Kylie: The Complete Discography Rate - Part. 1 The Albums+ (RESULTS! 2nd place & WINNER!)

[Maki]

Also, when is the "Golden" cull coming?

I hope that "Rollin'" marked the beginning of that cull. There are so many filler tracks on that album, that I've decided to view the album as a filler on its own. That's not very flattering, but quite a rare achievement.

@Verandi - 3 I feel like I've heard this melody at least five times already on this album.

This was literally my reaction to some of the songs. It's just a bunch of 6 and 7's with one or two standout tracks, but even these didn't receive a score higher than a 9 from me (or 8.5, if I recall correctly).

 

[MilesAngel]

I hadn't heard the entirely of the Golden album before the rate, so I didn't know there were songs that were only on the deluxe version. My two highest scores left from the album are those deluxe version tracks!

 

[Maki]

That Christmas song is cute, but I really don't have time for covers and therefore didn't rate it. It probably would've been a 6 or 7, because it's very pleasant.

Anyways, here are the remaining songs that have my scores lower than the current average score:

Spoiler

The Loco-Motion (this is still in?!)
Secrets
GBI
Sweet Music
No More Rain
Every Little Part Of Me
+ a lot of 6.5's that I'm patiently waiting to be kicked out.

 

[Verandi]

I hope that "Rollin'" marked the beginning of that cull. There are so many filler tracks on that album, that I've decided to view the album as a filler on its own. That's not very flattering, but quite a rare achievement.

This was literally my reaction to some of the songs. It's just a bunch of 6 and 7's with one or two standout tracks, but even these didn't receive a score higher than a 9 from (or 8.5, if I recall correctly).

Scream, I can't believe I agree with everything in this post.

Edit:

Sweet Music
No More Rain
Every Little Part Of Me

You had to ruin it!

 

[Touchofmyhand]

Lost Without You is an easy 10 and I thought it was the standard version's closer when I first listened to the album. It's that good.

 

[clowezra]

I’m a little late, but I’d like to say that I adore Mr. President, oop.

 

[Untouchable Ace]

I hadn't heard the entirely of the Golden album before the rate, so I didn't know there were songs that were only on the deluxe version. My two highest scores left from the album are those deluxe version tracks!

And that's one of the mistakes they made. Not including the 2 amazing bonus tracks on the standard album.

 

[elektroxx]

What we need is a Kylie Christmas cull, but because it was an optional category, I feel like some of its tracks will do quite well because the people who had the time to rate it clearly enjoy it.

 

[nikkysan]

The best thing I can say about New York City is this post when it was released.

Kuffie, sis, the synths...

 

[Crisp X]

Rollin' is Dancing 2.0, like this really should have stayed in the drafts, with the catchy chorus saved for another song.

Can't wait for Dancing 3.0 to depart next.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

I'm Gonna Be Warm This Winter, is a very good faithful cover. I like it, but it was again annoying how it was used over the Xmas originals on the promotional trail.

 

[P'NutButter]

Ooooh let's take it right back...

The Loco-Motion 6.52


Highest Score: 11 x 1 @Sprockrooster
10 x 5 @unnameable, @SophiaSophia, @Ana Raquel, @Remorque, @Gnuh Gnuh
Lowest Score: 2 x 2 @SlowGinFizzzz, @Andsov


​

@Sprockrooster - 11 It feels weird to hand out an 11 to a cover, but honestly Kylie made this famous from me. When I started getting into pop in the zeroes, Kylie was a high priestess for me and this track was an easy treasure from her then past days. Easy to connect with and consequently a staple till this very day.

​

@M24 - 9 I don't care if the lyrics are cheesy, it makes you want to do the locomotion indeed! It's not quite as euphoric as Madonna's similar groove dance tracks in "Madonna" (1983), so I don't give it a ten, but still give it a 9. Haters gonna hate.
@Verandi - 7.5 It's strange how the fanbase generally hates this, considering it sounds less dated than most of the PWL stuff.

​

@nanafan - 7 The SAW version is a massive improvement on the Oz original and the single remix is much better than the album version but I often skip it now.
@mrdonut - 7 I only really want the Golden/Glasto version of this song going forward. Can we have a studio recording please?
@hawkings24 - 7 I wouldn't choose to listen to this out of her discography, but when she did the disco version on the Golden Tour I just adored it, and that was a point at which I was tired of hearing it on tour, especially the Abbey Road version *eye roll*

​

@Ugly Beauty - 7 Decent cover.
@CasperFan - 7 SAW did an amazing job of reinventing a classic and Kylie has made this song her own. Always love the different live versions-toot toot!
@Maki - 5.5 Meh... I don't really like this cover. The song itself never did anything to me, and this one is one of the weakest renditions I've heard. It has good bits, but is way too repetitive and screechy at times, which can get quite annoying. My least favourite song from her debut.
@Andsov - 2 Incredible live performances over the years, but on record it remains a joyless mess.



.

 

[WhatKindOfKylie?]

I know this isn't a favourite with everyone. I more than get and understand that too. But, shall always be thankful for this song stating the legendary now FIVE decades music career of Kylie Minogue. A legacy in itself that.

 

[Verandi]

This was a cute retro moment

 

[P'NutButter]

This is also brilliant -

 

[clowezra]

Definitely a classic. I wouldn’t rush to listen to it in my spare time, but it is SUCH a joy live.

 

[madgemad]

The performance at Kylie Christmas 2015 is amazing. Those high notes at the end, chills.

 

[DJHazey]

Very glad that's gone.

 

[P'NutButter]

All I See 6.54

Highest Score: 10 x 4 @WhatKindOfKylie?, @OSHi, @unnameable, @Markus1981
Lowest Score: 2 x 3 @poshbabyyy, @Daniel_O, @Ramalama


​

@Verandi - 9 I still enjoy this! I didn't know people hated it before joining PJ.
@Holly Something - 8 Kind of sticks out like a sore thumb but it's cute.
@Andsov - 8 Such a random song, and so out of place on X. It's Janet Jackson rnb-lite tosh, but I've always liked it.

​

@CasperFan - 7.5 I like it but out of place on the album and should not have been a single!
@M24 - 6 I feel like I heard this before, for whatever reason. It's sort of fillerish but it's catchier than No More Rain.
@nanafan - 6.5 Pandering to the US but not a bad track. Very catchy.

​

@hawkings24 - 6 I dunno it's just a bit of a shrug, it's inoffensive but not one I actively listen to.
@Untouchable Ace - 4.5 What were they thinking?
@mrdonut - 3 Oh whoopee, another mention of the ‘DJ’. This track is so calculated and yet so messy. And that video, ugh.

.

 

[elektroxx]

I will never understand why this was chosen as the US lead single from X. And with Mims as the feature act as well, although looking at his discography, I guess that it'd only been a year since his first (and only) hit and he'd also appeared on a remix of Katy Perry's "I Kissed A Girl." It's cute, but unspectacular; I'm surprised that there were other parties interested in "All I See" and Kylie had to fight for it.