I guess it isn't too early to discuss LG7 but I need production like this. "Replay" just solidified how amazing Gags would sound in this realm.
I'm listening now. Wasn't feeling the Arca Remix... until Ariana's part came on, then it quickly became gorgeous and ethereal.
I know I already said it, but for me, Pabllo's vocal is the worst part about the Fun Tonight remix. The production style actually somehow suits the song, which I wasn't expecting at all.
The outro/buildup of the vocals in the "Rain On Me" remix feels like it's about to EXPLODE into something gorgeous, and then.... doesn't.
I threw the 1000 Doves remix into my editing software and bumped the key up to the original's (2 semitones). I love it that much more. Even in the adjusted key, it hits hard. Same with the "Alice" remix. The vocals in the original key just hits better. But I understand why they did what they did.
Amazing: Alice, Free Woman, Plastic Doll, Replay, Breebylon Good: Sour Candy, Enima, Sine Meh: 911, Stupid Love, Rain On Me (barely makes it this high in my rating) This is trash mawma: Fun Tonight, 1000 Doves Not even going to acknowledge that Haus thing.
The Plastic Doll remix could do without (Ashnikko?) voicing over Gaga on the entire chorus, would make it so much better.
I'm just so glad this remix album exists. It felt like this mythical thing that, like much of what Gaga promises, was never going to materialise. Yet here it is in it's spectacularly messy, chaotic and maximalist glory. There is a cohesiveness across it that I find astounding given the huge lineup of people involved in it's creation and almost all of them nail the assignment. Rina and Clarence deliver the Free Woman we all knew should've existed in the first place. Bree and Jimmy Edgar bring it on Babylon and even Ashnikko and Dorian (whose material has never really clicked with me) take Plastic Doll and Replay and dial them up to 11. I know this album won't be for everyone but after such a lukewarm era that only had glimpses of the brilliance that Gaga is capable of it's so nice to just be thoroughly enraptured with this. Now we just need her to work with these people on original music for LG7 and ditch Bloodpop and co.