For me 'I Was Gonna Cancel' and 'Beautiful' are the definition of average. I gave both of them 5. Not horrendous but not particularly interesting either.
Last edited:
Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)
- Thread starter P'NutButter
- Start date
I'm gonna miss Telltale Signs. Kinda wish I'd overscored it now. I don't mind My Secret Heart and Heaven and Earth leaving, wish they had stuck around a little longer but then they were in my bottom ten or fifteen so I shouldn't be one to talk.
Wonderful Christmastime was an ok first elimination for the xmas album (and there's still a lot more that should leave soon).
Oh and if 90% of Golden leaves now, I will riot, @Maki. In fact I gave my 11 to a Golden song #oops.
Wonderful Christmastime was an ok first elimination for the xmas album (and there's still a lot more that should leave soon).
Oh and if 90% of Golden leaves now, I will riot, @Maki. In fact I gave my 11 to a Golden song #oops.
Oh dear. Looks like alot of people really didn't 'Enjoy Themselves' with that album...
Just 1 ballad left now from Enjoy Yourself. Although even I am not too worried to see that go...
I think the next elimination won't be from "Enjoy Yourself", because it seems like the remaining songs from it aren't as hated as the ones that already left.
But I presume/hope that we're staying in the PWL era for now.
According to the previous rate, looks like "I Miss You" may be in danger.
But I presume/hope that we're staying in the PWL era for now.
According to the previous rate, looks like "I Miss You" may be in danger.
Or maybe I'll Still Be Loving You.
I'll say now the scoring has been as divided as the opinions posted. Onto today's exits...
@Untouchable Ace - 7.5 She seems quite forceful and intense with her vocal delivery this era. I would have appreciated some delicacy and variation in subtlety throughout.
@mrdonut - 6 The ‘belieeeeve’ vocal at 2:23 is hilarious.
@hawkings24 - 6 Another cute track but very very 80s.
@MrJames - 6 An easy, breezy cheerful bop.
@CasperFan - 6 I remember Smash Hits saying this was the best song on the album-they were wrong!
@Maki - 6 This is just an okay filler track. It's relatively good for what it is, but not remarkable at all. The chorus is so lame and it definitely sounds like it was just additionally recorded to be plopped onto the album. Meh...
@M24 - 5.5 It's decent, but it's lacking the quality of the previous tracks (which were all singles? Whew, that's a classic singles run). Just not enough punch in the verses nor in the chorus.
@nanafan - 4.5 Probably the weakest on the album. Could have been any SAW act
@Hudweiser - 3 I never liked this one. Songs with overuse of 'woah woah woah' trigger me.
.
@Untouchable Ace - 7.5 She seems quite forceful and intense with her vocal delivery this era. I would have appreciated some delicacy and variation in subtlety throughout.
@mrdonut - 6 The ‘belieeeeve’ vocal at 2:23 is hilarious.
@hawkings24 - 6 Another cute track but very very 80s.
@MrJames - 6 An easy, breezy cheerful bop.
@CasperFan - 6 I remember Smash Hits saying this was the best song on the album-they were wrong!
@Maki - 6 This is just an okay filler track. It's relatively good for what it is, but not remarkable at all. The chorus is so lame and it definitely sounds like it was just additionally recorded to be plopped onto the album. Meh...
@M24 - 5.5 It's decent, but it's lacking the quality of the previous tracks (which were all singles? Whew, that's a classic singles run). Just not enough punch in the verses nor in the chorus.
@nanafan - 4.5 Probably the weakest on the album. Could have been any SAW act
@Hudweiser - 3 I never liked this one. Songs with overuse of 'woah woah woah' trigger me.
.
I Miss You isn’t the worst from Kylie not when I’ll Still Be Loving You exists and overall there are recent songs that are more unbearable than I Miss You. This tanking of PWL songs is quite frankly is preposterous get better taste.
Cute song, but can cope enough with it going all the same.
Oh and PS @P'NutButter , LOVE your Kylie era background graphic for the eliminations!
Why is this sending me.
.
"I Miss You" won't be, er... missed.
There are waaaaay worst stuff than I Miss You in her catalogue, but I should’ve known since it’s a PWL era song that it will get booted early.
he/him
PWL is either killer or filler there's just no in between