Madonna - Madame X

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not Madonna if there's no controversy. I'm really looking forward to Killers Who Are Partying. With all of this criticism, looks like it's going to be one of my favorite songs on the album.

I think it's pretty fucking awful that you can read the valid criticism of the song, criticism that asserts that the track represents a speaking over of minorities, and then say, "This is sure to be one of my faves." This before you've even heard a note of it. That's pretty gross IMO.
 
D

Deleted member 29801

I think it's pretty fucking awful that you can read the valid criticism of the song, criticism that asserts that the track represents a speaking over of minorities, and then say, "This is sure to be one of my faves." This before you've even heard a note of it. That's pretty gross IMO.

It’s no more gross than having major ethical issues with Madonna’s music but buying it anyway?

Also, why is it okay for you to make assumptions about a song without hearing a note of it but not Rafael?

I’m not being shady, I’m just playing devil’s advocate.
 
It’s no more gross than having major ethical issues with Madonna’s music but buying it anyway?

Also, why is it okay for you to make assumptions about a song without hearing a note of it but not Rafael?

I’m not being shady, I’m just playing devil’s advocate.

There's a huge difference between buying an album in spite of some problematic lyrics and specifically saying that a song will be your fave specifically because other people find it offensive (for legitimate reasons). The latter is childish.

Also, I don't have to hear any of the song to know that the confirmed lyrics are problematic. They are literally in front of us. But Rafael is only anticipating this song will be his fave based solely on the controversy, which is what I think is awful. It's flippant in the worst way.
 
Last edited:
Where can you hear the solo version of Crave? I do like Swae's backing vocals but just out of curiosity. Is it just that Swae's vocals are deleted or are they replaced by Madonna harmonizing with herself?
 
Where can you hear the solo version of Crave? I do like Swae's backing vocals but just out of curiosity. Is it just that Swae's vocals are deleted or are they replaced by Madonna harmonizing with herself?

They just cut out his solo bit. You can do it yourself in Audacity, and also half of her middle 8. The whole thing is only 2.5 minutes long, it's so lame.
 
Do we think Crave will get a tinsy little bitsy more attention once the album drops? I'm a little sad to see it no do anything at all. :(
Honestly I don't get it..... I don't expect it to be a number one everywhere but it's such a lovely song..... It's modern but not desperate, it's infectious, well sung, the lyrics are nice.... It's pop at its best made by a superstar, it deserves some sort of attention, or maybe my ears are totally wrong this time around
 
I think it's pretty fucking awful that you can read the valid criticism of the song, criticism that asserts that the track represents a speaking over of minorities, and then say, "This is sure to be one of my faves." This before you've even heard a note of it. That's pretty gross IMO.

You can think whatever you want, I think the criticism is blown out of proportion, so yes, this is sure to be one of my faves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top