And here I was thinking we were friends!
Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)
- Thread starter P'NutButter
- Start date
And here I was thinking we were friends!
I agree, can't believe it's still here. As for Beautiful, I adore it, but at least it's not another PWL era song going.
Putting the stems of Beautiful into Audacity and muting Enrique improves the song a lot. I also became quite fond of it when Kylie sang it at the Commonwealth Games.
Where In The World 5.05
Highest Score: 10 x 1 @Gnuh Gnuh
Lowest Score: 0 x 2 @WhatKindOfKylie?, @SlowGinFizzzz
@nanafan - 9.5 A little throwaway but a nice new track on the album. I would have released this rather than Celebration or at least as a AA side.
@Maki - 9 The way the verses started, I thought I was going to give this song a 10 until it hit the chorus. Those harmonies are lovely, the melody is amazing and her vocals are gorgeous. It's so adorable and I don't get the hate for it at all.
@hawkings24 - 8 Honestly I love this song a lot.
@Andsov - 8 Objectively it's a shit song isn't it. I've always loved it.
@M24 - 4 This could use a remix. It's not bad but it doesn't pop off as much as it should. I guess it was never meant to do that, I guess.
@CasperFan - 4 Didn’t mind this when originally released but it has aged badly.
@MrJames - 3 A bit of a plodder.
@mrdonut - 3 Very much ‘will this do’
@Verandi - 1.5 Good grief.
.
Now this is travesty.
Okay, I knew it wasn't going to last long, but I wasn't expecting this to be out so early at all.
"Where In the World" is among my top 5 Kylie songs from PWL years and is a big loss.
There are tons of songs that could've left before this one and I'm afraid to name the singles I scored lower than it. I simply don't get the hate... How isn't that melody in the verses gorgeous and much more memorable than the majority of the songs from that period? Her gorgeous vocals? The key change? I'm remain puzzled and strongly stand behind the 9 I gave to it.
And @WhatKindOfKylie?, are you sure you didn't miss putting a 1 next to that 0?
Edit: looks like not, just saw you gave it a 0 in the previous rate, too. How's that?
Okay, I knew it wasn't going to last long, but I wasn't expecting this to be out so early at all.
"Where In the World" is among my top 5 Kylie songs from PWL years and is a big loss.
There are tons of songs that could've left before this one and I'm afraid to name the singles I scored lower than it. I simply don't get the hate... How isn't that melody in the verses gorgeous and much more memorable than the majority of the songs from that period? Her gorgeous vocals? The key change? I'm remain puzzled and strongly stand behind the 9 I gave to it.
And @WhatKindOfKylie?, are you sure you didn't miss putting a 1 next to that 0?
Edit: looks like not, just saw you gave it a 0 in the previous rate, too. How's that?
Last edited:
Oh, and...
Get. Celebration. Out. Now.
he/him
Damn, you know a Kylie song is shit when @WhatKindOfKylie? doesn't like it.
I removed Beautiful from my memory as it’s terribly phoned in and Where In The World deserved so much better it’s evocative of her first two albums for that reason alone I love it.
Some comments: If you were with me now was the first single by her that I didn't buy. I hated her doing a Whitney/Mariah style ballad. Leave that to them, I wanted Kylie to do great pop music and this was a dirge.
Where in the world I liked when the greatest hits came out but after not having heard it in years I realised it was dreadful, in a 20th place in Eurovision way.
Beautiful is a decent enough song that loses points by the vocoder but I can't envisage myself ever playing it again.
Everything else: Just beyond basic.
Where in the world I liked when the greatest hits came out but after not having heard it in years I realised it was dreadful, in a 20th place in Eurovision way.
Beautiful is a decent enough song that loses points by the vocoder but I can't envisage myself ever playing it again.
Everything else: Just beyond basic.
Finally something @WhatKindOfKylie? and I can agree on!
I think I've only managed to listen to all of 'Where In The World' about three times. It just makes my skin crawl.
I wouldn't call this a big loss (I think I gave it a 7?) but again there's waaaaay worst stuff out there in her discography.
Where In The World 5.05
Highest Score: 10 x 1 @Gnuh Gnuh
Lowest Score: 0 x 2 @WhatKindOfKylie?, @SlowGinFizzzz
Does 'Stop Me From Falling' have a key change? I can't remember. Something on Golden does.