#KS✿TY2024: The K-Pop Song of the Year 2024 Rate | #15: "Idk how viable her solo career is but I'm rooting for ha"

Slice of Life

Staff member
I fear a whole lot of you will be VERY happy with this elimination......





















































Definitely not me though..........


IMG-4497.gif












































































48.png


48-pinball.png


7.82143

SUPERBLOOM:
@KimLippington
HIGH: (10) @codecat, @enjoy, @KimLippington, @savilizabeths, @Slice of Life, @YRSHKD, @ysev (9.5) @Cotton Park, @Oleander, @vague (9.25) @askew (9) @Ana Raquel, @chrisjche, @clowezra, @leedlelee..., @Remorque, @thommyh
LOW: (4) @Sprockrooster (5) @Conan, @Joli Chat, @Salami, @Trinu 3.0
MY SCORE: 10

LEADERBOARD JOURNEY:
10 voters: 40
20 voters: 65
30 voters: 64
40 voters: 52
49 voters: 48
After 53 eliminations, it's finally time for RESCENE to lose their first of four songs in the rate. The victim? My sweet, sweet darling Pinball. Tragique!

Pinball is the second single from RESCENE's first mini album, Scenedrome. It was composed by Andreas Öberg, Maria Marcus and Felix Back, with lyrics written by Pa Ran (153/Joombas), Sun Hee (153/Joombas), Im So Hee (153/Joombas), Woo Seung Yeon (153/Joombas), Na Jung Ah (153/Joombas), bay (153/Joombas), Alphabet (153/Joombas), Lee Joo Heon (The Muze), Derful Kim (The Muze) and Andreas Öberg. Unfortunately for Pinball, it was totally eclipsed by her sister Love Attack so I don't think it appeared on any major weekly chart. A song for the arts and not the charts? Exactly!

I think this is the perfect time to introduce RESCENE as this is their first song to be eliminated... so lemme do just that. RESCENE is a girl group that debuted in 2024 under The Muze Entertainment which is totally a nugu agency. RESCENE is the only act currently under them and before RESCENE, they only had one other artist called CherryB, who is a soloist. RESCENE immediately made an impact... maybe not on actual charts... but definitely here on the K-Popjustice subforum. In 2024 alone, they sent three songs in the top 5 of our monthly charts (YoYo, UhUh and Love Attack), with Pinball also hitting top 10. Personally speaking, they are truly my rookies of the year. No other rookie act's music made my heart (and ears!) flutter the way RESCENE did in 2024. To think that a no-name rookie group under an equally no-name agency could release music that sounds this good... it was almost too good to be true but it's definitely true. We're not hallucinating this!

Pinball is my second most favourite song of RESCENE and it was definitely in the running as my choice for my Superbloom Song. Thankfully, I didn't have to do that because @KimLippington unnie chose it instead! We love a tasteful legend! No but even before Pinball got released, I was already a fan of RESCENE's music but this song... this right here was what made me laminate my RESCENE stan card. I was... simply shaken to my core on my first listen and I never recovered even today. Every time I listen to this song, I still get the rush. And whenever I listen to it, I always have to focus and, like, do nothing else but listen FFFFFFFF! This is a song that demands full attention and I oblige every single time. It's what Pinball deserves!

While I think Pinball sounds like a natural progression from the music RESCENE released during their debut era, I have to say it does sound like a more mature take on their sound. It reminds me so much of Red Velvet's more Velvet offerings. And you know me, a huge Red Velvet stan, so anything that sounds vaguely like them is automatically a winner in my book. The production, the vocals... girls, even the harmonies is giving Red Velvet. I mean, that harmonized chorus? I know a Red Velvet-inspired chorus when I hear one! Obviously, RESCENE does not have a vocalist on the same level as Wendy but you know what? I can forgive them for that. They still sound great and that's what matters. And they're so young so I know they'll only gonna improve from here.

I would've really loved for Pinball to go on further in the competition simply because it deserves to... but, meh, I can't really be that mad when RESCENE has four songs in the top 50 while others are huffing and puffing to send even just one to the upper half of the rate, kii! When my favourite RESCENE song gets eliminated though... I can't promise I'll be this chill about it, hehe~

THE JURY'S THOUGHTS:
@mika (7): "This is actually the only song I kept on this album" [Slicey: You kept the best song so lemme not attack you, kii!]

@Vixen (7.75): "It's cute, but 'Love Attack' outsold, I fear…"

@boom bazooka joe (8): "A bop! I don't know anything about RESCENE but I like this." [Slicey: Well, what are you waiting for, unnie? Do a deep dive now! They only have like twelve songs in total FFFFFF!]

@codecat (10): "This song sounds as if it was possessed by spirit of Red Velvet, GWSN AND Billlie (we love u Billlie even though you're not in the rate!!!) all at the same time, so I love it. Super fresh and beautiful. Wish it had a vocalist with a big V though." [Slicey: When The Muze Entertainment finally allows my girl Minami to do big high notes, trust it would be an earth-shattering moment!]

@savilizabeths (10): "If I thought I loved LOVE ATTACK, nothing could have prepared me for the hold Pinball would have on me." [Slicey: Right??? We love a one-two punch!]

@KimLippington (10): "Nugus of the year!"


 

Slice of Life

Staff member
This floppage needs to be studied.





























































IMG-5973.jpg















































47.png


47-gpt.png


7.84694

HIGH:
(10) @aux, @codecat, @love choerry motion, @TéléDex, @ultraviolet, @vague, @YRSHKD, @ysev (9.5) @Ana Raquel, @PopZeitgeist (9) @BEST FICTION, @clowezra, @He, @leedlelee..., @Slice of Life, @thommyh
LOW: (3.75) @eliminathan (5) @Salami, @Sanctuary, @Trinu 3.0
MY SCORE: 9

LEADERBOARD JOURNEY:
10 voters: 21
20 voters: 53
30 voters: 46
40 voters: 41
49 voters: 47
STAYC missed the top 30 of a KSOTY Rate for the first time last year. And this year, they just narrowly scraped the top 40. What the hell is happening in STAYC Land? Anyway, tonight, we say goodbye to STAYC's final song in the rate, GPT.

GPT is the lead single of STAYC's fifth single album, ...I. It was composed by Black Eyed Pilseung (B.E.P) and Flyt, with lyrics written by Jeon Goon. Unfortunately, GPT continued STAYC's run of singles that barely made a dent in the charts which started with Cheeky Icy Thang. It only peaked at number 165, making it STAYC's lowest charting single yet.

I feel like GPT is STAYC's way of course-correcting after the floppage of Cheeky Icy Thang. Released just four months after the latter, GPT saw STAYC drop the quirkiness of Cheeky Icy Thang and replaced it with... something softer and definitely something more public-friendly. I have to say, kudos to STAYC and their team for NOT going back to STAYC's more childish sound which they abused during Teddy Bear and Bubble. That really would've been the easy way out. And despite GPT being so different from Cheeky Icy Thang, I wouldn't call it a regression either.

It's not a sound that STAYC has explored in their previous singles yet. To me, GPT is closer to the sound of early Oh My Girl (something like Secret Garden) or even WJSN (I can definitely hear I Wish in that post-chorus). And unsurprisingly, it's a sound that suits STAYC very well too. And I expect nothing less from these versatile kweens. I admit GPT took its sweet ass time growing on me because by the time it was released, I was still very much obsessed with Cheeky Icy Thang. I love me some quirky STAYC, okay?! GPT only really made an impact on me during the voting period of this rate FFFFFF! I would've scored this a 7.5 if we rated this back in November.

My favourite part of the song is definitely the chorus. Something about the way the girls sing it just rubs me the right way, you know? It's so delicate, I feel like if they sang it a different way, something will break, kii! The post-chorus or the "baby I love youUUUUU" part continues to annoy me though and because of that, I just couldn't give GPT a perfect score.

STAYC switched it up again with their GPT follow-up single, the sexy and confident Bebe. And it seems like it did the trick and now the subforum is in love with STAYC again. Somehow, STAYC always wins hehehe~ Anyway, stream Bebe for clear skin, etc.

THE JURY'S THOUGHTS:
@eliminathan (3.75): "STAYC had a colossal fall off in 2024 cause these songs aren't anywhere up to the usual standard set by them." [Slicey: The way we didn't rate the actual bad STAYC single for this rate... yes, I'm looking at you, Meow.]

@Salami (5): "It's pretty cute but nothing special."

@boom bazooka joe (6): "I want to like this more but no." [Slicey: But why, sista!?]

@mika (6): "GPTified, didn't like it at first but cute nonetheless"

@Serg. (6): "They got so nothingy this year, god has forsaken the StayCnator."

@Joli Chat (7): "meet me at the gpt, gpt, gpt… Wait… :O" [Slicey: That's a different song, sister!]

@roblognick (7): "I think this would be nicer with a slightly softer backing track."

@soratami (7): "I genuinely always forget how this one goes when I’m not listening to it. I’m listening to it as I’m typing this, and… it’s cute enough I guess." [Slicey: Wait @ you not losing a high score in the last three eliminations!! You're losing a 10 next though ehehehe~]

@Crisp X (8): "The French sounding chorus still makes me giggle and I hate myself!"

@Vixen (8): "Sonically, GPT (very roughly) translates to 'I've farted' in French…..yeah…. yeah..... Poor jokes aside, this is nice. Very good production (that one flute-like synth that repeats itself is so lush!!), and also decent melodies. Miles above 'Cheeky Icy Thang', although I do think it suffers a little from the same issue where the chorus doesn't quite soar as much as it should after the verses, but this feels more convincing here and better realized? The last chorus really seals the deal for me. But they really should have let Sieun go all out instead of holding her back there." [Slicey: These French girlies omfgggg, I didn't need to know that pleek!]

@Macsun (8.5): "Wait..is STAYC back?!" [Slicey: They never left xoxo]

@savilizabeths (8.5): "A gorgeous mix of experimental and ethereal. It's like nothing else they've released. Admittedly, it took me a minute to connect with it but I'm on 100% on board now. The soft vocals are heavenly."

@clowezra (9): "A return to form and so close to their core sound I’ve been craving for years. Such a great year for them."

@Ana Raquel (9.5): "This might be my favorite STAYC release in... A while? Keep up!"

@ultraviolet (10): "LINK" [Slicey: This gif..... it's perfection!]

@aux (10): "Song so good it made me forget my hatred for AI assistants and generative AI models."

@codecat (10): "Another next level production from Rado, another masterpiece by the VOCALISTS of the 4th gen. The way Isa does the pre-chorus is so good on the ears. I listen to this and I feel like crying.......God is good. I love life" [Slicey: Wait, yes, spill! That Isa pre-chorus might be even better than the chorus actually!]

@love choerry motion (10): "The one good thing to come from that AI model, otherwise we're cooked!"


 

Slice of Life

Staff member
stayc.png


OVERALL AVERAGE:
7.76276

SONGS:

47. GPT - 7.84694
58. Cheeky Icy Thang - 7.67857

VOTER AVERAGE:
1. @TéléDex - 10.00000
1. @ultraviolet - 10.00000
1. @YRSHKD - 10.00000
1. @ysev - 10.00000
5. @codecat - 9.62500
6. @leedlelee... - 9.50000
6. @love choerry motion - 9.50000
6. @PopZeitgeist - 9.50000
6. @Slice of Life - 9.50000
10. @vague - 9.37500

11. @Ana Raquel - 9.25000
12. @He - 9.00000
13. @clowezra - 8.75000
14. @Remorque - 8.50000
14. @soratami - 8.50000
14. @thommyh - 8.50000
17. @BEST FICTION - 8.37500
17. @ohdenny - 8.37500
19. @Conan - 8.25000
19. @savilizabeths - 8.25000
19. @Wills - 8.25000

22. @aux - 8.00000
22. @ohnostalgia - 8.00000
22. @roblognick - 8.00000
25. @eccentricsimply - 7.75000
26. @Crisp X - 7.50000
26. @GeiPanda - 7.50000
26. @tj-x - 7.50000
29. @askew - 7.37500
30. @boom bazooka joe - 7.25000
30. @chrisjche - 7.25000
30. @Cotton Park - 7.25000
30. @enjoy - 7.25000

34. @Oleander - 7.12500
35. @mika - 7.00000
35. @Rhodanthe - 7.00000
37. @FunkyButChic - 6.75000
37. @Joli Chat - 6.75000
37. @KimLippington - 6.75000
37. @Macsun - 6.75000

41. @Sprockrooster - 6.50000
42. @Vixen - 6.25000
43. @Phonetics Girl - 6.00000
43. @Sanctuary - 6.00000
43. @ThisIsRogue - 6.00000
46. @Serg. - 5.50000
47. @Salami - 5.00000
47. @Trinu 3.0 - 5.00000
49. @eliminathan - 4.37500
 
he/him
Legit the saddest moment of the rate – and I thought Armageddon leaving early was bad! Crazy how they flopped even here…even though I understand some of the comments, I still enjoyed STAYC’s output in 2024 plenty! Rado is a phenomenal producer and there’s just something unique about their music that’s very rare to see in today’s Sweden/American writing camp K-pop landscape and it’s just awful that it’s not sticking!!! Everyone should be forced to listen to Metamorphic 9999 times in a row as punishment for what just happened!!!!
 

Top