I Was Gonna Cancel hadn't done too badly I think. And it's not too bad a bop either, when you take away all the various disasters that surrounded it, the low chart peak, Logies, THAT video.
Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)
- Thread starter P'NutButter
- Start date
Probably. It would just be a forgettable album track like... Sensitized
Kiss Me Once does have some very strong tracks going for it. The title track, If Only, Feels So Good and Into The Blue especially.
he / him
PWL stans stan everything from that era, tbh.
"Sensitized" is a cute little bop ruined by incessant "woo"-ing.
I genuinely forget that I actually quite liked the songs from the Kiss Me Once era until I list them. It wasn't a great album or album campaign, but it is quite a solid collection of songs.
Actually I take back what I said. I was gonna cancel is better than Glad To Be Alive. But then wasn’t that even pre- PWL?
I Was Gonna Cancel 5.93
Highest Score: 10 x 3 @SlowGinFizzzz, @Reboot, @The Hot Rock
Lowest Score: 0 x 2 @SinceYouTookYourPopAway, @Untouchable Ace
@Ugly Beauty - 8.5 I never understood why this is unloved here, is it because of Pharrell Williams producing it?
@Andsov - 6 I Was Gonna Cancel has a lot going for it. It's quite cool, and I like the rawness in her voice. But it lacks something to lift it from average.
@Verandi - 6 …the single release. Yes. Million Miles was right there.
@M24 - 6 I appreciate how Kylie went with something different here. Sadly I don't think I love the final product, though it's decent. The bells and then that post chorus are a bit weird for me. Also, that MV triggers my social anxiety.
@hawkings24 - 5 Bitch, she should have cancelled, I just do not like this song at all, it was a DISASTER and should not have been on the album, let alone a single. Pharrell's curse I fear.
@mrdonut - 5 Moto Blanco’s remix makes this much more bearable. I totally see where everyone was going with this but the lyrics don’t convince at all and you can hear in her voice she’s been crying. It really bothers me that out of all the Kylie songs to have as a lip sync (imagine On a Night Like This or Slow), Ru chose this.
@CasperFan - 3 Ugh!
@nanafan - 1 Abysmal. Shouldn’t have been a single and was promoted purely due to the producer. Least said about the video the better
@Untouchable Ace - 0 I generally don't like Pharrell anyway, so when I found out he made this... and that was the reason it was being pushes as a single. On top of that we have the hideous video.
.
I knew this was coming, I thought it may have been sooner ddd.
he / him
Some of Enjoy Yourself's album tracks and "Love At First Sight" (1988) are pretty dire, but maybe that's just me.
he/him
I know some of you have the stan goggles placed tight and an immense cloud of nostalgia surrounding these songs, which is why tens are being flung to the most basic songs imaginable.
The PWL era is the most asinine era in her career. The large majority of songs sounds pretty much the same, cut from the same cloth with tired production and same lyrical subject matter. The only moments worth highlighting in the PWL era are those moments when they went above and beyond in switching her sound to something interesting, like Finer Feelings for example.
Pharrell's style of production is an acquired taste, so I understand why some of you may hate I Was Gonna Cancel. I don't particularly hate it or love it. But (!) at least I Was Gonna Cancel has some flavour and it's something different in her discography, most of the PWL era can't say that.
This is the beauty of these rates. Everyone has different opinions and likes different things which is what makes the results more exciting.
It’s nothing to do with having goggles on. What some find basic, some find amazing. My scores are just as varied for the pwl years as the other eras.
It’s nothing to do with having goggles on. What some find basic, some find amazing. My scores are just as varied for the pwl years as the other eras.
Imagine!
What the heck?
Okay, I know "I Was Gonna Cancel" is very polarizing and was going to leave early, but not so early. And there are tons and tons of songs that should've left before it (mostly the PWL ones and the entirety of "Golden").
I gave it a 9, and it's my joint highest score from "Kiss Me Once". Such a shame that one of her most interesting songs of that decade is so snubbed.
Basically this:
I mean, if "I Was Gonna Cancel" was released by Kelis or Gwen Stefani circa 2005, you would've been all over it and you know that.
Okay, I know "I Was Gonna Cancel" is very polarizing and was going to leave early, but not so early. And there are tons and tons of songs that should've left before it (mostly the PWL ones and the entirety of "Golden").
I gave it a 9, and it's my joint highest score from "Kiss Me Once". Such a shame that one of her most interesting songs of that decade is so snubbed.
Basically this:
I mean, if "I Was Gonna Cancel" was released by Kelis or Gwen Stefani circa 2005, you would've been all over it and you know that.
Last edited:
he / him
"Time Will Pass You By" can vacate soon, but Impossible Princess shouldn't lose anything until the Top 100.
Just gonna quote myself:
I Was Gonna Bop should not have left as long as anything from Kylie and Enjoy Yourself is still in the rate. Somebody mentioned that it is a bit of an acquired taste and yes, I do believe that some of you should consider acquiring some taste.
I Was Gonna Bop should not have left as long as anything from Kylie and Enjoy Yourself is still in the rate. Somebody mentioned that it is a bit of an acquired taste and yes, I do believe that some of you should consider acquiring some taste.
You're all welcome.
he/him
I Was Gonna Cancel is a big surprise going this early. There are many other songs from that album alone that could've gone first. Pharrell's productions always get unfair hatred on this forum, I don't even think consciously about it being his or anyone elses whenever I listen to this or many other songs he worked on (or really in general), it's just a bop. I love the stylings and the vocal melodies. One of my favorites from that era.
Yes, recorded as one of two possible follow up singles to Locomotion in Australia, before SAW finally returned Mushroom Records calls.