Kylie Minogue - 16th Album

F

freelancer23

Raichu said:
Case in point: the reception to Disco .vs. Chromatica. Disco has its detractors for sure, but the fan response when it dropped was largely positive. Most fans seemed to think it was a fun joyful album. Chromatica's reception has improved with time, but when the album dropped, it was dragged. Both albums could have used more effort and both albums needed way more oomph in the production department, but Chromatica IMO clearly is superior in terms of lyrics, vocals, general songwriting (despite having a much worse lead single than Disco) and got a much worse PJ reception. Which indicates to me that Gaga is actually treated more harshly. Her fanbase gives her way less margin for error than Kylie's does.
Click to expand...

I think you overlook intention there? Kylie presented DISCO as a carefree homage to her favourite disco sounds; Chromatica had Gaga’s fans expecting a house masterpiece drawn from the trauma of addiction and grief with an overarching alien conceptual universe and got… that. And lots of make-up ads.

The point being: Kylie pretty much always delivers what she sets out to (Kiss Me Once really standing out in retrospect as an album/era which wasn’t offering anything really clear at all, hence the general indifference, probably) and while her fans may wish she would offer edgier things, they really don’t have the same justification to get narked at her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pdf
elektroxx

elektroxx

he / him
freelancer23 said:
I think you overlook intention there? Kylie presented DISCO as a carefree homage to her favourite disco sounds; Chromatica had Gaga’s fans expecting a house masterpiece drawn from the trauma of addiction and grief with an overarching alien conceptual universe and got… that. And lots of make-up ads.

The point being: Kylie pretty much always delivers what she sets out to (Kiss Me Once really standing out in retrospect as an album/era which wasn’t offering anything really clear at all, hence the general indifference, probably) and while her fans may wish she would offer edgier things, they really don’t have the same justification to get narked at her.
Click to expand...
Not sure what intention has to do with any of this. Just because a project does what an artist intends for it to do doesn't make the project above criticism.
 
Last edited:
F

freelancer23

I’m saying people’s criticism of Gaga was definitely more extreme than to DISCO, not because Kylie fans “put up with any rubbish”; but because Gaga hyped her album up in a kind of pretentious way that Kylie never would.
 
Celestial Mosaic

Celestial Mosaic

They/Them
I mean, Gaga did deliver what she set out to do with Chromatica though. The visuals might not have been as she planned but she had to change things due to the pandemic that likely had been planned for months before it hit.
 
Celestial Mosaic

Celestial Mosaic

They/Them
HEARTCORE said:
It's just boring hearing the same criticism of her.

Insiders indicates album direction -> "why not ___ part 2" -> first single release -> "this sucks" -> album released -> "awful album, she needs to push boundaries again"

Repeat ad infinitum.
Click to expand...
Comments like this are boring too and don't help.
People are going to air their grievances about Kylie and her music and are perfectly allowed to, just as people are able to praise her. There's room enough for all views to be said without the endless picking at one another. Everyone can just post their thoughts and leave, there is no need to read comments you don't agree with or to react to them. The way this is heading, mods will lock the threads and then NOBODY can post. None of us want that.
 
HEARTCORE

HEARTCORE

Celestial Mosaic said:
Comments like this are boring too and don't help.
People are going to air their grievances about Kylie and her music and are perfectly allowed to, just as people are able to praise her. There's room enough for all views to be said without the endless picking at one another. Everyone can just post their thoughts and leave, there is no need to read comments you don't agree with or to react to them. The way this is heading, mods will lock the threads and then NOBODY can post. None of us want that.
Click to expand...
There's nothing wrong with critiquing Kylie, but airing the same grievances, again and again, makes the conversation stale. We have had the same conversations about "Kylie isn't risky anymore" since...Kiss Me Once, I think? She has made it pretty clear that she's not going to deliver something edgy again, and I think anyone who's adamant that she will is setting themselves up for failure. I'm hardly going to bemoan the next single because "it's not Confide in Me Part 3!11" because it would be ridiculous to assume that we'd get that,.
 
Celestial Mosaic

Celestial Mosaic

They/Them
HEARTCORE said:
There's nothing wrong with critiquing Kylie, but airing the same grievances, again and again, makes the conversation stale. We have had the same conversations about "Kylie isn't risky anymore" since...Kiss Me Once, I think? She has made it pretty clear that she's not going to deliver something edgy again, and I think anyone who's adamant that she will is setting themselves up for failure. I'm hardly going to bemoan the next single because "it's not Confide in Me Part 3!11" because it would be ridiculous to assume that we'd get that,.
Click to expand...
So let them? Just ignore them, it's really not that hard. If you enjoy her music then that's all that matters, other people wanting more from her isn't harming you or your enjoyment. If the conversation is boring to you then maybe try and change the course or it or start a new one rather than moaning about it.
 
elektroxx

elektroxx

he / him
HEARTCORE said:
She has made it pretty clear that she's not going to deliver something edgy again, and I think anyone who's adamant that she will is setting themselves up for failure.
Click to expand...
Has she though? She literally said in an interview with Vogue back in June that she'd "like to make something like that ("Slow") again that pushes my boundaries."

And when we say "edgy," we mean "edgy" for Kylie. We're not expecting her to suddenly become fka twigs or SHYGIRL.
 
Celestial Mosaic

Celestial Mosaic

They/Them
elektroxx said:
Has she though? She literally said in an interview with Vogue back in June that she'd "like to make something like that ("Slow") again that pushes my boundaries."

And when we say "edgy," we mean "edgy" for Kylie. We're not expecting her to suddenly become fka twigs or SHYGIRL.
Click to expand...
Aren't we?
leespoons-kylie.gif
 
Celestial Mosaic

Celestial Mosaic

They/Them
soratami said:
I love how people always say it's perfectly fine to criticise Kylie but then get upset whenever someone does.

Anyway, what we've heard about Electric actually seems fairly promising so far to me. I'd very happily take a slick, well-produced, gimmick-free electropop album (emphasis on the well-produced).
Click to expand...
You’ll get 16 tracks produced on a potato with lyrics about magical sparks in the electric dark and you will deal.
And we will moan and prepare her for burning at the stake in order to resurrect IndieKylie
 
HEARTCORE

HEARTCORE

soratami said:
I love how people always say it's perfectly fine to criticise Kylie but then get upset whenever someone does.

Anyway, what we've heard about Electric actually seems fairly promising so far to me. I'd very happily take a slick, well-produced, gimmick-free electropop album (emphasis on the well-produced).
Click to expand...
There's nothing wrong with criticising Kylie, I just wish it was something different instead of the same comments about "risks" dd.
Like, let's talk about how her vocals are amazing live, yet we only get the same register in the studio. Her vocal chops have improved a lot (see: Confide in Me and Supernova live), and it'd be great to see her use those vocals more clearly in her music, like on Kylie Minogue 94. But instead, we get those high-pitched vocals instead, which is mildly annoying.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top