin & Slom


---


Which 6 songs do you think will leave us before top 80, unnies?

Come on, give me some new material to quote hehehe~
 

aux

he/him
Since the elimination order is a mess so far, we should get rid of "Why, Why, Why", "Heartstorm", that city pop song, Hwasa, the worst song that starts with "Super-" in the rate (by a lot), ZEROBASEONE, and the Khia of Life song.

salad.gif
 
he / they
Of those songs listed the next 6 ones on the chopping block for me would be:

* Gone - SOLE
* Run For Roses - NMIXX
* Classified - Oh My Girl
* Strawberry Rush - Chuu
* Flower Rhythm - ARTMS
* Full Moon (feat SPACECOWBOY) - Kim Areum
 

Top