Discussion in 'Charts, rates etc' started by Maki, Feb 16, 2020.
I'm definitely team Brooklyn Nights, never got the hype for Nothing On (But The Radio)
Honestly, what a strong top 3. I'm team Brooklyn Nights too, that very specific second verse paints such a beautiful image and it's just a fantastic love letter to New York. Both it and Nothing On (and Fashion) are essentially Gaga, they're all parts of her DNA.[/QUOTE]
It gets worse:
Honestly, I think that guy should go for a brain check-up. Either he's incredibly stupid and jealous, or just wants attention. Or both. I can't find another option.
The sheer delusion and the fight for a crumb of relevance...
Which team are you? For those who declared themselves, the current collation is:
Team Nothing On (But the Radio): 2
Team Brooklyn Nights: 3
Team Nothing On (Brooklyn Nights)
Well... it has been a while since we had a tie at the top in a rate. Gaga having 3 winners in the next winners rate is justice also.
Edit: since the main winner was already represented before. She will only have 2 with a tie here.
Something very interesting happened, you'll find it out when it's time.
Also, let's spotlight all of Gaga's 'fashion' songs:
Fashion of His Love is such a bop. Love playing it while I shower.
Fashion! Is the superior Fashion bop. Followed by Fashion of His Love, Fashion and then Amen Fashion.
I'm sure that I've made my feelings towards "Brooklyn Nights" quite clear throughout the rate, so it should come as no surprise that I'm Team "Nothing On (But The Radio)."
@Maki stop stalking the X-Tina rate and post them results!
Well, I should probably finish the write ups before revealing the winner, which can take a bit.
And I don't know when they'll be done, so... keep waiting.
I'm Team Nothing On (But The Radio). I have not rated any song as high as that song
I love both songs but Brooklyn Nights loses a bit for the dated production. I felt that way since it leaked around ARTPOP. It never felt done. Nothing On But The Radio feels like a rush. It’s a shame that the version we have isn’t all her. It has someone else’s vocals in sections/backing vocals. I honestly would love for her second version to leak someone make it happen!
i'm team Brooklyn Nights ! Mmmmm the lyrics.
I'm definitely team Radio. And I'm pretty sure it's winning too, I don't really see Brooklyn Nights doing better.
The teams are now looking like this:
Team Nothing On (But the Radio): 5
Team Brooklyn Nights: 4
Team superstitious both: 1 (@MilesAngel)
By the way, there are eleven 11's left (@pop3blow2 found shaking), meaning that one of the songs got at least one more than the other. But is that song the winner? We'll see... soon.
Oh, and this:
The scores I lost are 9.25, 9.5 and 9.75, so you still don't know the winner.
I just love being awkward
I am so ready to see Brooklyn Nights being crowned.
Separate names with a comma.