Not Joe Le Taxi, then?
Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)
- Thread starter P'NutButter
- Start date
he/him
Not even one 11 for that song? Somewhat surprised!
Of course that became a favourite too!
I gave 'I Should Be So Lucky' 10 and 'Je Ne Sais Pas Pourquoi' 9.5 but now wish I had switched them. I love the song but it does get repetitive near the end. Still it's incredibly catchy and has amazing moments such as the key changes in the verses, the pre-chorus and the middle eight.
he / him
I thought that it was widely disliked, so I'm surprised to see it go this far.
I cant believe 'I Should Be So Lucky' didn't get an 11. I probably should have switched my 11 to it.
He/Him
It is shocking that I Should Be So Lucky is out already! Both meanings!!
I'm sorry, but this is one PWL elimination too far. Without Lucky, and without Lucky being a success, than we may not have had Kylie still around today. Rightfully, still one of her signature songs, and it to be out before the top 50, well
(Even more so when Giving You Up is still here)
(Even more so when Giving You Up is still here)
I don't think I've ever heard "I Should Be So Lucky" prior to this rate, but it's obvious why it became a huge hit and one of her signature songs. It's extremely catchy and memorable, though I couldn't give it a higher score because it becomes so repetitive.
But this top 2 from "Kylie" is perfect.
It was my third favourite out of the remaining PWL songs, and the only two that should definitely make it to the top 50 are "Turn It into Love" and "Finer Feelings".
But this top 2 from "Kylie" is perfect.
It was my third favourite out of the remaining PWL songs, and the only two that should definitely make it to the top 50 are "Turn It into Love" and "Finer Feelings".
I hope my PWL #11, can very much hold on that's for sure.
I'm leaking 10's all over the place...
Giving You Up 8.15
Highest Score: 10 x 15 @P'NutButter, @One Stop Candy Shop, @Jóga, @m_dimitrov, @clowezra, @DJHazey, @hawkings24, @poshbabyyy, @tylerc904, @Ugly Beauty, @GimmeWork, @fatyoshi, @Verandi, @Remorque, @Untouchable Ace
Lowest Score: 2 x 1 @Daniel_O
@hawkings24 - 10 One of her best song in my opinion, it's criminally underrated and considerably homophobic that she only performed it on the Showgirl Tour.
@Ugly Beauty - 10 This song is such a trip, it may not be Xenomania's very best but it's pretty close.
@Verandi - 10 Sadly forgotten but what a perfect Xenomania affair.
@Untouchable Ace - 10 Genius. It's in the wrongfully undervalued & over-judged singles along with 'Fall To Pieces', 'Love Like This' and 'Power & Control'.
@Andsov - 7.5 I always think I like this less than I do. It's not bad at all, if a little too one-woman Girls Aloud.
@CasperFan - 7 Not classic and all but forgotten by Kylie-the b-side was far better. It just doesn’t really go anywhere but I don’t hate it.
@Hudweiser - 7 Always sounded curiously incomplete, but she only got one day to record it right?
@nanafan - 7 A forgotten single that is a good song. I think I may be one of the highest scorers of this.
@M24 - 6.5 It's not bad, but I'm not too crazy about it either.
@mrdonut - 6 I nearly creamed my jeans when it was announced Kylie was working with Xenomania but looking/hearing back, it’s definitely a case of ‘made sense on paper but paper only’ (exception to the rule being the unreleased Lovin' You of course).
.
Giving You Up 8.15
Highest Score: 10 x 15 @P'NutButter, @One Stop Candy Shop, @Jóga, @m_dimitrov, @clowezra, @DJHazey, @hawkings24, @poshbabyyy, @tylerc904, @Ugly Beauty, @GimmeWork, @fatyoshi, @Verandi, @Remorque, @Untouchable Ace
Lowest Score: 2 x 1 @Daniel_O
@hawkings24 - 10 One of her best song in my opinion, it's criminally underrated and considerably homophobic that she only performed it on the Showgirl Tour.
@Ugly Beauty - 10 This song is such a trip, it may not be Xenomania's very best but it's pretty close.
@Verandi - 10 Sadly forgotten but what a perfect Xenomania affair.
@Untouchable Ace - 10 Genius. It's in the wrongfully undervalued & over-judged singles along with 'Fall To Pieces', 'Love Like This' and 'Power & Control'.
@Andsov - 7.5 I always think I like this less than I do. It's not bad at all, if a little too one-woman Girls Aloud.
@CasperFan - 7 Not classic and all but forgotten by Kylie-the b-side was far better. It just doesn’t really go anywhere but I don’t hate it.
@Hudweiser - 7 Always sounded curiously incomplete, but she only got one day to record it right?
@nanafan - 7 A forgotten single that is a good song. I think I may be one of the highest scorers of this.
@M24 - 6.5 It's not bad, but I'm not too crazy about it either.
@mrdonut - 6 I nearly creamed my jeans when it was announced Kylie was working with Xenomania but looking/hearing back, it’s definitely a case of ‘made sense on paper but paper only’ (exception to the rule being the unreleased Lovin' You of course).
.
Phew! My lowest score left now gone. I don't hate, hate it (gave it a 4), but alot of Xenomania's stuff can be very hit and miss, and this alas, falls into the later category. Fair play (I think!) for it beating out so many other more well known songs though.
he/him
Well I mean it fared better than I expected it to, it should have stayed a few more places in my opinion though, it's a lot better than some of what remains
I do love her look in the video for Giving You Up, she looks fab.
Giving You Up 8.15
Is it bold of me to say that this is one of my favorite singles of hers? it feels more like a trip than a song but in a good way, oh I would've loved a Kylie album full of Xenomania-in-their-peak bops.
Also, Kylie is the only 'big pop girl' that Xenomania worked with right?