Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)

[Robert]

Come Into My World is top tier Kylie and deserved to last a bit longer.

I didn't realise she re-recorded her vocals for the single version though. Is there much else different between single and album versions?

 

[Untouchable Ace]

I don’t think there is any need to get personal, we are all entitled to our opinions, however questionable they may be

I'm sorry you've just had so much commentary near the bottom of each elimination that I've associated you with being an enemy to my favourites.
You have actually tanked some of my top scorers Fever, If Only and Come Into My World. But you have also given very middling scores to many other favourites.

I'm grieving losing all of my 11s here now.

But we can both have In My Arms & Did It Again though.

This is all just @Verandi/@Robsolete levels of banter anyway.

 

[Verandi]

Come Into My World is top tier Kylie and deserved to last a bit longer.

I didn't realise she re-recorded her vocals for the single version though. Is there much else different between single and album versions?

Both the vocals and the production actually.

 

[nanafan]

I'm sorry you've just had so much commentary near the bottom of each elimination that I've associated you with being adjacent to my favourites.
You have actually tanked some of my top scorers Fever, If Only andCome Into My World. But you have also given very middling scores to many other favourites.

I'm grieving losing all of my 11s here now.

But we can both have In My Arms & Did It Again though.

We were actually within a point (10-9) for the majority of the last eliminations (Your Disco, Timebomb, In My Arms, Finer Feelings Aphrodite, Please Stay) so I am a bit hurt by being singled out by you when it seems we agree on a lot of her tracks.

I don’t agree about Come Into My World, it’s one of my least favourite singles (great video though and the TOTP performance us amazing, performing an edgy remix!!!) and I’ve never been a fan of Fever but I don’t think I’ve been near the bottom of many songs at all as I love La Minogue.

The beauty of her catalogue is the diversity in it and we all have different things we enjoy. I lost many 10s early in but didn’t single out the voters who clearly prefer something else about Kylie

 

[Verandi]

I actually appreciate miss @nanafan for always providing commentary and not just tanking and hiding teebs. The real troll low scorer is another one I exposed a few pages ago.

 

[nikkysan]

The way this rate has completely unravelled in these last 20 or so eliminations...

 

[hawkings24]

Spoiler: hi

Hi all, just to remind y'all my 'Rhythm of Love' album rate is open! Please read the rules (they're more or less the same as the rules on here)

https://forms.gle/tPEd8YZMjDYvtfnaA

 

[elektroxx]

"Come Into My World" deserved Top 20, y'all. What are y'all even doing?

Also, I think that it was @Verandi who said this initially, but I need to reiterate that on a better album, "Lost Without You" probably wouldn't get as much love as it gets. That and recency bias has meant that it was always going to outstay its welcome, but it can vacate immediately.

I didn't realise she re-recorded her vocals for the single version though. Is there much else different between single and album versions?

The album version is a more straightforward vocal, whereas the single mix uses a more breathy vocal which she continued to use during the Body Language era.

 

[SlowGinFizzzz]

The way every version of Come Into My World is an absolute serve... Album version? Yas! Single version? Also yas! Abbey Road version? Orchestral yas! Fischerspooner Mix? Pussy-popping yas! That's an accomplishment. Not every song has that.

 

[tylerc]

Chocolate and Disco Down are absolutely tragic losses (catching up on 10+ pages) but I suppose it's getting down to the wire now. Lost Without You remaining is an absolute disaster though. Into the Blue too actually.

 

[Untouchable Ace]

"Come Into My World" deserved Top 20, y'all. What are y'all even doing?

Also, I think that it was @Verandi who said this initially, but I need to reiterate that on a better album, "Lost Without You" probably wouldn't get as much love as it gets. That and recency bias has meant that it was always going to outstay its welcome, but it can vacate immediately.

The album version is a more straightforward vocal, whereas the single mix uses a more breathy vocal which she continued to use during the Body Language era.

This is so true.

When you rate Golden you think ok this is a Kylie album this should have a 10 somewhere.
'Lost Without You' is the best song o the era, but compared to the rest of her discography...

 

[inevitable]

I didn't participate but my oh my how dirty a majority of Body Language and X have been done. A travesty.

 

[maverick_79]

I mean we’re close to the top 20 now and given how huge Kylie’s discography is, all the big hitters are still in, so I'm not sure why people are so shocked by the current eliminations.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

I love Come Into My World, my favourite Fever single.

 

[SloMover]

This rate...

 

[AGiantSheep]

I'm really surprised my Parlophone 11 has made it this far. I love it but outlasting Come Into My World (Album Version)??

(Cue @P'NutButter with the elimination in 10... 9... 8...)

 

[P'NutButter]

So, what will miss the top 20?...

Light Years 8.86


Highest Score: 11 x 2 @One Stop Candy Shop, @AGiantSheep
10 x 29 @P'NutButter, @Adora Day, @Jóga, @WhatKindOfKylie?, @m_dimitrov, @OSHi, @clowezra,
@Womanizer, @Fuchsia, @DJHazey, @mrdonut, @Reboot, @hawkings24, @WoW73, @Physical, @Andsov, @KingBruno, @Phonetics Boy, @VeryPSB, @GimmeWork, @MrJames, @IntoTheBlue, @letuinmybackdoor, @unnameable, @SophiaSophia, @Verandi, @Markus1981,
@MilesAngel, @Ana Raquel
Lowest Score: 4 x 1 @Daniel_O


​

@mrdonut - 10 One of the greatest album closers of all time, this I Feel Love-meets-I Lost My Heart to a Starship Trooper electro disco gem is everything a Kylie album track should be.
@Andsov - 10 Is this the best closer for an album ever? No, Fine is even better. Such a good pointer for things to come though.
@MrJames - 10 I just adore this. Pure Kylie with a capital K.

​

@Ana Raquel - 10 This not having a sample of I Feel Love i-
@CasperFan - 9 Amazing synth pop, what an end to her best album!
@nanafan - 9 One of the strongest album closers ever. KM Air, the place to be.

​

@Untouchable Ace - 9 We did enjoy, thank you.
@Hudweiser - 8.5 I know up until Golden she never released title tracks as singles but this could've been another exception the rule. What a great Donna Summer-esque bop. "My name ...is Kylie" gets me every time.
@M24 - 8.5 That beat sells the song. And Kylie's flight attendant lines too, of course.

​

.

 

[AGiantSheep]

I can't believe you didn't continue my countdown for that reveal.

Also this is exactly what I wanted to say:

@mrdonut - 10 One of the greatest album closers of all time, this I Feel Love-meets-I Lost My Heart to a Starship Trooper electro disco gem is everything a Kylie album track should be​

 

[Adora Day]

An absolute belter of a song! And the DBop Voyager mix SLAPS!

 

[Adora Day]

Seriously though, bugger off Kiss Me Once. This is crazy!