#22/22
ROSA
8.111111111
My Score: 8.5
(@caladan, @Mirwais Ahmadzaï, @Remorque: 10) HIGHEST V. LOWEST (@Untouchable Ace: 5.5)
This is the last
Giedi Primes song to fall and it’s not hard to see why. That insistent bassline is an earworm and it’s
funky. Like some of you said in your commentary, the song is serving that indie rock band realness, but most of all it’s the cut on the album that best demonstrates Grimes’s ability to reference a sound and make it her own. The bassline may be the glue that holds it all together, but the keyboard/synth parts really give it a unique flavor. Then there are the lyrics, which are possibly some of the most interesting in her entire discography. They express the common theme of feeling different about a lover in the sober light of day in a way that’s fresh and narrative compelling. I also really love the melody, but I would have liked her to sing with a tad more enthusiasm. I don’t think the nonchalant delivery works here quite as well as it does in “Zoal, Face Dancer.” But that’s a small complaint. Whenever someone tells me that they don’t want to fuck with Grimes's early work, I point them to “Rosa.”
We’ll start with
Cutlerystradamus (9), whose prediction came true: “A sis served her breakthrough alternative rock band single! I know this will likely be the last GP song standing, and it's not undeserving at all! From the drums and repetitive guitar in the background, it is pretty accessible while still retaining the quirkiness of her early works.” As for predictions that didn’t pan out,
Remorque (10) didn’t think he’d like Rosa, but then lost his wig to her sorcery: “I never thought I'd like this as much as I do, but here we are... It's hypnotic.”
Sanctuary’s (6) wig, on the other hand, only twitches a bit: “There are so many bits in the musical structure that shine through, but even as one of the highs of this era, the execution loses the momentum.”
Earth Intruders (6.5) has similar thoughts: “To me this is quite reminiscent of her later pop work, but like many of her early songs it's content to just plug along without much development.” But enough about Justin Timberlake’s emotional/social maturity.
In other news, holy shit!
happiestgirl gives an early Grimes song a 9!: “I love this sweet little indie ditty.” *checks the new to see if there’s also going to be a solar eclipse* No solar eclipse, but
Xanax (9) takes us into another dimension: “The most pop song on Geidi Primes for sure! It follows a very clear structure and does such a good job at sounding familiar enough, yet taking use of the very alien/foreign instrumentation. This almost sounds like a Grimes from a parallel universe who is singing in an indie-band. The keyboard-solo is my favorite part of this!”
caladan (10) also loves the keyboard solo, though he doesn’t call it that: “Such a simple yet great song. That bassline and the singing are very catchy. Another thing that I love is that little instrumental breakdown. This is probably the highlight of Geidi Primes."
Mirwais Ahmadzai (10) agrees: “When I finally explored Grimes’ pre-Visions albums, Rosa was probably the greatest revelation. Unlike anything else on the album. My first 10 of the rate!” Meanwhile,
constantino (9) may or may not be lighting up while that funky bassline plays over and over in the background: “I forget how much of a curveball this is in the context of the album. I LIVE for an downtrodden 90s stoner rock ~moment~ on an early Grimes album.”
Trouble in Paradise (7.5) offends “Rosa’s” indie cred by referring to it as “jaunty”: The jaunty bass line keeps this moving and her voice stays close to center which lets the lyrics shine.” Last but not least,
Satyress (9) describes the song with the perfect marketing buzzwords: “Indie meets Electronic meets Pop meets French folk songs.” I hear French folk songs are the new up and coming trend in pop music. Perhaps Geidi Primes will get its summer smash after all.
YouTube Comments Section
Micah Buzzan: Each one of her songs is like it's own solar system of sounds.
andrea reyes: i used stick and poke to tattoo "ROSA" onto my thigh this song is the best
Sheldon Gregward: Helga Pataki from Hey Arnold.
SKIN
8.111111111
My Score: 8.5
(@Cutlery, @caladan, @Trouble in Paradise, @constantino, @enjoy: 10) HIGHEST V. LOWEST (@Untouchable Ace: 4)
Skin is a rather subtle song, so it took me awhile to appreciate its beauty. The beginning is deceptively simple, almost sounding like lounge music, but then it slowly unfolds into one of the most sensual songs in Grimes’s discography. The melodies are given room to breath and they work their way into your consciousness like a good massage. I also really love the transformation into a more synth-poppy digital sound, with the melodies becoming more chant-like. One of my complaints about
Halfaxa is that many songs last too long, but this song (along with a few others) shows that by
Visions, she was getting much more skilled at the longer form. The song is six minutes but I don’t find myself getting bored at all. Most of all, I appreciate the song’s sensuality. With the mostly non-sensual
Art Angels being her most famous work, I don’t think people appreciate that side of her.
For the second time in the rate,
Trouble in Paradise (10) gets vulnerable: “There’s such a foreboding moodiness to the verses that breaks into the aching anxiety of the chorus that speaks to my shakey anxious heart.” Speaking of vulnerability,
constantino (10) says, “Probably her most beautiful and touching song. The key is its simplicity, which allows the emotion and vulnerability to radiate and become the main focus. Gets me every time, and the length only makes it more immersive and easy to get lost in.”
Xanax (7) is also hearing the human fragility: “Such an alien ballad. It feels so sparse and cold…still totally relatable, human and full of emotion.” I totally agree about the duality between coldness and warmth in this one. It’s an interesting dynamic. For
caladan (10), it’s both emotional and hummable: “Even her ballads are very catchy. The instrumental is really good and her voice sounds better than ever.” The one voter not really feeling the emotion is
Untouchable Ace, who gives it a 4, but it’s not a total bust for him: “The beginning sounds like a demo with too much focus on the keyboard. Towards the end it gets better.” We’ll end with
Cutlery (10), whose rhapsodizing commentary suggests that this could have been in the running for his 11: “Grimes’ own and original spin on an acoustic ballad, the longest Visions cut soars through sorrow, sadness and rejection in intimacy. The emotional effect of the lengthy verses and choruses is maximized by the slowly-progressing melody in its keyboard and drowned out guitars. Lyrically, it holds a lot of raw power with lines such as “You touched me within / And so I know I could be human once again”, and Grimes’ high-pitched vocals only enhance the sense that she's running breathless.
Intense and flawless, basically.” As much as I appreciate the compliment, we’re supposed to be commenting on the songs, not the rate host.
YouTube Comments Section
Douglas Robertson: Claire must have been deeply hurt by a relationship....now she suffers
gender sisyphus: pretty sure this songs about gender dysphoria some how ;_;
sad bear: if you replace "soft skin" with "sasuke" it becomes a narusasu love ballad
This fan-made video is a choice, but your mileage may vary: