Lady Gaga & Tony Bennett - Cheek to Cheek / Love for Sale

he/him
Let me buy a copy because I refuse to see her lose the #1 album to The Script of all people in the U.K.
085c1a145c07ba5a387dbcbcb642f06f.gif
 
This and Cheek to Cheek were weird for me. I've *always* adored music from the 20s/30s/40s. I adore Tony. I adore all of Gaga's albums. And yet I really, really don't like the way she sings this material. She completely nails it...but it sounds so forced and almost like an impersonation. That's about the only way I can describe it. On paper I should be all over these albums, but they leave me cold.
 

Lila

Staff member
This and Cheek to Cheek were weird for me. I've *always* adored music from the 20s/30s/40s. I adore Tony. I adore all of Gaga's albums. And yet I really, really don't like the way she sings this material. She completely nails it...but it sounds so forced and almost like an impersonation. That's about the only way I can describe it. On paper I should be all over these albums, but they leave me cold.

If I’ve said it once on this forum I’ve said it a million times: the issue is her phrasing. It’s better now than it was in 2014 but because she’s singing in a specific ‘tone’ (calling it an impersonation is less kind, though you’re not wrong), some of the most basic things she should be thinking about are just totally out the window. Sounding like a jazz singer is maybe the least important part of actually singing these songs, and yet it feels like the most important one to her. She sounds charismatic and charming, but the way she actually phrases the lyrics is just so wrong and it just throws me out of the whole experience every single time.

A great example of this on the new record is the intro to Night and Day. She sounds manic because she’s singing it all in one breath for god knows what reason, and then the contrast with Tony is so stark that all the chemistry that they do have just goes out the window.
 
Last edited:
Top